Question to Indians on this forum.

Don’t try to be smart dude.

Post the figures from 1947 time.

Jammu and Kashmir at the time of partition comprised of 77% muslims, 20% Hindus and 3% other mostly Sikhs.

…Jammu and Kashmir was ruled by Hari Singh, a Hindu Maharaja whose name was a byword for capricious, autocratic rule throughout the Indian subcontinent. However, the decisive majority of the population of Jammu and Kashmir consisted of Muslims at the time of decolonisation, partition and independence in 1947. Jammu and Kashmir at that time was approximately 77 percent Muslim, 20 percent Hindu and 3 percent other, mainly Sikh. Under the partition formula, Jammu and Kashmir probably belonged to Pakistan, being a territory with a solid Muslim majority. However, its ruler was a Hindu king who was above all concerned with preserving his own inheritance. He would do anything, including acceding to Pakistan, if Pakistan would agree to leave his throne intact…

The major basis of the Pakistani claim is that it was a solid Muslim-majority territory. The claim is also that, according to United Nations Security Council resolutions passed in the late 1940s, right after this drama, a plebiscite or referendum should have been held throughout the territory of the former princely state of Jammu and Kashmir to ascertain the wishes and allegiances of the people. The plebiscite was never held

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

I wonder why India sweats when the free referendum is asked for....;)

One can see the evil tactics India is playing to make muslims a minority day by day in these areas.

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

Hey atleast Azad Kashmir has the right to vote on its own issues. Does that happen in the world’s largest democracy? :hehe:

lol. Yes. Question rightlfullyy asked.

And so is the question asked by OP.

India has always dodged the international community in this regard making them look like fools.

which rights you are talking about?

when you cannot express anything positive about your country you should not find fault in others. You know how Pakistan has acheived the status in World’s top 10 failed states? bcoz people like you cannot produce anything positive to your country but can do only chaparr..chaparr online using keyboard

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

Yeah Indian sources uploaded on the internet are legitimate sources of information :rolleyes:

Why as an Indian do you visit a Pakistani website?

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

not a single one of the indians have answered to the question we asked about giving kashmiris a referendum to decide their own fate.

Getting desperate?

Discuss like a sensible person dude.

Abbe behra hai kya?????? how many times i'll tell you....cant you understand simple english...Kashmiri speaking muslims can shove their kashmir up their asses but only after giving kashmiri hindus their portion of kashmir.

ANY PAKISTANI WHO OPPOSES THIS WILL BE QUESTIONING THE EXISTENCE OF PAKISTAN

Prove what you wrote in caps on!

The condition placed on Kashmiries to give a piece of area to Hindus is deliberate attempt to not solve the issue.

P.S. Be civil!

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

He can't be civil. He knows he is wrong and has nothing to stand on. So he makes wild accusations that make no logical sense.

Kashmir is an integral part of India and will always be coz it was **legally **acceded to secular India by the Maharaja of Kashmir, it was Pakistan who invaded Kashmir **illegally **to capture it in the name of religion and made mess of Kashmir > Proof

As far as UN resolution is concerned it clearly says Pakistan has to leave POK first and only then can a plebiscite be held, now go ahead and set a good example for Indians

Without a proof if you come and shout again you will get only what you deserve for, a 60 years of thenga :k:

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

Can we see this Accession document? Where is it?

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

^ can be found here

Kashmiri speaking Muslims kicked out Millions of Kashmiri speaking Hindus out of Kashmir. When India got it's freedom, Hindus of India did not kick out muslims of India out of India. They were not kicked out of India to Iran, Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan. A separate land exclusive for Muslims was carved out of India. Kashmir not the Baap ki jageer of Muslims of Kashmir. It belongs to hindus of Kashmir as well. Any Pakistani who opposes this is not a Pakistani.prove you are Pakistani,by giving what you got 50 Years back.

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

every day they are killing and keep on killing, but for how long... ?

I just cant comprehend when can call themselves a democracy and yet deny people of Kashmir their right of vote.

Just let them decide, what the want. Lets have a referendum now today and the majority opinion wins.

Simple as that.

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

That ancession document and the whole deal is invalid, the maharaja had no right to give away kashmir to india. that was just plain wrong.

people of kasmir MUST be free.

Re: Question to Indians on this forum.

India was not divided into two halves based on majority hindu decision. If Morally bankrupt Muslims of kashmir cannot give Kashmiri Hindus their right of their land, they have not right to ask for it.
If you dont want to give, you have no right to ask. If you don't want to hear, you can't expect to be heard. Thats it. Period. End of story.

I do not think you understood what was written in post 81 and the link also provides the video of the writer.

The maharaja had no basis other than being an evil guy to accede to India at that time not following what the division of India was base on. Jammu-Kashmir had majority mslims and was supposed to be the part of Pakistan.

Then came the referendum issue in late 1940's. Which was never accepted and India kept dancing around the issue.

The last bold part of your like the rest has to be a joke, since India division was based on religious majority and hence Pakistan should get more instead of giving it any!

Keep writing funny claims however.

It was India who was/is morally bankrupt when it accepted accesion of Jammu Kashmir but forced Nizam of Hyderabad not to access to Pakistan.

Screw the maharaja . Why did not Pakistan force nizam to join Pakistan. Today you talk of two nation theory. But u forget Bengalis didn't care much about it. We don't expect pakistanis to care for minorities of kashmir. This is 2010, if Kashmiri Muslims want independence, they should give away part of Kashmir to their minority brothers. That's is the logical and only solution.