Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

India is building dams on the rivers on which Pakistan has the right (as per Indus water treaty). So what is Pakistan’s government doing about it?

What are the governments plans for building water reservoirs and introduction of technologies (drip irrigation) to reduce wastage of water?

In a report released last week by the Asian Development Bank (ADB), Pakistan was pinpointed as “one of the most water-stressed countries in the world, not far from being classified, ‘water-scarce’.” As water demand exceeds supply in the South Asian country, more and more water is being withdrawn from the nation’s reservoirs, leaving them in a critically precarious position. According to the ADB, Pakistan’s storage capacity, the amount of water it has on reserve in case of an emergency, is limited to a 30-day supply – far below the recommended 1,000 days for countries with similar climates. Without meaningful action, a water crisis could push the country into further chaos.

Consider what a water shortage means for Pakistan. The last several years have seen the country plagued by chronic energy scarcities. Power outages lasting up to 18 hours a day are routine throughout the country, and they have had damaging effects on the economy and on the wellbeing of Pakistanis. Citizens frequently take to the streets, demanding a solution from their government in protests that often turn violent, worsening an already tumultuous political environment. Deficiencies of another precious natural resource, such as water, have the potential to intensify the already unstable situation in the country.

Early signs of the potential imbroglio that could transpire are already beginning to take shape. Late last week, residents in Abbottabad vowed to hold mass demonstrations if the local government was unable to address rampant water shortages in the city. The city has lacked sufficient water for the past month, with over 5,000 homes impacted in the hottest months of the year.

At a conference organized around water shortages in the province of Sindh earlier this month, leaders of political parties and various trade organizations blamed a wide array of individuals, including former Pakistani heads of state, other provinces in the country, and even Pakistan’s neighbors, for the nation’s water woes.

Extremist groups, of which there is no dearth in Pakistan, have also weighed in on the matter, using it as an opportunity to garner support for their movement. Hafiz Saeed, the founded of the militant group, Lakshar-e-Taiba – the organization behind the 2008 Mumbai attacks – has unequivocally blamed India for Pakistan’s water crunch, accusing its government of committing “water terrorism.” By evoking an issue that is sensitive to millions of Pakistanis, Saeed’s rhetoric demonstrates the potential of militant groups to exploit this issue.

The country’s demographics make it seem as though this trend will only worsen over time. Pakistan’s population has grown exponentially over the past several decades. With two-thirds of the population currently under the age of 30, the nation of 180 million is expected to swell to 256 million by the year 2030, and demand for water will only grow. Meanwhile, climate change, which has reduced water flows into the Indus River, Pakistan’s main supply source, will continue to shrink the available water supply.

The response to any crisis is likely to play out, in part, through Pakistan’s foreign policy. For starters, the government has been pushing to redefine the terms of the Indus Water Treaty of 1960 – the water-sharing plan struck between India and Pakistan that outlines how the six rivers of the Indus basin would be shared. Pakistan has recently contested the construction of Indian dams on rivers that begin in India but flow into Pakistan, arguing that the dams would restrict Pakistani supply.

The dispute, which is currently being reviewed by the International Court of Arbitration in The Hague, will clearly impact the relationship between the two historic rivals, as water demand increases in both countries. But with pressure mounting from various groups within Pakistan, and the likelihood of instability increasing due to shortages, the Pakistani government may find itself in a difficult position when negotiating with India – it will have limited bargaining room against an Indian government that may be reluctant to renegotiate a treaty that has been in place for 53 years.

There are other ways, outside of India, for Pakistan to alleviate the problem. Requiring and enforcing updated, modern farming techniques is a start. Pakistan’s agriculture industry is notorious for its inefficient irrigation and drainage processes, which have contributed to the scarcity. The government will also need to reach out beyond its borders to create solutions. The Memorandum of Understanding between the Karachi Water and Sewage board and the China International Water and Electric Corporation, which strives to make Karachi self-sufficient in water supply, is one example of how deliberate international efforts can help the situation.

