Roshan Jamal e yar Say Hai ........

Speechless…What do you people get out of thses lyrcis.

Re: Roshan Jamal e yar Say Hai …

Not a thread for this section. I think.

The poetry is just so so.

There are a lot of “Tuk Band” poets in Urdu, this seems to be one of those examples.

Music is third class, sorry to be blunt. Composition is irritatingly slow with pauses. The string instrument is not tuned properly. With every vibration the strings bring many different vibrations. Sounds like…pun intended :)… the strings are a bit loose.

Only good thing is that Abida Parveen sang it well, in tune (sur) and controlled her voice well. She does try to sound like Persians for no reason. :slight_smile: