Reactions to Indian team's exit from World Cup

Ian Chappell, the former Australian captain, has come down hard on Sachin Tendulkar, saying the time had come for him to consider quitting the game. Chappell said that the Tendulkar decision would be crucial as India try and rebuild after their shocking first round exit from the ongoing World Cup. Tendulkar managed only 64 runs in India’s three first-round matches of the World Cup, and couldn’t make much of an impact against Bangladesh (7) and Sri Lanka (0), the two games India lost.

“Before anybody else makes a decision on what will happen to Tendulkar the player himself has to have a good long look in the mirror and decide what he’s trying to achieve in the game,” Chappell, 63, wrote in Mid-Day, a Mumbai-based tabloid. “At the moment he looks like a player trying to eke out a career; build on a glittering array of statistics. If he really is playing for that reason and not to help win as many matches as he can for India then he is wasting his time and should retire immediately.”

Chappell went on to compare Tendulkar with Brian Lara, the West Indian captain, and pointed out how the latter hadn’t changed his style of play over a 17-year career. “This is a credit to his technique and mental strength, as the aging process generally makes a player more progressively conservative,” Chappell wrote of Lara. "Tendulkar hasn’t worn as well; his last three or four years have been a shadow of his former self.

Chappell took into consideration the slew of injuries that Tendulkar had suffered during his career, a factor that had forced him to miss a number of matches in this decade. “Tendulkar hasn’t been as lucky as Lara,” Chappell wrote, "the Indian batsman has suffered a lot of injuries in this period where his play has deteriorated and there is nothing that melts your mental approach quicker than physical handicaps. Lara has been relatively free from injury and he certainly doesn’t have the weight of numbers riding on his shoulders that Tendulkar does. However, the population of the Caribbean might be small but they are extremely demanding.

"Despite all the fuss and the odd controversy that has surrounded Lara’s career he has remained himself; this is my game and that is how I play. For whatever reason Tendulkar hasn’t been able to maintain his extremely high standards for the last few years and unless he can find a way to recapture this mental approach he’s not doing his team or himself any favours.

** "If Tendulkar had found an honest mirror three years ago and asked the question; ‘Mirror, mirror on the wall who is the best batsman of all?’ It would’ve answered; ‘Brian Charles Lara.’ If he asked that same mirror right now; ‘Mirror, mirror on the wall should I retire?’ The answer would be; ‘Yes.’ **

© Cricinfo: http://content-usa.cricinfo.com/india/content/current/story/287897.html

so true

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Spot on Ian :k:

Original article
http://www.mid-day.com/sports/international/2007/march/154464.htm

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Lara is and will always be so many miles ahead of Sachin.

Sachin may have been great but Lara is the true batting legend of the 90s.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Quiting....... I don't know, but he should be droped for now. May be some months down the line when he comeback he will regain his past glory. I think he is trying too hard, he need to chill out a bit and start enjoy the game rather than feel like a burden.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Tendulkar is India's David Beckham

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

You anticipating 250 million dollar deal in US for him? :D

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Without cricket Sachin is nothing, his franchise will evaporate and no one will want to associate with this boyish character who has no presentation skills.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

^He can become president of India

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

He has already made so much money...it is not about money...anyway, Ian is Spot On...Sachin has given so much to the game of cricket but may be he should consider hanging his boots....And for folks like me who saw him displaying his magic between 1989 to 1998, it is simply pathetic to see him struggling against average bowlers. Ian has made a solid point …..what exactly Sachin is trying to achieve by prolonging his career? Why to test selectors’ and Indian public’s patience? If his presence in the Indian team was equivalent to Lara’s in WI in terms of effectiveness, one could very well understand why he is still around but sadly; sachin is a total failure whenever the going gets tough. And now I have heard rumors to make him captain. That would be a disaster, both for Indian cricket and Sachin. Dravid should continue by all means.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

as put in by Gavaskar... make your personal records!

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Guys you don't get it. I think Sachin even knows that he's past his best but is merely prolonging his career for personal records. Lara (11953) is already 1200+ test runs ahead of Tendu (10688) and only a test hundred behind him. Lara is still good enough to keep playing test cricket for another 2-3 years. There's every chance of both those records eventually falling to Ponting though who at 32 still has 4 or 5 years of cricket left in him.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Tendulakar still has a lot to offer but he can't keep up with his past. Playing for stats only shows that a great player doesn't necessarily have to be a great person.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Tendu should play some more matches to recover his lost form & confidence :no: atleast for next couple of matches he should try his luck :teary2:

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Tendu, Ganguly, all should quite ODIs. Dravid should play with a younger side in ODIs.

