Reply to Shia

salam alaikum bro pagluu

I actually had the original book version of this work it was green cover and published in NY

as u can notice its not a very referenced work but merely a polemical one which is a propogation of 12er viewpoint

more scholarly and referenced works ( which give a overview of early shiaism) by non-partisan sources if ur interested are these

Amazon.com: Shi’ism: Professor Heinz Halm, Professor Janet Watson, Professor Marian Hill: Books

Amazon.com: The Charismatic Community: Shi’ite Identity in Early Islam (Suny Series in Islam): Maria Massi Dakake: Books

to the aqeel123

my views are very similar to the companion Khalid b saeed radiallahanhu who told sayyidna ali "by God no man is more entitled to lead this community after Muhammad (saw) than you "
Same Khalid later gave bayat to sayyidna Abu bakr after Ali did so and was appointed to lead armies by him.

so dont confuse the early differences in sahaba at saqifa ( which were non-bloody at this time) as genesis of ithna ashari ideology

btw ghali is a term for extremist rafidi sects ..its not a bad word

Re: Reply to Shia

^thank you for the references. I will read them as soon as amazon delivers them.