quick question

Society Religion & Philosophy
1

i jsut wanted to know whether any of u could give me a reference to where in the Quran it says that non-muslims cant visit the Khana Kabah..

nopes me doesnt want to start a war.. someone mentioned it to me lastnight, and i was just curious what the exact wordings were for it…

thank u :flower2:

2

9:28

Check this out

http://www.gupistan.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=153288

3

thanks Faisal :flower2:

just read 9:28.. “idolaters”, does that also refer to Jews and Christians?

4

According to the Hanfi fiqa interpretation of 9:28, the non-Muslims pagans are not allowed to pray in Khana Kaba, though they can visit. This is because according to the pre-Islamic tradition some of the tribes actually used to circle the Kabba naked & had other rituals that were deemed inappropriate.

There are also Ahadiths that show that when different crowds of people would visit AnHazoor (saw) in Madina, many of them Christians, he would let them pray inside his mosque.

5

i am totally against this 1, i don't agree with any non muslims being allowed to visit makkah and madinah or any other holy place inside the daaira of islam.

6

thanks ahmedjee… thats what i wanted to know. Whether, christians and jews are also not allowed to go to Khana Kabah

LUC, ur entitled to that opinion :flower2: i just wanted to know what the right meaning is