Persistent Vegetative State

Re: Persistent Vegetative State

:salam:

I have nothing against Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips, he is doing great service to Islam. Though at times I think it is better for Islamic scholars to not say something about certain matters than to give an opinion. Issues like this one in my opinion are better left to personal choice rather than a religious cirteria because honestly we have none and it is highly debatable. I don’t think Abu Ammenah can explain his view when a young child is in PVS. I have witnessed a case where a child child of 9 years suffered brain damage in went into PVS. His parents eventually had to pull the plug on him.