Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

This is really sad. Karachi needs to be cleaned up.

Pakistan’s commercial hub faces growing extortion menace | Reuters

(Reuters) - One afternoon a stranger called at Muhammad Faizanullah’s stationery shop in Karachi, Pakistan’s commercial capital, and wordlessly handed the man behind the counter two items: a piece of paper with a phone number scrawled on it, and a bullet.

“The letter contained a demand for 200,000 Pakistani rupees ($2,000),” Faizanullah, 20, said. “The man said ‘Just call this number and pay the amount, otherwise the bullet is meant for you.’”

Businesses in Karachi are facing a surge in extortion demands from criminal gangs, forcing many owners to delay new investment or to relocate their families to escape the sense of insecurity gripping the urban heart of Pakistan’s economy.

The worsening law and order situation in Karachi, which generates 25 percent of Pakistan’s economic activity, presents one of the many challenges new Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif must overcome to fulfill promises to set Pakistan on a path to faster growth.

An expanding middle class is fuelling consumer spending but extortion is hurting confidence among thousands of family-run firms that form the backbone of the economy.

With the Muslim Holy month of Ramadan due to start in July, a traditional time for extortionists to come calling, Karachi traders and shopkeepers are braced for what police say will be a record year of demands.

“The extortion racket has blown out of all proportion with the previous year,” said Ahmed Chinoy, chief of the Citizen Police Liaison Committee (CPLC), a Karachi body set up to help police by providing crime statistics and technical support.

The growing demands reflect the shifting dynamics of a city of 18 million people where new challengers, including Pakistan’s Taliban movement, are locked in an increasingly violent, neighborhood-by-neighborhood battle for control.

Figures collected by Chinoy’s committee show there were more than 630 extortion complaints registered in Karachi from January to mid-June, compared to 589 in the whole of last year. Most cases were registered by people who have refused to pay.

Police say the actual number of incidents is many times higher since the vast majority of extortion demands go unreported and victims usually decide to pay. There is no way to know the sums involved, but police say payments run into tens of millions of dollars annually and that 2013 will be a record year.

Ten days after the extortionist paid his visit to Faizanullah’s shop in the bustling Alam cloth market in December, two men on motorbikes stopped him, his father and uncle as they were driving home from work.

One of the men, a gun visible in his waistband, told Faizanullah: “You people don’t seem to understand our polite attitude, we will have to shoot you.” They demanded the men’s cellphones and roared away.

“We live under constant stress,” Faizanullah said. But he has insisted that his family refuse to hand over any cash.

Professionals, not just shopkeepers, are also targets.

When Javed Hanif, a doctor, answered his cellphone in June the caller reeled off a list of Hanif’s personal details: his work in a government hospital, the registration number of his car, and preparations for his son’s wedding. The man demanded 500,000 Pakistani rupees.

HAND GRENADES

Karachi traders say paying extortion has long been part of the cost of doing business in Karachi.

The police say thugs working for the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), the dominant political party in Karachi, are the biggest extortion menace in the city.

The police have also linked other political parties to extortion, although the MQM and other parties in Karachi repeatedly deny any involvement.

In the past year, the rules of the game have changed as competing political parties, militant groups and criminal entrepreneurs intent on challenging MQM’s grip on Karachi have expanded their extortion rackets to fund ever deadlier turf wars, police officials say.

The number of killings in Karachi jumped to more than 2,300 in 2012 from 1,700 the previous year. More than 1,400 murders have already been recorded since the start of this year. The increasing death toll has made it easier for gangs to coerce people into paying money, although there have been few reports of extortion-related killings.

“The extortion racket in Karachi has become an industry,” said senior police officer Niaz Ahmed Khosa. “There are around 50 no-go areas in Karachi, which police can not enter. Most of the extortion rackets and other crime are being generated from these population pockets.”

The police blame much of the increase in extortion on a criminal gang known as the People’s Aman Committee (PAC), based in the district of Lyari, one of the police no-go areas, and which they say is expanding into new parts of the city. The gang, the police say, is linked to the Pakistan People’s Party, which ruled Pakistan until its defeat at May general elections.

“If some political party says they are not involved in the extortion racket, they are lying,” said Majyad Aziz Balagamwala, a former president of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry.

