Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Every information which is against Bhutto is Non-sense and in favor is a truth :cobra:
I enjoyed comments on Youtube and i must say "jahanma main jao , Jahaman main jao ------ " 
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Another year passed , This year everyone here at PA forgot this day .
The day to remember for ever as a day to remember our mistakes .
We should think again on this all to avoid further mistakes .
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Not only Bhutto but all opposition parties, bureaucray, meida, and all West Pakistanis were supporting military janta of the time. Why do you exclude them?
NAP and JUI were willing to go and talk to awami league in Dhaka, so this is where we got Bhutto's threats against anyone who went and talked to them.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
NAP and JUI were willing to go and talk to awami league in Dhaka, so this is where we got Bhutto's threats against anyone who went and talked to them.
Yeah right. NAP than leader wali Khan was driving around in Dhaka with BD flag on his car, this was before BD came into existence. Bhutto's role cannot be justified however as they say in this hamam sub kay sub nangay thay, both political leaders and the army, the army being the main culprit. Read Ayub's book published well before the whole episode blew up, in which he talk about the agartalla case and when he called a round table conference the politicians told him that accept Awami league's demand and there will be peace to which Ayub said If I accept their demands "which Pakistan".
Lets not be blind to the fact that army was ruling Pakistan and despite how much noise Bhutto made if the army was sincere they would have transferred power to Awami league and let the politicians sought the mess. Why didnt they?
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Did anyone notice he actually did not listen to people and made his own interpretation of noise of crowd?
It appears people were saying something different and were standing up when he made his interpretation..but he made them sit down.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
it is same as when crowd of Liaqat Abad showed him shoes and he said " Ok Ok I know shoes are getting expensive". This was at the time when he did open ceremony of Liaqat Abad underground shopping place?
Need confirmation.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Yeah right. NAP than leader wali Khan was driving around in Dhaka with BD flag on his car, this was before BD came into existence. Bhutto's role cannot be justified however as they say in this hamam sub kay sub anngay thay, both political leader and the army, the army being the main culprit. Read Ayub's book published well before the whole episode blwew up, in which he talk about the agartalla case and when he called a round table conference the politicians told him that accept Awami league's demand and there will eb peace to which Ayub said If I accept their demands "which Pakistan".
Lets not be blind to the fact that army was ruling Pakistan and despite how much noise Bhutto made if the army was sincere they woudl have transferred power to Awami league and lwet the politicians sought the mess. Whyu didnt they?
Why didn't Bhutto prosecute any of the officers after the hamoodur rehman report? We had the likes of tikka khan who became staunch ppp jiyalas. Army had its problems but I wouldn't let Bhutto get off scott free. No matter the stroke of genius that might be present in him, his dictatorial tendencies which came from his feudal background led to his undoing later when his party unnecessarily rigged the 1977 elections.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Why didn't Bhutto prosecute any of the officers after the hamoodur rehman report? We had the likes of tikka khan who became staunch ppp jiyalas. Army had its problems but I wouldn't let Bhutto get off scott free. No matter the stroke of genius that might be present in him, his dictatorial tendencies which came from his feudal background led to his undoing later when his party unnecessarily rigged the 1977 elections.
I am not justifying his role but to say that he said "idhar hum, dhar tum" and Pakistan broke up. How simple and naive. It was much deeper than that. All I am saying is that all the politicians and in particular the army is primarily responsible for the breakup of Paksitan and to cover up their crime they pointed the finger towards the politicians. Why didnt Bhutto prosecute any officers? Has any govt ever had guts to prosecute the owners of Pakistan -- the army. Name one govt.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
allah o akbar…hindustan murdabad..after seeing these pictures of my beloved mujahaidin, my blood is boiling with passion…allah o akbar..i want to go and kill every hindu and hang pak flag on Indian fort and take revenge of 1971…
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Other side of story
Pak ex-General Khadim Hussain Raza admits to ’ 71 genocide](Redirect Notice)
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
jhoot boltay ho tum Pasha…cant you see the pic that I posted…kitna walwala hai hamaray mujahdin may…allah o akbar, difah council zinda bad!!! generel hamid gul and hafiz saeed zinda bad…
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Main nay to kuchh naheen bola
Please don’t send suicide bomber to me
http://sphotos-e.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc7/s480x480/3878_10151349995699919_1454376734_n.jpg
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
This was a blunder in which all (politicians and military) were a part of. Ayubs martial law laid the foundation, Yahya's arrogance and Bhutto's ego and hunger for power proved as a catalyst.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
This was a blunder in which all (politicians and military) were a part of. Ayubs martial law laid the foundation, Yahya's arrogance and Bhutto's ego and hunger for power proved as a catalyst.
Ayoub ,Yahya and Takht e Lahore mentality , The only responsible
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
I agree Bhutto had the Takht e Lahore mentality.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Did the general admit 3 million deaths because that is what the indian rag is trying to spin it as one.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
immediate reasons for the tragedy was poor response to the cyclone of 1970, refusal to accept the election results and postponing the assembly session followed by operation searchlight. Pakistan's military did horrendous things from march 1970 till the war break out. We all are guilty
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Why didnt Bhutto prosecute any officers? Has any govt ever had guts to prosecute the owners of Pakistan -- the army. Name one govt.
Imran Khan made a very significant and logical statement in one of his interviews recently. He spoke well of ZAB, and said that the guy had come in after getting elected (however that happened). And an elected representative, who is fair and just, always has a moral authority, and noone can ever question that. Not even the armed forces. It was on the back of that moral authority that ZAB fired the army chief, and I believe, the air force chief as well during his tenure. But later on, when ZAB got drunk in power, he lost his moral authority, which is when his own pet, Zia ul Haq turned on him.
So its not fair to say that noone has the guts to go after the army. Anyone can have the guts. Its just that noone has had any moral authority. Mainly because all our past politicians themselves have been standing in neck deep crap themselves.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto.
Re: Responsibility for 1971 tragedy
Just know this fact
After ten year of independence during 1956-57 , Total number of Bangali officers in all three forces , Army , Air force and Navy was less than 100 .
Thousands officers .
but majority was less than 100
85 % from Punjab mostly central and Northern Punjab .