Re: real scenario: So you
Since I of course have a story for virtually every scenario - here’s one.
Couple married 20 plus years. In the first 1 or 2 years, they had a physical relationship, but shortly after she decided she no longer wanted a physical relationship. Couple is well-to-do, they ended up with separate rooms and lived very independent lives, more like room-mates than husband-wife. Almost 20 years later, the husband regrets not challenging his wife’s decision, he feels like he missed out on a more fulfilling relationship (they never had kids - wife’s choice, of course).
Now, he just turned 50 and they are getting divorced and she’s making him feel guilty (and he does feel guilty) for wanting more from the relationship
He never cheated on her, but the temptation was there - he thinks because he was tempted, he’s in the wrong.
So, yes there are some asexual people out there, but it’s wrong to marry someone who wants a more complete relationship.