Water deficiency, and how Pakistan responds to it, has the propensity to shape the country significantly over the next several years and decades. Without any meaningful action, the future looks alarming. A growing population without the resources it needs to survive, let alone thrive economically, will throw the country into a period of instability that may be far worse than anything we see today.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

These dams will generate the electricity which Nawaz Sharif intends to buy at bloated prices.

Re: Pakistan’s New Big Threat Isn’t Terrorism—It’s Water

Ali bhai chorreiN in buri, buri khabroN ko, aek qata arz kia hey, mulaheza farmiya:

Hairan hun dil ko roun k pitun jigar ko meiN
maqadur hun to sath rakhun nauha’gar ko meiN
chora na rashk ne k tere ghar ka nam lun
har ek se puchta hun ke jaooN kidhar ko meiN!

Ghalib

By the way, let them as many dams as they want, once they are done, we will buy every unit of electricity they will produce… becharey deikhtey hi reh jaeiN ge :hehe:… bohat teiz heiN hum :is:

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

It seems that water is soon going to become a much bigger issue in pakistan..

Re: Pakistan’s New Big Threat Isn’t Terrorism—It’s Water

and while the haram khors were busy in haram khori…

Jamaat Ali Shah escapes to Canada - thenews.com.pk

ISLAMABAD: Syed Jamaat Ali Shah, former commissioner of Pakistan Commission of Indus Water, whose name was put on the Exit Control List after it was established that he had helped and facilitated India in building a hydropower project on Pakistan’s Indus River, inflicting huge damage to the country’s water interests, has escaped to Canada…

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

atom bomb kis din kaam aayegaa? Daraa dhamkaa ke paanii le leN...yehii shaayad N$ kii strategy ho! bomb bhii to unhoN ne hii phoRaa thaa...vo kisii se nahiiN Darte...vo sher e Punjaab haiN! :D

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

the rivers that are supposed to be for pakistan as per the IWT, are geographically unsuitable for india to use for anything other than small hydel power plants. no storage, no arable lands without serious investment in pumping water over multiple mountain ranges down to the plains.

pakistan's power outages aren't because india is storing away their water flow magically. it is because the government refuses to pay the generating plants for electricity already consumed. even when pakistan talks about importing power from india, the plan is for india to import additional fuel, generate power in india from extra generation capability, and sell this - and not sell an existing surplus from hydel power. this is how lousy/chalaak your government is.

[QUOTE]
Hafiz Saeed, the founded of the militant group, Lakshar-e-Taiba -- the organization behind the 2008 Mumbai attacks -- has unequivocally blamed India for Pakistan's water crunch, accusing its government of committing "water terrorism." By evoking an issue that is sensitive to millions of Pakistanis, Saeed's rhetoric demonstrates the potential of militant groups to exploit this issue.
[/QUOTE]

hafiz saeed, lal topi hamid etc. are the champions of this. and if they are the ones who get to set the tone of your public policy, good luck with that..

in the end, unless pakistan and india can stop seeing each other suspiciously, this wont be resolved. india will hold the upper hand simply because of geography. you divide up a population along unnatural non-geographical boundaries to make distinct countries, you better be on good terms as neighbours.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

IWT affects agriculture more than hydel power generation. Pakistanis have been living without electricity for a long time, and have proven that they can survive....but agriculture is the backbone of Pakistan, which is being hurt by dams built on Jhelum, Chenab and Indus, which are meant exclusively for Pakistan under IWT.

Re: Pakistan’s New Big Threat Isn’t Terrorism—It’s Water

which dams in particular on the jhelum, chanab or indus is reducing the amount of water flowing into pakistan? as far as i know, india has no storage dams on them - even the highly contested baglihar dam is nothing when it comes to storing water. nimoo and chutak are both run of the river power projects with no significant storage.

also, india is facing the opposite problem with a lot of newly comissioned hydel plants all over the himalayas - there has been way too much flow and flooding - possibly due to climate change. a few projects have been decomissioned even before the scheduled comissioning dates.


