PCB Shake-up : One Army General to replace another?

Are major changes in PCB set-up on cards?

From our correspondent

LAHORE: Federal Government is considering replacing Chairman Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) with yet another serving General, Lt Gen Munir Hafeez who is currently serving as the Chairman National Accountability Bureau (NAB).

Highly-placed sources confided to ‘The News’ here on Wednesday that replacement of Lt-Gen Tauqir Zia might lead to drastic changes in the PCB set-up and officials right from Chishty Mujahid (Director) to Zakir Khan (GM Cricket) would be shown the door.

Khalid Butt, PCB’s acting General Manager, Media, confirmed that there would be new faces around in near future but insisted that it should not be seen in the perspective of the World Cup defeat.

“It is quite possible,” he said while elaborating the background of these changes. He said that a lot of infrastructure changes in the PCB’s setup were on cards which were suggested by the PCB consultant. The NAB Chairman Lt-Gen Munir Hafeez may be the next man to head the PCB.

The move has been suggested just to divert the growing criticism and hatred towards the management of the PCB which failed to create harmony amongst the players.

Sources added that a total revamping of the Board was in the offing and a couple of professionals from the private sector would also be inducted in the PCB in order to streamline the cricket affairs.

“This time it will not be replacement of faces but the change of whole infrastructure is under way,” the sources asserted. Possible induction from the private sector will be the President of Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI), who has been consulted to seek his consent about any responsibility in the future setup of PCB. Sources further said Yawar Irfan had already been invited to some closed-door meetings of the PCB and he had been in permanent contact with the patron-in-chief of the PCB on this affair.

When contacted, Yawar Irfan confirmed that he had received offer to serve in the PCB but declined to comment further. He said; “let things take its final shape”.

Speaking about the current performance of the cricketers, sources said that it was a collective protest of the players against the threat of strict action which was given to them while offering ‘contracts’ for the World Cup. "The players just smiled and commented: “General has gone mad” when Lt-Gen Tauqir Zia invited them to his office and declared: “I want World Cup on this table”.

I think if the reins of the PCB were handed over to GS people, we would become the numero uno test and ODI nation fairly easily. The talent in there in abundance, it's just a matter of tapping it and getting rid of the parchi-walas.

I always liked Gen. Zia even though some of his decisions were not the smartest. He did mean well for Pak cricket but simply didn't have the credentials/experience to handle the intricacies (read politics) of Pak cricket.

I still don’t really understand what qualifies members of the army to organise matters on a cricket field, but maybe someone can enlighten me.

Anyway, here’s Shaharyar Khan’s assessment of what went wrong:

‘Failure of openers, Inzamam cost us dearly in World Cup’](Daily Jang: Urdu News - Latest Breaking News update Pakistan - jang.com.pk)

From Waheed Khan

JOHANNESBURG: Pakistan manager Shaharyar Khan on Wednesday admitted that the failure of the team to even qualify for the Super Sixes of the World Cup was a big let-down for the nation.

“It is a big disappointment for everyone back home and I personally believe that we just never got going in the tournament. The boys worked and trained hard and it is not as if they didn’t try but I would agree to an extent that they didn’t show the passion for such a big competition,” he told “The News”.

“The continued failure of the batting didn’t help at all, specially Inzamam being out of form, because everyone was depending a lot on him. But then he himself realizes just how bad his form has been and it happens to every great batsman. But the fact is the batting revolves around him specially when you don’t have a reliable opening pair.”

Shaharyar pointed out that in the past the team didn’t depend on just one batsman and Pakistan always had three of four players capable of holding up the fort.

“At that time you had Saeed Anwar in prime form and an able opener in Aamer Sohail. Salim Malik, Ejaz Ahmed, Inzamam were all capable of scoring runs in one match or the other. That is why the batting never really flopped.”

"I think we faced a totally different situation in this World Cup. The batsmen had been failing even before the start of the tournament and nothing fell into place.’

Shaharyar didn’t totally agree that the constant shuffling of the batting order and failure of the team management to rotate the players was a major contributing factor to the failed World Cup campaign.