‘Sachin, Look into that mirror’ – Ian Chappel

This article, was recently published in Mid-day, a tabloid having large circulation in Mumbai - Sachin’s hometown. A soft reminder for Sachin to figure out that even cricket followers in Mumbai are anxiously waiting for him to call it a day with dignity.

I guess, partly due to respect for Sachin and partly due to Maharashtra dominated Cricket board,no one in India is coming out and speaking openly against Sachin’s performance and future.

So, finally this Tabloid in Mumbai, decided to publish an “outsiders” comment!!

http://www.mid-day.com/sports/international/2007/march/154464.htm](http://www.mid-day.com/sports/international/2007/march/154464.htm)


If Tendulkar is playing to eke out a career, then he is wasting his time and should retire immediately

IN the fallout from India’s early demise at the World Cup one of the major decisions will concern the future of Sachin Tendulkar.

Before anybody else makes a decision on what will happen to Tendulkar the player himself has to have a good long look in the mirror and decide what he’s trying to achieve in the game.

At the moment he looks like a player trying to eke out a career; build on a glittering array of statistics.

If he really is playing for that reason and not to help win as many matches as he can for India then he is wasting his time and should retire immediately.

Super Lara

When you think that for a decade Brian Lara and Tendulkar went head to head in a wonderful battle of stroke play to establish who was the best batsman in the world, they are now worlds apart in effectiveness.

Lara’s quick-footed tip toe through a terrific innings against a good Australian bowling attack when the rest of the West Indies top order succumbed easily was in direct contrast to Tendulkar’s stumbling effort in the crucial Sri Lanka match.

Creditable

The amazing thing about Lara’s brilliant career is the fact that he hasn’t changed his style at all over seventeen years.

This is a credit to his technique and mental strength, as the aging process generally makes a player more progressively conservative.

Tendulkar hasn’t worn as well; his last three or four years have been a shadow of his former self.

Struggling

His double century at the SCG in January 2004 was a classic case of a great player really struggling.

He came to the crease out of form and despite amassing all those runs and batting for in excess of ten hours he was no closer to recapturing his best touch than he was when he started out.

It was a tribute to his determination but it was a sad sight to see; there are enough average players around that you don’t won’t to see a class one reduced to that level.

Injuries

Tendulkar hasn’t been as lucky as Lara; the Indian batsman has suffered a lot of injuries in this period where his play has deteriorated and there is nothing that melts your mental approach quicker than physical handicaps.

Lara has been relatively free from injury and he certainly doesn’t have the weight of numbers riding on his shoulders that Tendulkar does.

However, the population of the Caribbean might be small but they are extremely demanding.

Despite all the fuss and the odd controversy that has surrounded Lara’s career he has remained himself; this is my game and that is how I play.

For whatever reason Tendulkar hasn’t been able to maintain his extremely high standards for the last few years and unless he can find a way to recapture this mental approach he’s not doing his team or himself any favours.

If Tendulkar had found an honest mirror three years ago and asked the question; “Mirror, mirror on the wall who is the best batsman of all?”
It would’ve answered; “Brian Charles Lara.”

If he asked that same mirror right now; “Mirror, mirror on the wall should I retire?”

The answer would be; “Yes.”

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

we ve been saying he is done but the apparent fascination with him in india still exists!

Re: 'Sachin, Look into that mirror' -- Ian Chappel

Sachin is looking in the rear-view mirror instead and seeing all the lucrative endorsements that will go abegging were he to retire. The man has million dollar contracts with marketing firms. I believe he signed a three-year deal for reportedly 40 million dollars with Iconix, the marketing wing of Saatchi and Saatchi

And it also does not look like he has a future in the commentary box (not that it is as lucrative)......but I could be wrong there...since "eloquent" speakers like Kapil Dev, Waqar, Sohail, Srikkanth, Yashpal Sharma.....have been considered good enough for commentating.

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

Ehsan Bhi never agreed with me on who is better between sachin.....

Abb Tou Maan jaain, Lara > Sachin

and More Importantly Waqar > Wasim :D

Also Jhelumiz >>>>>>>>>> Lahoriz

Re: 'Sachin, Look into that mirror' -- Ian Chappel

some people shud stop *****ing abt him...he will hit a century in the next match he plays and everyone will be singing bhajans about him all over again!

Re: Tendulkar should consider quitting

lara is not bigger than sachin :P