Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Not much is expected from the Parliament since most MPs have their familes in the west.

http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2011\09\24\story_24-9-2011_pg7_14

Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure: PILDAT

Staff Report

ISLAMABAD: While Pak-US relations face a deepening conflict after the September 13 attack on the US embassy and NATO headquarters in Kabul, scathing criticism and serious charges have been levelled on Pakistan in a mounting chorus from US institutions – from Pentagon to the Central Investigation Agency (CIA) to US Congress and Congressional Committees – parliament and a number of its committees charged with the responsibility to oversee national security, foreign affairs and defence, seem to be indifferent.

As elected public representatives, it is parliament’s responsibility to oversee the country’s foreign and security policies. However, in keeping with its poor tradition of playing no role in a crisis or in influencing a policy, parliament and its committees seem the most unaffected by the challenges Pakistan faces, especially vis-à-vis the disquiet and mounting pressure in Pak-US relations.

On the other hand, committees in the US Congress, especially the Senate Armed Services Committee and the Senate Appropriations Committee, have met since the September 13 Kabul incident with US Defence Secretary Leon E Panetta, and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen testifying before the former. The Senate Appropriations Committee reportedly passed a bill making ‘all’ US financial assistance to Pakistan conditional to cooperation against the Haqqani network and other terror groups associated with the al Qaeda.

A look at the dismal performance of the parliamentary committees charged with the responsibility to oversee Pakistan’s national security and defence policies reveals that these committees have failed to even examine the serious issues confronting Pakistan, let alone offer policy advice on behalf of the people of Pakistan. The National Assembly Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, chaired by Awami National Party (ANP) leader, MNA Asfandyar Wali Khan, last met on June 6 just to undergo a call-on by the British ambassador to Afghanistan. Since its formation in 2008, the committee has only met 17 times in three and a half years, out of which the chairman himself was not available to chair 10 of the meetings. The Senate Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, chaired by Senator Salim Saifullah, has not yet met after the current crisis and since its formation in May 2010 has held only 11 meetings.

The Parliamentary Committee on National Security, chaired by Senator Raza Rabbani held its last meeting on August 18. Since its formation in November 2008, the committee has met 35 times, with all meetings held in-camera. The National Assembly Standing Committee on Defence, chaired by MNA Dr Azra Fazal Pechuho, last met as a full committee on June 29 to discuss the attack on the PNS Mehran, a month after the attack. The committee only met 27 times since its delayed formation in February 2009 after the 2008 general election.

The Senate Standing Committee on Defence and Defence Production, chaired by Senator Javed Ashraf, held its last meeting on August 1 on a matter relating to the Pakistan International Airlines (PIA). It has held 26 meetings in all since its formation in July 2009.

The Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency (PILDAT) demanded that these committees meet immediately and start discussing the options Pakistan has. The committees should seek relevant expertise from across Pakistan and parliament needs to take a lead on deciding the country’s policy choices.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Just having family in the West is not the reason for people to support US. Take a look at Jamati ameer's daughter who is in the US as well.

And nothing is expected from our parliament. They have pathetic record of discussing anything beyond their narrow personal confines. For example, take a look at how many laws they have discussed/ created during their tenure. Abysmal.
Rubber stamp parliament. They will do what president/PM will ask them to do.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Hina Rabbani Khar's statement is quite powerful message to Sam. So the apprehension about the parliament is not true. Zardari has already summoned NA and seems to set for strong message to Sam. I think they have passed many laws and your contention about these also seems to be incorrect.

Comming back to "abysmal" performance, what about your mqm? what your leader done was shameful press conference nerve braking for four hours. Eveyone including yourself wanted to puke. Your Chief issued message against US for supplying money to Asfand Yar for breaking Pakistan and the next day he sh!tted in his pants and retracked his statement. When you criticize parliament or government always keep in view performance of your mqm particularly in Sindh because it is not exclusive from the parliament and the government.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Khar should be paying her taxes first, and her interview was nothing but typical bs compared to what khurshid kasuri or even musharraf could answer. I still remember Fareed Zakaria's face when Musharraf broke down all the "aid" numbers right in front of him.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

My comment was meant towards the WHOLE parliament which includes not just PPP but all other parties as well, including MQM. You are yourself feeling the heat because you take politics personally. This is why instead of talking about parliament you started abusing MQM, because you think I support it.
Party affiliation is more important to you than the good of people of Pakistan.

But I don't understand how MQM's "failures" justify the abysmal performance of PPP government? Will PPP work well only if MQM works well?
Ridiculous.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

The feudal lady from the house of a feudal lord.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Pakistani parliament is a true representative of Pakistan. Pakistani people are totally indifferent to USA and so is its parliament.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

Pakistan parliament is bunch of thugs (baring few), and US knows that. They somehow think that if they even speak against uncle sam, they will be doomed for life in Pakistan politics. war of words started by US for their own means and designes, on top of defending Pakistan, Pakistan should also do counter offensive through same communication channells what are being used by US policy makes to create negetive image of Pakistan!

What I dont understand, why in response to a US general, the whole parliament has to be called just to issue a statement without meaning? why cant these so called elected leaders being leader issue strong statements themselves? whats so hard about it? but i think they just lack the spine needed by true leaders!

loosing 35000 people to this "war OF terror", and getting such words from ally like foe is utter disgust and shame!

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure

This war is not result of policies of "bunch of thugs (baring few)," This is all due to another bunch of ...... , Four out can be named, Ayoub,Yahya,Zia and Mush.
Weak and corrupt democracy still working better than the other bunch.

Re: Parliament seems indifferent to US pressure


oh bhai mere, Shak Kills ne bhi yahi bola thaa