Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
^^ thanks ..:)
this is a view of Hanafi Deobandi scholar......i think ...
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
its seems that above quoted fatwa of Mufti ebrahim Desai is more close to Ahle-Hadees scholars of Post no. 39 ....
But Jamia al-Azhar...has a bit vast and open minded institution....
And Allah knows best....
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
^Anyway.....all of them are allowing use of perfumes. So dawa_i_dil ....the hadith you've quoted and the link you've given is saying that alcohol is haram for treating diseases....may be haram for eating or drinking but not haram for using on skin etc? They haven't clarified this.
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
Exceptions are always there...if you have to reside in that place where there is nothing to eat ....and you are about to die... i think...pork and pure wine ...is allowed at that time....
but i cannot think that if you give medication containg alchol due to fear of death,,,it will be haram death...as you avaoided the best of wine...but only fear of death...one's used it.....
surely , it's a haram death .
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
The alcohol in such perfumes & deodorants evaporates away after a while. The simple rule I follow, based on a fatwa I read many years ago, is that you cannot pray while the deodorant or perfume is still wet on you because that is when the alcohol is present.
Once it is dry, there is no alcohol left on your clothes and you can pray.
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
Yaar masalon ka batangar banwana ho to hamaray Ulema ki expertise ka jawaab nahin hai …
Bhai intoxicants are haram and that being said meaning anything used for the purpose of intoxication whether it be alcohol, bhung, wine, beer, ether etc etc. I don’t know if anyone drinks perfumes to get high ho …
Kahan intoxiocants ka masala le jaa kar medicines or perfumes me milaa diya hai …
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
sorry my desi english cannot understand the meaning of word immunized...plz...explain with help of online dictionary ...:)
Are you kidding me?
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
The alcohol (OH class) used in perfumes is not the one that is consumed orally. It is called alcohol because it belongs to a class called ALCOHOL in periodic table (elements containing Hydroxide - OH) ...
The alcohol in perfumes may cause death as it can be served as poison too... It's different and it's allowed.
This is the position of Shaikh Yousuf Islahi of India and I agree.
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
^^ thanks ..:) this is a view of Hanafi Deobandi scholar......i think ...
yes it is:)
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
The alcohol (OH class) used in perfumes is not the one that is consumed orally. It is called alcohol because it belongs to a class called ALCOHOL in periodic table (elements containing Hydroxide - OH) ...
The alcohol in perfumes may cause death as it can be served as poison too... It's different and it's allowed.
This is the position of Shaikh Yousuf Islahi of India and I agree.
I'm amazed that if science can put something forward so simply, how has the entire muslim population not realized this truth that the alcohol that is haraam for drinking is not the same alcohol you put on your skin in a perfume?
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
The alcohol in such perfumes & deodorants evaporates away after a while. The simple rule I follow, based on a fatwa I read many years ago, is that you cannot pray while the deodorant or perfume is still wet on you because that is when the alcohol is present.
Once it is dry, there is no alcohol left on your clothes and you can pray.
Just curious, would you by the same logic eat food cooked with a little bit of alcohol? All that heat causes the alcohol to evaporate and all thats left is desired taste or something.
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
no.... no... i myself is a kid.... yesterday...my class 3 final exams were ended....thanks god..they finally ended ... :)
Re: Perfumes with Alcohol
There should be no issue. Many colognes and perfumes use synthetic alcohol as well.
Hareem also answered the question.
Although there is a difference of opinion, and mostly those who consider it impermissible are from the deobandi school (india, Pakistan, Bangladesh), in general the scholars have no concern over this.
It is still more loved to use the Attar (fragrant oils) instead of these as they were preferred by the Prophet SAW.
Allah SWT knows best.
