Religious Tolerance (Shias and Sunnis)

[bao_bihari]

Re: Religious Tolerance (Shias and Sunnis)

To start khoji, justification of killing any one be it sunni or shia is bogus. You tried to justify one in your previous post which was not right.

Now let’s talk about killing of Sipahe Sahaba terrorists. In a civilized society, no one should be allowed to take the life of another person no matter how many people that person might have killed. It is only the courts who have the right to punish any terrorist. But in Pakistan, the judges, policemen etc are afraid of these marauding criminals, and they let these terrorists go free because they receive death threats against themselves and against their family members. There are many cases of this unfortunately and it has been discussed several time here.
In such a scenario, some relatives of the victims pick up arms and kill those terrorists on their own. This is not acceptable in a civilized society,** but in a society being ruled by kharijis, sometimes this is the only way possible to punish them. It is for this reason that such killings of terrorists are understandable,** even though not exactly the right thing to do.

Having said that

You claimed that shias dont call rightous calips kaffir, i can show you many other evidences including the scholars that you have faith on( ghulam hussain najfi was very popular amongst current shia lot, principle of one the the biggest shia madressa in pakistan) .

Would i have mentioned this if you did not claimed what you claimed (and now proven wrong)? We are discussing religion, you brought this in discussion and now are unwilling to accept it. how naughty :o

How can we stop each other for killing? what do you want sunnis to do? whilst scholars amongst you keep bad mouthing/abusing personalisties dearest to us more then our parents?

Please think about what damage this thinking is doing, majority is trying to give as much relaxation as it can and just in turn require that you do not abuse personalities they love based on some historical mumbo jumbo?

My request to you and others is to analyse with unbiased approach. and not to claim some thing which you dont know about.

Lakum deenakum wali ya deen.

Leaving this discussion for readers to decide.

@khoji

There was a time when I used to indulge in religious discussions all the time. But then I realized that it is nothing but a waste of time. Religious people, all religious people, are just too much confused. People interpret things differently even when belonging to the same group.

So what you posted above is the opinion of some which others may or may not agree with. And I don’t have time to play the fruitless game of religious cat and mouse. I know some people, like yourself, enjoy this game, but I really don’t enjoy it anymore. Like I said, to me such debates are waste of time.

All I want to say about your post above is that Shia scholars do not consider any caliph a kafir.
And I am more concerned about killing of innocent people, then calling each other kafir.

---

Now the point you missed and overlooked was what I said later in that post. I had said that if neo kharijis are killing Shias because they think Shias consider the three caliphs kafir, then why do they kill Sunnis?
This proves this justification to kill Shias is bogus.