"It was not a good thing but there were logical reasons for shuffling the players around. Everyone, however, agreed that Inzamam, Youhana and Younis Khan were our main batsmen and should be batting at the number three, four and five positions to play out maximum overs and build big innings.

“But because the openers were not working and Inzi was also struggling and his heart was not in batting at number three the shuffling had to be done. But yes, I did suggest that we should play a settled line-up for atleast two or three matches and give them a chance to settle down.”

Shaharyar said the Board had not consulted him on the formation of a three-member inquiry committee to find out the reasons for the World Cup failure.

“I think it is natural for this to happen. Obviously, there is a lot of criticism back home and also some backlash and the Board has to find out the reasons for what went wrong. There is nothing wrong in it.”

Shaharyar said that perhaps the time had come for the Pakistan board to start grooming some new players. “It is a fact that some of our senior players who have given us yeomon services in their prime are now past their prime and we need to groom new players.”

But he insisted that there were no indiscipline or non-cooperation problems in the team at all. “Nothing of that sort happened. Even the Inzamam and Younis Khan incident was nothing big. Neither have I bothered to report it to anyone. We all understand just how frustrated Inzamam is at the moment and I think in the heat of the moment he lost his cool. But after a short whiile both players embraced each other and everything was forgotten.”

To a question, Shaharyar agreed that the Board should also give thought to adopting a different approach with the players. “Yes, the Board has perhaps spoilt a few players but they are not bad human beings and I tell you they all worked hard and tried their best. But when luck is not with someone nothing goes right.”

He said the players mentally were prepared for the backlash at home and would be returning home on schedule.

However, Shaharyar admitted that the Board had permitted few players to take a personal holiday. He conceded that Shoaib Akhar had been permitted to remain in South Africa, Saqlain Mushtaq would be flying to England and Yousaf Youhana would stop over in Dubai while the players based in Lahore would fly directly there from Dubai.

The Pakistan team is due to leave for home on Thursday but some of the Karachi players already left for home on Wednesday evening – among them Rashid Latif and Muhammad Sami.

Shaharyar said he would be submitting his report on the tournament as soon as he reached home and would be flying straight to Lahore. “I will meet with the Board officials to discuss my report and other things on the World Cup.”

I don't understand how Pakistan world cup defeat can be attributed to bad batting! they did score 273 runs which by any means is a very good score. Shoaib Aktar was to be the main strike weapon and Sachin Tendulkar attcked him mercilessly. That was the reason,not batting failure. Yes Inzamam could have scored but do you really think with that kind of batting attack from Sachin and steady play by Yuvraj and others, India wouldn't have chased out even 325? remember they did 274 it with 6 overs to spare!

Speaking about the current performance of the cricketers, sources said that it was a collective protest of the players against the threat of strict action which was given to them while offering ‘contracts’ for the World Cup. "The players just smiled and commented: “General has gone mad” when Lt-Gen Tauqir Zia invited them to his office and declared: “I want World Cup on this table”.

:smash: It’s cricket for God sake.

I had heard similar storied while in Pakistan. I say leave at least army mentality out of sports.

Re: PCB Shake-up : One Army General to replace another?

Right, like army’s command will bring everything they want :rolleyes:

Pakistan failure a major setback to cricket: Sarfraz

I don’t really have any respect for this guy, but he makes one or two interesting observations which make this piece worth reading:

Pakistan failure a major setback to cricket: Sarfraz

ISLAMABAD: Former Pakistan Test cricketer Sarfraz Nawaz has said that Pakistani team’s failure in the World Cup is a major set back, not only for national cricket but for the game too.

In a panel interview with the PPI sport correspondents Irfan Ghauri and Jahanzaib Ali, the fiery fast bowler rejected probe body constituted by the Pakistan Cricket Board and demanded a probe by** impartial experts.**

He said due to failure of Pak team, cricket lovers across the world had lost faith in a top team. He, however, made it clear that the board and selectors were equally responsible for the blunder.

He said it was unfortunate that cricket lovers in the world would miss four top teams of Pakistan, West Indies, England and South Africa in the World Cup as all of them could not qualify for the second round (Super Sixes).

