Re: Pina Colada
Cream is thicker as the name implies...but it better in a pina colada. Perhaps use less coconut milk, and maybe cut down on the vanilla flavoring, I never used Vanilla flavoring. 2 teaspoons is enough to flavor a cake. Also you don't really need sugar, pineapple should be sweet enough, no? Which brand pineapple slices are you using?
Afro, i learnt about the vanilla bit at some other site about copy cat recipes for OJ drinks, hence tried it. I should look for coconut cream next time i am at walmart. And i added splenda because silly me got the unsweetened pineapple slices, not on purpose. Will try making again.