Re: Really black eye liner
many, many years ago…tried it.
for some reason it smears too easily on me…always ended up looking like I had two black eyes… 
maybe I was dong something wrong.
Hashmi kajal smudges!!! Try Urban Decay or even Bourjois Clubbing black eyeliner! Love the latter
Re: Really black eye liner
Revlons luxurious colour in black velvet is my fave. It's black black and dosent have any greyness to it.
I use this same one, and it is the blackest black! I use to use a Rimmel one, and that got discontinued. I bought every black eyeliner at the drug store and bought a couple expensive brands and tried them all. Back in university (oh gosh, Im old!), I used to use kajal - the old school one, in the pot with the stick! and I loved the way it looked, it was so black! But the powder used to spill on my face, essentially ruining my makeup.
So anyway...after the Rimmel one got discontinued, I tried all those news ones, and the Revlon Luxurious in Black Velvet gives me the most intense black. I totally recommend it!
Re: Really black eye liner
mac's pencil liner is a very deep black and goes on like very soft crayon. you can go over the line as many times as you want and it gets darker.
Re: Really black eye liner
I love Avon glimmer sticks liquid to pencil eyeliner in black!!! Its so dark!
Really black eye liner
Instead of hashmi kajal, get shahnaz hussain's kajal. Slightly more expensive but more dramatic, longer lasting and smudges less so worth the money.
They have a few vendors in us although I've always got mine in Pakistan. Seriously,I've never heard anyone whose used it have any complaints.
Re: Really black eye liner
Avon Supershock CB, £3 atm online.
Re: Really black eye liner
I have the hashmi one in the tube…I use the stick as a pencil so I don’t run it across with my eye closed. It’s pretty darn black. I have used it in the waterline and as an eyeliner on top. Its the one on the right in the picture below. I got a few of them from Pakistan quite a few years ago and they were super cheap.
Totally agree - it does smudge and is so hard to remove :mad: I don’t really use it anymore.
Re: Really black eye liner
Try MAC's black track fluid line gel liner!
Re: Really black eye liner
thats rigth cb… buy one of each the guppans have suggested.. and then write a review so it may help another guppan from wasting bucks in trying to find a jet black eyeliner in the future
(just not you) 
and my choice ofcourse
florelle eye liner. its super black.. infact i love all their eye pencils.. amazing indeed.
Re: Really black eye liner
Bah! I tried the hashmi kajal, koi faida nahi 
Re: Really black eye liner
tbh, i don't think really black eyeliner is for everyone.
Re: Really black eye liner
Ok guys , I went and bought the GOSH eyeliner … am gonna check it soon and see if its what I wanted .. waise it did seem really nice and black .. lets see .. 
Re: Really black eye liner
^yayy...let us know how it goes. i need a new one too.
Re: Really black eye liner
I think I said this before, but try UD's 24/7 eyeliner pencil in Perversion. I put it on my waterline, it's the blackest black i've seen and it stayed on all day...even till the next morning.
Re: Really black eye liner
Everyone always ask me why my eyeliner is so dark and doesn't smudge. Iv tried many liners but go back to MILANI black eyeliner pencil and I go over it with liquid UD perversion. The effect is amazing.
Omg... hashmi kajal.... i do not like it. Just bought some for myself recently when I went to pakistan... it smudges WAY too much.... its only good to use if you want a smokey eye effect for a function. lol. Then it works out fine.
Re: Really black eye liner
Ok so I have tried GOSH liner on me , since I bought it the other day and its awesome … I think it is really black … and its a proper kohl .. Loved it … and its not pricey at all .. thanks so much guys for recommending it 
I did try UD perversion as well and found it really good too , but I think its a bit expensive .. considering i have already spent so much money on expensive brands .. I think GOSH is a good one …
I have asked family in pak to send me hashmi kajal dibia .. I dunno why i do really want to try it out and see what happens
Re: Really black eye liner
Chanel’s Ligne Lines is quite dark and it has good staying power :k:.
Re: Really black eye liner
I just picked up black kohl pencil by Sephora (at the Sephora store). It's amazing!!! Really intense, highly pigmented and doesn't smudge or leak.
Re: Really black eye liner
urban decay