He said in the ICC World Cup, 2003 the teams having young blood turned successful as opposed to the teams having experienced players.

Commenting on the Australian cricket team, Sarfraz said that the ACB had dropped Waugh brothers and included many young players and made their way to the Super Sixes. Similarly, he said, Kenya, Zimbabwe and New Zealand had also included many young players in their teams and reaped the harvest. “No doubt there is no substitute for experience but young blood is also a very important part of every sport,” he said.

While explaining the reasons behind the worst ever performance of the Pakistan cricket team in the World Cup, hero of the 1979 Melbourne Test, said that the main reason for not qualifying for the Super Sixes was that captain Waqar Younis and Coach Richard Pybus did not give any chance to the younger players.

He said Azhar Mahmood, Muhammad Sami and others could not even play a single match due to apathy of some senior players. He was of the view that these junior players had the ability to bring off some upsets.

When asked about the collapse of batting line in the World Cup, Sarfraz said that batting had flopped because the senior players had taken their places in the team for granted.

“The senior batsmen do not always accommodate the junior players and axing of Imran Nazir from the national side is an example of it,” he added.

He asked Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis and Saeed Anwar to voluntarily resign from the national side for the better future of the Pakistan cricket.

He said there was a lot of talent waiting at the doors of the cricket Board and they could replace these players well.

He asked the chairman of PCB General Tauqir Zia to immediately resign from his office after the worst-ever performance of national cricket team in World Cup history.

“This is the right time for PCB Chairman to voluntarily resign to save the future of cricket in the country,” Sarfraz said. He recalled that earlier when PCB Chairman had tendered his resignation to General Pervez Musharraf, the Patron of Pakistan Cricket Board, there was no option but to reinstate his services as there was no time left in World Cup.

Sarfraz said he had been apprising the nation regarding the PCB’s poor policies for the World Cup 2003. Former cricket star said he had been sounding warnings that people like Ramiz Raja, Zakir Khan, Brig. Munawar Rana and Chisti Mujahid would destroy cricket in Pakistan. “They have limited knowledge about the game and were stuck to the Pakistan cricket for their perks and privileges,” he added.

He lashed out at the inquiry committee formed by the PCB Chairman to review the performance of the national team and said that the members of the committee were incompetent to investigate the blunders committed in the national cricket.

“It is a joke played with the entire nation that the people sitting in the board were conducting accountability of their own selves. Gen. Tauqir Zia should realize that the whole nation and the world has witnessed the worst performance of the national team live.”

“Being selectors of the team, they must accept responsibility and go home, paving way to save Pakistan cricket” he added.

He said people like Naushad Ali who played few matches from national side, Sultan Rana and Aqib Javed who was the junior player could not handle such high level matters.

He opined that the PCB inquiry committee should have included the people like Justice (Retd.) Nasim Hassan Shah, Justice Ijaz Yousaf a panel of senior sports journalists and two senior test cricketers.

He demanded the President of Pakistan or the Prime Minister who himself is a sports man, should conduct an inquiry at the highest level as the Cricket Board had lost its credibility and confidence of the nation.

He accused the Chairman PCB of imposing his own decisions in all matters and holding others responsible for his own mistakes.

Commenting on the reasons for failure he said there was no planning for the World Cup, there was no discipline, incompetent officials, wrong selections and lack of physical fitness and top form were the main reasons for the worst-ever performance in the world cup.

“There was no match winning strategy and anti-Waqar element was another factor for the failure of the national team,” he said.

“There was no need of foreign coaches as the coach Richard Pybus has been getting 1500 pounds per day for the last five months and the performance is still zero,” he said.

He recalled that in the previous World Cup, the national team made its way to the finals with the help of their own coaches.*** NOTE: in fact I’m pretty sure that Richard Pybus was the coach in that campaign - Xtreme]**

Most of this article is the usual Sarfraz wind machine in action, but I agree with the part about including senior test cricketers in the enquiry panel(bolded). Army general’s expertise lies elsewhere and maybe they should stick to what they know best.