Restored attachments:

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Can't india divert that water to rajasthan which it has for agriculture? Also, a lot of indopak problems would not be there if partition had happened exactly according to which country got the muslim and hindu majority areas. But what is done is done for now.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

india built a ton of canals and storage dams to take water into punjab and rajasthan's arable lands, but these are from the three eastern rivers - satlej, beas, ravi that were allocated under the treaty to india's use. india is not allowed to divert water from indus, jhelum, chanab - which it can't either without some major engineering projects - these rivers flow in individual valleys separated from the plains by distance, as well as ranges of mountains.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Soon we can expect a war between Pakistan and India this time on Water

Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

It has been said many times that the next war will be because of water issues. This is when the nukes may go off!

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

The water level in Jhelum river has reduced quite a bit during the past few years.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Two dams that I know of are kishan Ganga and baglihar dams.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Sookha para hai Jhelum just passed by it few days back

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Koi baat naheen NS/SS china say naya river banwa rahain hain...that is their plan....great leadership really..such future thinkers...

Re: Pakistan’s New Big Threat Isn’t Terrorism—It’s Water

60 back-to-back power projects being built by India on Chenab - thenews.com.pk

ISLAMABAD: In another shocking revelation, after India on June 25 laid the foundation stone of the 850-MW Ratle Hydroelectric Project (RHP) on Chenab River in Jammu and Kashmir, another row of 60 back-to-back water cum power projects is coming up in the Chenab basin of Himachal Pradesh and Indian-held Kashmir, reveals a document available with The News.

Chenab irrigates the central part (Sialkot, Narowal, Gujranwala, Sheikhupura, Depalpur, Okara and some part of south Punjab (Bhawalnagar) in Pakistan. The Punjab is the food basket of the whole country and if this trend of constructing hydropower projects continues unabated, then the day is not far off when the province will turn barren, Hamid Malhi, presidentof Punjab Water Council told this correspondent.

The document also shows that India has chalked out plans to store 20 MAF water on Pakistan’s rivers with the purpose to get power out of them and harness the capacity to regulate water releases to Pakistan.

Another objective of India is to replace coal-based electricity generation with clean hydroelectricity. However, our novice water and energy adviser has recommended in the power policy 2013, which provinces did not approve in the Council of Common Interests (CCI) meeting, the import of electricity from India without considering its impact on the Indus Water Treaty under the umbrella of regional trade of electricity.

A statement by the Pakistan High Commissioner in New Delhi Salman Bashir has also been reported which quotes him as saying that Pakistan will import electricity from India. How he made that statement and whether he did that with the approval of the Foreign Office is not yet clear.

Eng Syed Shafiq, expert in renewable energy, claimed that the power policy presented in CCI is purely a cut and paste policy, as most of the slides out of total 23 slides of the power policy had been taken from the presentation a local think tank had prepared.

He said that the advisor was a pharmacist and has experience of just 3 months in the ministry. However, he possesses the quality to impress the participants through his speaking skills, Shafiq said.

He also suggested that Pakistan should learn from the power policy Kabul has craved out as its policy consists of well-defined framework and action plan.

The document discloses that the new 540 MW Seli Hydro Electric Project (HEP) is another addition in Chenab River but in Lahul & Spiti District in the state of Himachal Pradesh. “The project has been awarded to contractor for construction.”

**The Seli HEP envisages the construction of a dam near Shulling village and the underground powerhouse situated on the right bank of the Chenab River near Gugal Nala. **The project also involves the construction of the headrace tunnel, surge shaft, penstock and a powerhouse tailrace channel, and is proposed to have four units, each of 120 MW Capacity. The project envisages construction of a dam of 78 m from river bed level and 123 m high from deepest foundation level, two head race tunnels about 4.17 km and 4.25 km each and a underground powerhouse on the right bank of the Chenab river with installed capacity of 540 MW. The catchment area of the project is about 6053 sq km, of which about 3787 sq km remains under snow.

