Anyone ever wonder if the lot suffered psychologically imbalances? Perhapes suffering from delusions of grandeur or just psychotic delusions?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
I believe only those who claimed to be prophet but were not prophet may have suffered with Schizophrenia.
And I believe that From Adam:as: to Noah:as: to Ibaraheem:as: to Mosa:as: to Isa(Jesus):as: to Muhammad:saw: were all true Prophets of Allah:swt:
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
Well that's convenient.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
Well they sure accomplished a lot despite being supposedly schizophrenic.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
Have you seen the movie A Beautiful Mind?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
No, I have seen the Movie "The Message"
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
yes, I have. Your point? Or are you implying a mathmetician has accomplished something even remotely comparable to a prophet?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
I mentioned 'A Beautiful Mind' for skhana sake. A true story of a brilliant and accomplished mathematician who suffered from Schizophrenia.
.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
and point is?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
My point is that one can be mentally unsound and be ‘accomplished’. In the case of Prophets such a disability would actually help them in what they did.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
I see you believe in a movie.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
Now your not making any sense, explain yourself.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
this whole thread is ridiculous and pointless
first all prophets are accused to be mentally unstable and now a mathmatician is the same as a prophet?
a little too much to drink tonight?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
It’s called Schizophrenia 
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
First off, I haven't accused anyone of anything.
Second Skhan, "prophets' are mortal men, you do understand that don't you?
No drinking here friend, yourself?
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
If you two can't deal with the topic then leave the thread.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
right
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
“Anyone ever wonder”
No kidding I’m right. Does such questioning of this possibility shake your foundation that much that you are threaten by it? I highly doubt that so back onto topic please.
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
No lets have some fun.
You start off with this.
Anyone wonder? Nope not me. Do you? If yes, then why?
Mathmaticians. Mortal? Yes. Can do calculus? Yes. Reveal divine scriptures and define the life of billions? No.
Prophets. Mortal? Yes. Then again I am a Muslim, others might differ
Re: Prophets & Schizophrenia
69:38 So I do call to witness what ye see,
69:39 And what ye see not,
69:40 That this is verily the word of an honoured apostle;
69:41 It is not the word of a poet: little it is ye believe!
69:42 Nor is it the word of a soothsayer: little admonition it is ye receive.
69:43 (This is) a Message sent down from the Lord of the Worlds.
]69:44 And if the apostle were to invent any sayings in Our name,
69:45 We should certainly seize him by his right hand,
69:46 **And We should certainly then cut off the artery of his heart: **
69:47 Nor could any of you withhold him (from Our wrath).
69:48 But verily this is a Message for the Allah.fearing.
69:49 And We certainly know that there are amongst you those that reject (it).
69:50 But truly (Revelation) is a cause of sorrow for the Unbelievers.
69:51 But verily it is Truth of assured certainty.
69:52 So glorify the name of thy Lord Most High.