Pinata for the elderly- what to put inside?

I am working in an assisted living facility as a recreational therapist. For the 4th of July, I will be setting up a pinata for them to challenge themselves with breaking.

I’m a little lost on what to add to it other than the traditional candies, lollipops, coins, etc. I’m thinking some small little trinkets… but what? I plan on stuffing it possibly with mini-lotions, lip balms for the ladies… but what else? Preferably something that’s gender neutral.

I was thinking of putting in keychains/rings but I already did that for the men for father’s day and don’t want them to have multiples of the same items… suggestions?

Re: Pinata for the elderly- what to put inside?

small hand sanitizers, small pill cases on keychains, mints, those foamy stress balls, pens, post its in different colors/shapes (i’ve seen some as sandwiches, apples, hearts, etc)