The proposed Shamnot HEP in Doda district of Jammu and Kashmir, is located upstream of the proposed Baglihar project on Chenab. The project envisages harnessing the hydropower potential of the river. **A concrete gravity dam is proposed across the river just opposite of the Shamnot village and an underground powerhouse with an installed capacity of 4 x 92.5 MW is proposed upstream of Udhaipur nala in Doda District. **The main project will generate 1651 Gwh in a 90% dependable year and 1738.02 Gwh in a 50% dependable year.

**The Shamnot HEP envisages construction of 450 feet high concrete gravity dam across river Chenab to provide a live stage of eight million cubic meters at 912 meters above from Seal Level.
**
Another Barinium HEP, in Doda district is also proposed on river Chenab upstream of Ungilar Nalla. **The project envisages harnessing the hydropower potential by construction of a concrete gravity dam and surface powerhouse with an installed capacity of 2 x 120 MW is proposed down stream of dam. **The scheme will generate 1170.34 million units of electricity.

Several other hydroelectric projects, including Gyspa, Chattru, Shangling, Miyarm Tandi, Seli, Reoli Dugli, Bardang, Patam, Tinget and Purthi, are coming up in the ecologically vulnerable region of Himachal Pradesh but on Chenab river.

When contacted eminent water experts Shamsul Mulk and Arshad H Abbasi warned the said projects have been initiated without any cumulative impact assessment in terms of ecology, geology, disaster and climate change impacts.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

Just thinking, Why Shia community knows more about water shortage coming up? Heard it from too many shias now.
Is water a bigger discussion in Shia gatherings for some reason. Not being sarcastic rather just wondering.
Don't take it negatively.

Re: Pakistan's New Big Threat Isn't Terrorism—It's Water

This was initiated by Mush era. Why that good for nothing real haram khor was silent? Wasn't his foriegn ministry responsible for not taking any action against India? Read the full report, haram khoron ne us ki pension band ki magar aap jaisay halal khoron ne usay mulk se baahir bhaga dya.

*Pakistan ki badbakhti hay ke chand aqalmand halal khor bastay hain. Instead of capturing real evils, they go after shadows, blaming other than real culprits and results 'tun tun ghotala'
*

[quote]
According to Additional Secretary Hamid Ali, it was established in the report prepared by Mohammad Imtiaz Tajwar, Secretary Wapda, that Syed Jamaat Ali Shah did not play his due role and remained silent about the Nimoo Bazgo Hydropower Project (built by India during 2002- 2009) and did not raise any objections during the Pak-India meetings at the level of Permanent Indus Commission of Indus Waters.

*On the basis of its report, the ministry has withheld the pension of Mr Shah who retired just before the finalisation of the report, a copy of which is available with The News. Jamaat Ali Shah retired on September 30, 2011 and the report was submitted on September 23, 2011.
*

The official claimed that India had informed Mr Jamaat Ali Shah about the Nimoo Bazgo project 6 months before the initiation of its construction. At that time Syed Jamaat Ali Shah had objected to the design of the project as being against the provisions of the Indus Waters Treaty.

According to the report, Military Intelligence (MI) Directorate had informed the government on June 6, 2005 that India was planning to construct the Nimoo-Bazgo hydroelectric project, which would be completed by 2010. The report also divulged that Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) further informed the government on July 25 2005 that the Indian Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh has visited Leh, Kargil and Siachen Glacier on June 11, 2005 and laid the foundation stone of Nimoo-Bazgo and Chutak hydroelectric power plants. Similarly, the ISI on September 7, 2005 shared information about the visit of the Indian prime minister to Siachen and Kargil.
[/quote]