Plots for Bureucrats; More Land Barons

Retirement benefits in the shape of plots have long been a highly debated topic. Everyone, all us civilians, have had something or the other to say about the plots military officers are allotted at subsidized rates after retirement in sectors/housing authorities developed by the military for its housing schemes or other uses. Now top bureaucrats reitiring after 30 Jun 06 will also get a plot in the new sector D-12 in Islamabad. But there’s a catch. Only those bearing the title “secretary” will be granted one, while others in the same grade but not “secretaries” won’t. And obviously there’s unrest among the bureaucrats who lose out.
What’s amazing is that all of them want to have plots, and those who are not given any want them as an equal right. None of them have condemned the govt’s decision to waste valuable resources and land on them, like it was so hurtful for everyone to see the military doing so for its (most often star-wearing) officers.
This proves, ppl hate the military pampering its officers just because they are jealous and feel left out, NOT because they suffer from severe love for the nation and feel some sort of loss for Pakistan’s resources when such facilities are provided.

Retirement bonanza arrives before retirement;
http://dawn.com/2006/11/03/nat18.htm

Letters have started flowing the way of 48 reigning federal secretaries allotting each a 500 square yard plot in the scenic sector D-12 as “retirement benefit”.

Rules notwithstanding, they would get the “benefit” even if they, or their spouse, already possess a plot in any government residential scheme in Islamabad or in Rawalpindi, sources in the government confirmed to Dawn on Thursday.

** Colleagues who have retired, or even in service and of equal status but not bearing the mighty title of ‘Secretary’, have been left out in the cold and to their own frustrations and devices.

Their heart-burning would be understandable, considering that the market value of each plot in D-12 is Rs20 million. No wonder the frustrated ones are said to be planning to go to the court to challenge the discrimination done to them by the country’s lawmakers.
**
Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz was implementing a recommendation by the Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat of the National Assembly that benefits accorded to federal secretaries retiring after June 30, 2006 should include a plot, Secretary Housing and Works Chaudhry Abdul Rauf said.

But the reigning ones could get same before their retirement, the committee said.

** Apart from the D-12 plot, each would get a government-paid orderly also - so that they keep some touch, however tenuous, with their past?**

** Secretariat sources said the plots were meant to keep the top secretaries in good humour with the perks and privileges enjoyed by retired army generals. However, other federal officials of equal status but not carrying the title of secretary have demanded that they should also be favoured with pre-retirement benefits.**

A recent government notification laid down that federal secretaries who already owned a plot in a government scheme in the capital would be given an additional plot measuring 500 sq year or one kanal. That decision militated against existing rules that the Capital Development Authority (CDA) and the Ministry of Housing and Works (Federal Government Employees Housing Foundation) cannot provide more than one plot in the twin cities of Rawalpindi and Islamabad to the same person, or his spouse.

Chaudhry Rauf said the committee had asked the government to provide same retirement benefits to top bureaucrats as announced by the government of Punjab for its senior officials.

The official said Punjab government had announced that it would provide a house, a security guard, a car, three arms licences and concession in utility bills to the provincial secretaries at the time of their retirement. Mr Rauf said the facility was being given only to the federal secretaries.

Recently retired former secretary Privatization Commission Tehseen Iqbal said the government should also facilitate all ex-secretaries who have been retired in the recent past.

** “It is totally discriminatory that those who have served in the present government have been deprived of this facility,” he said.
**
Meanwhile, an official of the CDA who did not want to be identified, said the CDA could not provide plots to the government employees as it can be done by the Federal Government Employees Housing Foundation (FGEHF). He said according to a criterion set under Land Disposal Regulations, the CDA could not provide additional plot to the top bureaucracy.

But Housing Minister Syed Safwanullah contended that the FGHEF had nothing to do with the allotment of plots which, he said, was the purview of the CDA.

“We don’t have land to accommodate federal secretaries therefore it has to be done by the CDA,” the minister said.

A source in the CDA said federal secretaries had started pressuring the authority to get choice sites specially in sector D-12 which is currently being developed by the CDA.

Re: Plots for Bureucrats; More Land Barons

Federal secretary? even a Army captain gets plots, all Army officers get it. For every beauracrat getting a plot, 1000 Army officers get plots. That's the crucial difference

As for a 3 star general (equivalent of federal secretary), they get a hell lot more than a single 500 square plot.

Thus your attempt to draw a comparison between the two is not appropriate

Re: Plots for Bureucrats; More Land Barons

You scratch my back I scatch yours.... is what I see going on here. There must be NO landplot allotments available to ANYONE. Working class works their a$$es off all their lives to be able to buy a land/house and takes generations to achieve that, while military personnel and 'higher-ups' get plot-allotments so easily. This type of 'benefits' is just ridiculous.

Re: Plots for Bureucrats; More Land Barons

^I agree Captain.

TRD,
Yes, they all "get" plots. But would you explain "getting" a plot? the military cuts certain amounts from salaries as a newly commissioned officer begins service and an amount proportional to the salary is cut till the time the officer is retd. be it 30 yrs later as a 4 star General officer or 1 yr later in the same rank that one joined. Larger no. of officers retire between Major and Colonel ranks and the amounts/ retirement funds of sorts are issued to them in an optional portion of a plot's price, in the locality standardized for that particular rank, and the remaining sum in the value of the plot is to be paid by the officer out of his/her savings etc to get posession. The best localities are reserved for generals.
It's obvious that ranks retiring below Major usually cant and dont acquire plots upon retirement. Also, the benefits are usually not provided if the retirement is voluntary.
Just to mention how "getting military plots" works.