For me it has to be Kaneria, and no its not based on just one inning, but observed in many other innings/matches.
Who is crappy/maatha fielder in your opinion (in current Pakistani team only!!)?
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
Pakistan team.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
^ 
… I know, but who is relatively crappier within Pakistani team.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
In order of merit:
Kaneria
Shabbir
Razzak
Yuhana
Inzamam
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
I think all our bowlers are yakk fielders. they will bend over when bowling but can't bend for fielding.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
arshad khan.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
One bowler who IS a good fielder is Shoaib Akhtar.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
and a good actor too…
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
------------cvabn-----------
CHAPATTT!!! Yeh chapair tumhari hoye,yeh looo,enjoy it 
I think kaneria and shabir are the ‘weakest link’
Shoaib is always excellent along with Afridi # 1 top class in the cover point area.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
shoaib akhtar has to have the worst throw back to the keeper/bowler....
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
Just because you are on the dumbass Shoaib hatin' bandwagon, it does not mean that calling him a bad fielder is right. He is a fine fielder and has one of the best throws in the Pakistan team. The real maatha fielder is Kaneria currently.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
Our oneday outfit is a very good fielding side. Likes of Afridi, Shoaib Malik, Younis, Sami and Akhtar are excellent fielders. Even Youhana, Inzi and Razzaq give their best. Few test players struggle in fielding occassionaly. We all know about Kaneria and now we know why Woolmer was not keen on playing Asim in one day arena.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
As long as you dont include Sami and Afridi in thet list im happy.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
^ S Malik is also decent fielder
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
kaneria i guess is on top when you talk abut over all fielding efforts and salman butt has the butter fingers. Salay kay hath may soorakh hain
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
Hain? dont be so naive yaar. Match dekha nahi aur ainwen mai? Since that australian tour, Salman was quite fine in the field against india. Took some exceptional catches in oneday series.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
Konsay matches or exceptional matches kee baat karrhay hain sabi bhai. ODI series may tu salman nay aik hee catch lya tha. Lagtaa hay app ko bhee dosray logo kee baimaree lag giee hay. Forgetting things after one series. Salman butt has butter fingers.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
I dont forget things after one or two series. Salman took two very good catches against India. He is Not a great fielder like Afridi or Younis but he is not that bad either. Being young he will improve.
Re: Pick your maatha fielder!
I never said kay salman did’nt take good catches, took a good catch of sehwag in the 2nd ODI when he was going mad. I guess if you are a professional cricketer you take some good catches. Even a below average fielder like saeed anwar i remember took some brilliant catches during his career. I am sure salman butt wil improve with time but his has shown that he has the potential to be the butter fingers in the current side. Droppped pretty easy cathces in Australia at tense moments.