Re: Pratibha Patil - First Women President of India
[quote]
dadiamma sounds like the perfect spineless president so far.
[/quote]
Think you have not heard of VV Giri or some other idiot who signed the declaration of emergency from his bathtub .
Or Zail Singh who did not even know what he was talking about.
Re: Pratibha Patil - First Women President of India
Women on top? Poof!
26 Jul 2007, 0015 hrs IST,Diya Sengupta
So we finally have a woman as president. Big deal. While announcing Pratibha Patil’s candidature, Sonia Gandhi hailed her nomination as a “historic occasion”.
According to the ever-delightful Sonia, it was a true symbol of women’s empowerment in India. Yes, she really thinks we are stupid enough to buy that line! Truth be told, one was downright disgusted, and insulted, when a woman as president of India was equated with the overall empowerment of women in the country.
It is obvious that Pratibha emerged as the top choice mainly due to her loyalty to Gandhi-Nehru family. That, along with the fact that she was a compromise candidate, what with the Left sticking to its guns and spiking the candidature of other pros-pective candidates.
The presidential post is merely a ceremonial one in India. Real executive powers are vested in the council of ministers, headed by the prime minister. Thus, it is clear that the only ones who will benefit from Pratibha the president is the UPA government and not the women of India.
On another note, it wouldn’t be far-fetched to compare a woman president with the common women of India. Women in our land have been worshipped as Durga, Saraswati and what not. The bahu’ of the house is called ghar ki Lakshmi’.
To an outsider it would seem that the women of India enjoy high status and respect, equalled only by the reverence we reserve for our gods. And they do, but only in name. On one hand, we Indians chant various incantations praising women and on the other, we feel no qualms in suppressing them in more ways than can be counted. The same ghar ki Lakshmi’ is beaten to pulp if she fails to bring a hefty dowry or bear a boy child.
And that is just one example of the many atrocities inflicted upon women. Women in India, like the president, have a ceremonial high post in society. Go ahead, fete Pratibha on her victory. Just don’t call it women’s empowerment. It is a symbolic sham and means very little.
Re: Pratibha Patil - First Women President of India
Is Patil the right leader for India?
By Vishakha Desai
Sunday, Jul 29, 2007, Page 9
`Gestures cannot be a substitute for real action, or for the hard work that is necessary to empower all Indian women.’
As the US debates its readiness to accept a woman such as Hillary Clinton as president, India has already done so, with the election of Pratibha Patil. Although in India the presidency is primarily a ceremonial post that carries less weight than that of prime minister (the position once held by Indira Gandhi), it is symbolically significant. Sonia Gandhi, the leader of the ruling Congress Party, who pushed hard to promote Patil’s candidacy primarily on gender grounds, calls this election “a special moment for women across the country.”
Moreover, India can claim a great deal of pride in the fact that the last two presidents were from minority populations – one from the lowest of castes (Harijan, formerly referred to as “untouchables”) and another one from the Muslim community.
As a daughter of a woman who fought for women’s rights during the independence movement and was instrumental in starting one of the first women’s institutions in India, I should feel a genuine sense of pride in the election of Patil.
But I have mixed emotions.
Both of India’s last two presidents had distinguished themselves in professional careers before being elected – one in the Foreign Service and the other in nuclear physics – and their reputations were above reproach. Patil, on the other hand, is a controversial figure, with questionable qualifications. Most of India’s major news outlets highlighted in their coverage of the story charges of corruption and ineptitude. One well-respected publication even called Patil’s selection “embarrassing.”
Women hear over and over that we have to be twice as good as men to be perceived as successful, deserving leaders. Even if we disregard some of the accusations against Patil as baseless, it is hard to imagine a less powerful candidate for the highest ceremonial post in the largest democracy in the world.
All the same, I applaud Sonia Gandhi for her commitment to appointing a woman to this important position. In a country full of contradictory attitudes toward women – ranging from the worship of the powerful goddess Durga to the killing of innocent young brides – such gestures can be very powerful.
But gestures cannot be a substitute for real action, or for the hard work that is necessary to empower all Indian women. Indeed, one could argue that such symbolic acts may even create a blind euphoria that obscures the fact that, as a result of less education and lower pay, young females in India continue to have far fewer resources than their male counterparts.
While the Indian president may be only a ceremonial head of state, during periods of political instability – especially in the age of coalition governments – it is the president who makes crucial decisions about governing parties. Many past presidents have also used the position to throw their intellectual weight behind such important issues as education and India’s cultural diversity.
So President Patil has large shoes to fill. One can only hope she will prove her critics wrong. For those women in India who have proven themselves to be effective leaders, it would be wonderful if she can demonstrate early on that she has the intellectual and professional gravitas that befits the position.
Vishakha Desai is the president of the Asia Society.
Re: Pratibha Patil - First Women President of India
Eww!!
i dont know if i am the only one, but i really hate her !!!! she is not just fit to be a President !!!!! Kalam was the Best !!!!!!!!! Sonia would have been cool too , but no Prathibha !!!!
Re: Pratibha Patil - First Women President of India