Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

[PhatBalongri]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

*Why does it say Ali on it? *

[fallenpieta]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

^^ Exactly. Leave it to Shias to bring everything back to Hazrat Ali.

[Unkilon_ke_Abba_Jaan]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

Now, that gives a whole new meaning of Ghalib's shair:

Kabay kiss moonh say jao ge Ghalib
Sharam tum ko magar nahi aati

[bitter_reality]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@PhatBalongri

*Why does it say Ali on it? *

Because according to Shia belief Hazrat Ali was born inside the Ka'aba.

[Sheraz_CT]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@bitter_reality

Because according to Shia belief Hazrat Ali was born inside the Ka'aba.

don't forget a lot of sunni historians have also recorded it

so you see a name Ali (a.s.) on it and then just assume that shias are calling it House of Ali and doing tawaf around it..good job :) its really fine with us as long as you don't send one of ur suicide bombers there

[danial]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

no words,

[fallenpieta]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

I posted this picture here before and someone else posted the video. Except that I got warning points for it because mods thought I was being rude. Anyways, I'd like to see shias explain this picture.

Sunni historians have been misguided: Hazrat Ali was not born inside the Kabaa.

[bitter_reality]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@fallenpieta

I posted this picture here before and someone else posted the video. Except that I got warning points for it because mods thought I was being rude. Anyways, I'd like to see shias explain this picture.

Sunni historians have been misguided: Hazrat Ali was not born inside the Kabaa.

One of my Video where I showed a shia imaam slapping his own head also got removed. I didn't mean to disrespect anybody but wants to show what goes around in the world. Please allow freedom of speech as long as we are ethical and we dont swear.
Thanks

[Lusi]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

I remember is pakistan, this is what we were taught in Islamic Studies and I was taking sunni Islamiat.

[fallenpieta]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka’ba in Karbala

@bitter_reality

One of my Video where I showed a shia imaam slapping his own head also got removed. I didn’t mean to disrespect anybody but wants to show what goes around in the world. Please allow freedom of speech as long as we are ethical and we dont swear.
Thanks

Because its OK to offend Sunni but god forbid someone show proof of shia being caught in the act.

[Mr_Fraudia]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

bitter

I tink it got moved because it did not have much to do with this discussion but should otherwise not have a problem posting it because that is not derogatory or anything

[Naughty_honey]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@bitter_reality

Yes, As u can see from the video People are gathered around it. Basically, the Shias of Iran and Iraq are not very happy with Saudians and to show their contempt they have made their own Ka'aba the Shiite Ka'ba in Karbala. Be reminded that Karbala is a holy place for Shia's as Mecca and Medina are to Sunnies

this is not true.dont spread these false statements.

[Naughty_honey]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@Sheraz CT

stop uttering bull****..they are not doing Hajj and Mecca and Madina are the holiest places for shias...yes karbala is also a holy place for us...there are differences between shias and sunnis...so it doesnt matter if sunnis dont agree with shia practices

right

[Naughty_honey]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@bitter_reality

Take it easy man! the videos speak for themselves....as they say " Seeing is Believing" Proof is here...for all to see! let the people decide and enjoy!

how u prove the video is real

[Naughty_honey]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

@PhatBalongri

People are so dumb! Why does it say Ali on it? Thats pretty close to shirk, isnt it? hazrat Ali was indeed an important personality but kabaa with his name on it? I am sure if he himself ever say it, he would be really mad.

Its just like making Jesus God, you guys are no different.

use better language for holy sahabas

[Sadiyah]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

bitter_reality, get a grip. This thread's about the replica of Kabaa and not about Shia religious personalities, or other pictures.

Please stick to the topic.

If there's a need to address different issues and topics, then start an appropriate thread in an appropriate forum.

[Naughty_honey]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

un logon ko hadayat de jo fasad peda kr rhe hain inhain yahan post kr k

[bitter_reality]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

well these are all inter related. Making imitations ...making pictures and worshiping them....in my opinion they do have a link and my purpose is not to offend anybody but to have a decent debate.
you must have noticed that i have not used any bad lingo!

[Lusi]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka’ba in Karbala

@bitter_reality

well these are all inter related. Making imitations …making pictures and worshiping them…in my opinion they do have a link and my purpose is not to offend anybody but to have a decent debate.
you must have noticed that i have not used any bad lingo!

it is not interlinked, replicates of kabah, masjid-e-nabvi are very common,you find them on small and large scale in homes, masajids, etc
As far as the pictures are concerned, I think it is disrespect to those holy figures and artist(s) should be condemned.

[Iconoclast]

Re: Replica of Holy Ka'ba in Karbala

Fraudia has a point.

What if they make a replica of Kaaba in Disney Land, wouldn't we feel offended? I would be.