Aslamulaikum,
if any of you guys have the program End of Times by ARY Digital and Sadaf Stereo, i think they neglected the life of Hazrat Khizar a.s. and Hazrat Idrees a.s who in my thought are alive.
Hazrat Khizar drank ab-e-hayat and became got the life before qayamat,
but i think hazrat Idrees’ life and death is not clear i’ve read in a book that he was brought up from a mosque, and He is still alive.?
can any body guide me through this?
Yourz Truly
NAly
Where did you read these things?
ref: Stupid Idiot
from tareekh-e-Ibn-e-Khuldoon
a more realistic belief is that hazrat khizr and hazrat idrees (as) r not alive and the stories r just made up....
i personally see no reason why they shud be alive....
Allah knows the best....
ref: Hazrat Khizar
I think hazrat idrees might be dead because there no solid proof!
but hazrat khizar's Aive because he drank Ab-e-Hayat
And got life till qaiyamat!
Well where does it say that he drank Abe-Hayat?
What's the source of your information?
Re: ref: Hazrat Khizar
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by SpyGuy: *
I think hazrat idrees might be dead because there no solid proof!
but hazrat khizar's Aive because he drank Ab-e-Hayat
And got life till qaiyamat!
[/QUOTE]
Quran says clearly that every soul has to taste death....
see verses 3:185, 21:35, 29:57....
so where does the concept of anything called "aab-e-hayaat" come from????
Re: Re: ref: Hazrat Khizar
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by armughal: *
Quran says clearly that every soul has to taste death....
see verses 3:185, 21:35, 29:57....
[/QUOTE]
Not sure the concept is right and wrong but way of refuting is absolutely not correct. How these verses show that Hazrat Khizar (AS) is dead now. Life can be long or short; after all there is death to everything you can see or you cant see with your eyes but Allah. If you apply these verses to shorten the age of Hazrat Khizar (AS). Why don’t you apply on the age of Prophet Isa (AS)?
Did you read “And got life till qaiyamat!” He never said that Khizar will never die!
We should have a broader vision. If there is God; He can Do.
He did or not this is another question. That is why your 2nd question is logical.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by armughal: *
so where does the concept of anything called "aab-e-hayaat" come from????
[/QUOTE]
^^ I second that.
This is possible that Khizar :as: is alive. I heard that he appeared in Mosa :as: and some other prophet’s era as well
The concept of 'Abe-Hayat' has it's origin in Christian belief. Where, some Christians believe that if you drink from the 'cup of the carpenter' (Jesus a.s) you will have eternal life.
[quote]
I think hazrat idrees might be dead because there no solid proof!
but hazrat khizar's Aive because he drank Ab-e-Hayat
And got life till qaiyamat!
[/quote]
You see my brother ibn khuldoon did recieved the revalation, so he must have quoted some other refference try to get to that. The only two source that you can reffer to on religious things are Quran & Sunnah [hadith] Besides you may want to answer the question asked by the brother:
[quote]
so where does the concept of anything called "aab-e-hayaat" come from????
[/quote]
[quote]
If you apply these verses to shorten the age of Hazrat Khizar (AS). Why don’t you apply on the age of Prophet Isa (AS)?
[/quote]
nice point