Partition weakened Muslims in subcontinent: Altaf

I said in a different context…

I know Altaf Hussain isn’t seen as a major leader within Pakistan, still, he too seems to agree with this point here

  • Future of Indian immigrants in Pakistan remains under question mark

Staff Report

KARACHI: Muttahida Qaumi Movement leader Altaf Hussain said on Wednesday the partition of the Indian Subcontinent in 1947 weakened the strength of Muslims and started the turmoil through which they were now passing.

“At present at least 400 million of the Subcontinent’s population are Muslims and the Partition divided them,” Mr Hussain said at a literary evening celebrated with Indian poet Manzar Bhopali at the party’s London secretariat.

He said no government in united India could have been formed without the consent of these 400 million Muslims, had they been united. “But the Subcontinent’s partition divided this huge strength,” he said.

“We cannot visit the graves of our elders,” unlike the Muslims who stayed in India, he said. He complained despite the passage of 57 years after the Partition, the future of the offspring of the Indian immigrants was still under a question mark, and they were being called by derogatory names.

Urdu-speakers who were born on Pakistani soil “are also not accepted as sons of the soil and their patriotism is doubted.”

Those who gave the most sacrifices for the creation of a separate homeland for Indian Muslims were called traitors, he added. He said the ancestors of Urdu-speaking people had left their homeland and migrated to Sindh, and now Sindh was their motherland.

“Sindh is our homeland and will strive for Sindh’s rights and will never migrate to another place,” he said.

“Bengalis were 99 per cent loyal for Pakistan and they were called traitors. G M Syed voted in favour of the resolution for the creation of Pakistan and he was also dubbed a traitor and enemy of the state,” he said. He went on: “Our ancestors created Pakistan and sacrificed hundreds of thousands of lives people to see their dream fulfilled, they left everything behind,” he said.

“Those who opposed the creation of Pakistan, supported the British Raj and were informants against the freedom fighters are given certificates of patriotism,” he said. “Our people were massacred for raising the voice for their rights and a state operation was launched against us, which killed more than 15,000 youth,” Mr Hussain said.

He added that areas in Sindh’s urban centres were cordoned and women and the elderly were subjected to insulting behaviour during the operation.

“We were not against Pakistan and are not against it now. What we want is that we should be considered equal citizens and the rulers should end injustices against us,” he said.

On the occasion, the MQM leader, who often tries his hand at versification, read out a poem he has written, criticising the Partition. Titled, “Ye kaisi taqsim hui,” it read

Re: Partition weakened Muslims in subcontinent: Altaf

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by cscraja: *
KARACHI: ...Altaf Hussain said ...the partition of the India ...weakened the strength of Muslims ...
[/QUOTE]

Good! So he needs to live in Bhopal and make the Indian Muslims "stronger". I am sure he can send out his goons on motorcycles and collect Bhatta (free money) from the local shopkeepers. This for sure will make all Bhopalis much stronger and bring them at par with the citizens of King Lallu's la la land aka Bihar.

Living in London and making reading poems is easy. Working for the betterment of people is mighty difficult.

Bharati nationalist Hindis and Hindus must realize that the year of 1947 gave birth to 2 brand spanking new countries; Bharat and Pakistan. Questing this birth is like posing stupid questions about the births of cscraja or his brother Altaf.

Mr, you fell into the trap of a military dictator. He used you for his own political purpose and when you were playing his stooge you didn't think for a second that thus you were plunging the whole province into the mire of ethnic conflicts.

You're a hypocrite of the highest order, your party clashed with almost all other ethnici groups living in urban and rural sindh. You fought with Sindhis in interior sindh and with pashtuns and punjabis in Karachi, and now you're talking about muslim brotherhood. The partition of British India was in my opinion inevitable. If the partition hadn't happened this whole region would be in a much deeper mire of ethnic and religious fanaticism now. Forget what happened in the past and learn to live with the people of other ethnic groups, esp in karachi. But you're a proud british citizen you don't need it anyway.

The future of Mohajirs is dubious, hmmm, tell it to Musharraf and Shaukat Aziz. Your language has been made the national language, your city is the most advancecd and industrialized city in Pakistan, your people have the best opportunity to get a good education and a better job in this country. What the hell do you want now? Your party is ruling Sindh although PPP had emerged as the biggest political power in the last election. If Sindhis whine one might understand because he is no more the master in his own province, but why the hell are you whining? who told you that your forefathers gave the most sacrifices for the creation of this country. In my opinion the bengalis and muslim punjabis of east punjab sacrificed more than any other people.

Sindh is also the homeland of 'pukka sindhis', and they are also striving for their rights. Actually all ethnic groups are striving for their rights, you and your people are no exception.

Well guys did anyone watch that program on GEO 'Hot Seat' in which Dr. Farooq Sattar was the guest. Shawaiz the questions that you are asking are more or less the same that the host asked Mr. Farooq Sattar. It is interesting to see people denying events and facts that are so evident.

** It is interesting to see people denying events and facts that are so evident**

Could you please elaborate a little more on that?
Thanx in advance...