Re: RaangaR kon hain?
But who are RanghaRs?
Ranghari is dialect of Haryanvi spoken in southern Haryana,such people are called Rangharis:)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
What is Hindustani? Is Punjabi also considered to be a dialect of Hindustani? As politically and historically I dont think this to be correct.
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
What is Hindustani? Is Punjabi also considered to be a dialect of Hindustani? As politically and historically I dont think this to be correct.
Urdu with lesser use of Arabic and Persian words :D
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
What is Hindustani? Is Punjabi also considered to be a dialect of Hindustani? As politically and historically I dont think this to be correct.
Dialect is spoken while when it is added with unique script it becomes language, Punjabi is a language as it has its own script. Hindustani is mixture of hindu,urdu and local words of the region of UP,Bihar,MP, it is dialect.
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Yes I have heard of Hindi, but this Hindustani thing seems to be different... :)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Dialect is spoken while when it is added with unique script it becomes language, Punjabi is a language as it has its own script. Hindustani is mixture of hindu,urdu and local words of the region of UP,Bihar,MP, it is dialect.
In India Punjabi is a language.. In Pakistan it has been converted to dialect in love of Urdu :)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
In India Punjabi is a language.. In Pakistan it has been converted to dialect in love of Urdu :)
Punjabi is written in Gurumukhi in India and Shahmukhi(urdu script) in Pakistan
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Punjabi is written in Gurumukhi in India and Shahmukhi(urdu script) in Pakistan
But Urdu script can't fulfill needs of Punjabi. (We discussed in detail earlier) :)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
But Urdu script can't fulfill needs of Punjabi. (We discussed in detail earlier) :)
Little idea as I can't write in either of script:)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
But who are RanghaRs?
They wear gheer wali shalwar and short kameex. :)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Little idea as I can't write in either of script:)
you can read/write urdu too?
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
None of Jats are kshytriyas, one has to be vedic tribe to be kshytriya, Khatri word comes of sanskrit Kshatriya while Jats are peasent farmer who sneaked in India during 3AD, held the arable land of punjab and haryana and later that culminated them becoming warrior during Khalsa time, All sikh gurus were Khatri but foot soldiers were mostly jatt, later Maharaja Ranjit singh was also one of us.
sneaked from where?
BTW even if they migrated to india wouldnt they still be ksharitya? varna system has nothing to do with your nationality right
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
sneaked from where?
BTW even if they migrated to india wouldnt they still be ksharitya? varna system has nothing to do with your nationality right
There were no battle involved in migration, secondly most of the scythian tribes, migrated from mediterian region. in strict sense, Varna system itself is vedic, hence one has to be vedic tribes, jats are not vedic tribe
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
What is Hindustani? Is Punjabi also considered to be a dialect of Hindustani? As politically and historically I dont think this to be correct.
Punjabi is a pure language not a dialect
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Punjabi is a pure language not a dialect
yes. Dil pe mat le yaar :p
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
There were no battle involved in migration, secondly most of the scythian tribes, migrated from mediterian region. in strict sense, Varna system itself is vedic, hence one has to be vedic tribes, jats are not vedic tribe
yeah it is vedic but is applies to anyone who lived here. those tribes adopted that system and made it their way of life. just like anyone got citizenship of india today would be an indian even though they are white, black or chinese.
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Punjabi is a pure language not a dialect
i dont know man. they say same thing about rajasthani as well and i tend to agree. it is not listed in languages of india.
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
yeah it is vedic but is applies to anyone who lived here. those tribes adopted that system and made it their way of life. just like anyone got citizenship of india today would be an indian even though they are white, black or chinese.
Not necessarily and now we have four varnas but many castes, highest of all rajput are chandravanshis as mentioned in RigVeda, one Chandravanshi tribe I know is Yadavs and they are backward caste now, none of thakurs will ever consider Yadavs their equal. Jats are farmer first, making them peasent class, warrior status came later, now Jains are as vegan as Pundas but still they aren't punda. Immigration of post vedic tribes had caused new castes in the system, but in punjabi society original Kshatriyas are Khatri, Jats are just peasent farmer caste:)
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
^Wrong, Jats came from Scythia and were warrior tribe(for that matter everyone in old days) who occupied the northern indian agricultutral lands. The locals in their varna system considered every invader as sudra. Jats were not part of the varna system of vedas anyway. This brings us to another topic, which is, why is varna system so strong in India even in this day and age while it is not in Pakistan.
Re: RaangaR kon hain?
Who made this thread like a Bollywood thread 