Racism Vs Underachievement

Racism vs Underachievement

It is absurd to say that institutional racism is dead. It is still alive in the form of Islamophobia. . One of the deepest expressions of institutional racism affecting immigrant communities, and one that has been long documented is the unequal treatment of their children by the education system. They are motivated, but knocked back by their experiences of the school system. They are often treated more harshly and viewed with lower teacher expectation on the basis of teachers’ assumptions about their motivation and ability.

**LAs are failing in their duty to combat racism in schools, according to OFSTED, Education system exhibits “aspects of racism”. A quarter of authorities are not doing enough to promote equal educational opportunities. A Brighton University study found that the Britain education system is institutionally racist, with pupils and teachers vulnerable to abuse by peers, teachers and management. I discovered the element of racism in early 70s. National Curriculum does not reflect cultural diversity and minority pupils are being held back by native teachers. London Borough of Newham was judged by OFSTED as unsatisfactory in tackling racism. There are big issues about racism in schools needed to be tackled but could not understand that Bilingual Muslim pupils need state funded Muslim schools with bilingual Muslim teachers as role models during their developmental periods. It is a crime against humanity to deprive a child of his mother tongue but in the name of integration every thing is fair. Independent schools are also racist in nature. The parents of a Pakistani boy who was racially abused by his classmates and teachers are suing St. Christopher School. **

Education report by Birmingham Advisory Service recommends that school lessons should take into account cultural differences in order to improve pupils’ performance. It calls for teaching “the need for mutual respect and understanding”. Minority pupils are underachieving at school because the curriculum is racist. The study found lessons often failed to motivate or interest pupils because curriculum did not provide enough positive role models. The curriculum needs to be more balanced and less Eurocentric. Pupils grow up thinking there is no other playwright than Shakespeare. An ethnicity “Tsar” should be appointed to reform British schooling. Muslim schools performed best overall, although they constitute only a fraction of the country’s 7000 schools. Muslim schools do well because of their Islamic ethos and a focus on traditional discipline and teaching methods. They teach children what is right and what is wrong, because young children need structural guidance. Muslim school is responsible for the development of the whole child. Muslim schools give Muslim children “pride, identity and a sense of culture and languages.
Iftikhar Ahmad

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

Europe Racism is world known specially Britan where Pakistanis are treated as 2nd grade citizens , what new :confused:

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

What about racism in the so called Islamic countries. Why isnt anybody talking about it. One thing I have noticed is that muslims do get hurt very fast and scream of racism at the slightest pretext while they care two hoots for worse behaviour that is meted to people who visit the so called Islamic countries.

While in SA people are treated as slaves and nobody bothers. What an irony.

why is the educational achievement of indians in UK so much different than Pakistanis. They are immigrants, they are brown...

if we talk islamophobia, why is it that when the academiuc achievements of Pakistani origin students are evaluated it seems like ppl from certain backgrounds dont do well, usually uneducated millworkers who came from their viollages directly to mill towns in UK. Children of educated families seem to do very well.

go to any major British University and you will see Brits of Pakitani origins in large numbers, ranging from LSE to Imperial or oxbridge.

is there racism there, sure is, is there prejudism, sure.. is that the only or the major reason holding ppl back? I dont think so... but hey it sure beats taking personal responsibility.

reminds of of a family of siblings, one a doctor, one a successful business professional, one a well respected educator, and one who sat around blaming the system for being unfair and hanging out with the HT brothers.

Yet Pakistanis are known to treat the Christians living there as second-class citizens.

Have any of you ever spoken to Paki Christians living in the West? A lot of them don’t like Muslims, and wonder why?

Muslim countries have the worst in treating their minorities with respect, so until Pakistan has the courage to elect a Christian in their elections, I don’t think Pakistanis here have a leg to stand on when they complain about discrimination.

On another note, how come no one here cares about the discrimination minorities in Muslim countries often face? :rolleyes:

I have spoken to a lot of Pakistanis living in the West. A lot of them don’t like Pakistan generally. I wonder why!

A better test is interacting with minorities in Pakistan. I haven’t come across many who complain. A lot of hindus in Sindh are doing very well. They have some of the best brains and a lot of them excel in academics. A lot of Christians in Punjab are doing well in corporations and public service.

I have many non-muslim friends living in Pakistan. None complain.

The treatment of ahmedis in Pakistan has not been good at all for various reasons discussed in other threads though.

Well said. It is time that everybody decided growth is their own responsibility and act accordingly.

Maybe that's because there are very few of the them, and they don't want to be blown up or gunned down?

+1

I don't think I should bring the grisly photos of Shi'as being beheaded by the Taliban in Parachinar, should I?

Pakistan has a horrible record of treating their minorities, and for these same Pakistanis who support repressing minorities in their own countries yet whinge like little girls about the West is downright idiotic and pathetic.

Maybe if Pakistanis in the UK stop plotting to bomb civilians while living off of welfare, perhaps they could get somewhere.

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

^ Please give a credible reference to the 'horrible' record! I know Pakistan lacks on Human Rights issues to a great deal and that is applicable to everyone living in pakistan but the record for minority discrimination is at least not 'horrible'.

Shi'as are not minority because they are Muslims in the first place. We are not talking about illegal actions and sectarian violence. We are talking about systematic discrimination against minorities as a policy.

Taliban gave similar treatment to Pakistan Army personnel. Would you call it minority discrimination? Those who are plotting bombs do not represent Pakistanis in general. Those helping build western and Pakistani economies are in a huge majority and represent Pakistan. The Taliban militants are not Pakistanis nor Humans as far as I am concerned.

Please give an example of any official policy that would discriminate minorities in Pakistan. The two laws I am aware of are:

  1. Blasphemy law
  2. The president of Pakistan has to be a Muslim.

While the first one is controversial, and similar to 'anti holocaust deniel' laws in Europe and the second law is similar to what they have in USA.

There are quotas for minorities in educational institutions and government jobs (in addition to merit opportunities) and I personally know many people from religious minorities doing well in life.

But, I do agree that we talk up the racism that exists in the west.

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

its funny how muslims call out islamphobia but FAIL to recognize the insititutional racism and prejudice they hold about other minorities. like in gs people talking about how black woman are angry, how gays are evil, etc.

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

^ do you consider GS an institution? ;)

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

no, im saying that institutionalized racism exists now on all levels not just islamphobia.

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

Institutionalized racism? what's that?
Islamphobia is not racism. Its a psychological state. :D

On a serious note, I do agree that we have lots of prejudices. You do not have to go as far as Black girls or gays. We have prejudices against other castes, people from other cities or ethnic backgrounds, languages, religious/sectarian views..on and on......

What can be done? we are raised and trained like that. Centuries old caste/zaat system would not change in days. We can only try by educating the next generation.

Re: Racism Vs Underachievement

a LOT CAN be done. bringing light to our prejudices is just the beginning, educating ourselves, our peers, and most importantly our children about these prejudices is crucial to bringing forth a change.