Police say Pakistan’s Taliban movement, which originated on the northwestern frontier with Afghanistan, has also ramped up extortion operations in Karachi in the past year and has been blamed for attacks that have killed dozens of police.

In spite of the climate of fear, business sentiment is not universally bleak. Retail is booming in Karachi, symbolized by the opening of a flashy modern shopping centre called Dolmen Mall Clifton in 2011 which showcases international brands such as Debenhams and Fatburger.

But nobody is immune from an extortionist’s call.

Byram D. Avari, the owner of a prominent hotel chain and a well-known figure in Karachi, refused to pay the demands of a caller who threatened to set off hand grenades at his hotels and home. But many others dare not say no.

Re: Pakistan’s commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

For Karachi, 2013 will be a record year of extortion demands: Police – The Express Tribune

same story with pic


Restored attachments:

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

^^^ I have always said that Karachi needs martial law. The army should be put in charge of Karachi to stamp out these gangs w/o fear or favor b/c police can't do the job. They are too corrupt and politicized to handle the situation.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Why Army does not want to go into Karachi?

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Express Tribune removed the reference to MQM from the Reuters story.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Ok tell me MQM bandits are behind this and they will only increase this as Bhai is put on the hot seat...Nora league needs to step up security and raid the "dadas" of MQM preemptively.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

I don't believe MQM is behind this kind of bhatta khori, its mostly Amn Committee or TTP (or so they claim).

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Jo darakht bhai ney 30 saal pehley lagaaya tha, ab us ka phal sirf bhai hi nahin buhut sey criminals kha rahey haiN

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

mqm and others all involved in this crime

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

If you are from karachi and you have folks still living there...then I wonder how you don't see it like we do. MQM is a major stake holder in these loot by bike and etc. bhutha system. A very close family member know AH's moomani who is there 2 doors down neighbour. So they know almost all of it from inside. MQM' all five are in this "ghee" deep...
Now they are probably not the sole perpetrators but probably leading the pack. Kind of the like Big dada's and small parties messing around in the same zones sometimes. Where the big hoodlums often shoot it out with the small ones to show who owns the territory. If it sounds like the wild west or "zamana-e-jahiliyat" then yes it is just like that.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Agreed. There is no other way.

50 no go areas? WTH! Sounds like Somalia at the height of the civil war, not a financial hub of a nuclear power.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace


MQM is involved in bhatta-khori, I completely agree, there is no denial. My comment is mainly towards demanding huge bhatta and killing if bhatta not received. I have many family members who are in retail business or other commercial activities in MQM dominated areas (as well as others). MQM dominated areas report bhatta of small amounts monthly, whereas areas that are not MQM dominated get "parchi" of huge amounts with threats of (and many times actual) killing if bhatta not received. I haven't heard of any instance where MQM gave a parchi of huge amount and it resulted in killing for non-payment.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

^^ You probably have a point there.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Army is there in the form of the Corps led by the famous Corps Commanders. Army itself is a qabza group with DHA, cantt etc. Army has been deployed in the sense of the paramilitary Rangers that do partially report to the Army unlike the Police force and what has the govt or the army achieved till now?

I don't know if there is a concept of military police in the army, but lets face it, 1971 and swat etc show that the army sucks very bad at COIN. FATA is one thing since there is no police there anymore, but even there I favor more setting up of police under FC leadership. What message does it send to the people, the bureaucracy, criminals and the police itself that army has to come handle everything with a standing police force in a major metropolis of Pakistan? I would fire all the police walas or hang them if army has to do everything.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

If it wasn't for WoT, army would've happily turned Karachi into a war zone at least couple of times by now and I doubt it would've helped the situation in any way.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Karachi is not Swat or Orakzai Agency, where you can apply draining the swamp kind of strategy, that is take everyone out, clean the area and let them in with strict checking on their way back.

Its huge metropolitan, tooo much congested residential areas, over populated. moving everyone out is simply not feasible. I've seen homes where people have purpose built watch-towers on building tops, with properly planned "eye holes" in walls (not doors), and "gun-holes" (if there is a term like that) to counter any such operation. City has huge quantity of heavy weapons, from anti-tank mines to AA guns to rocket-launchers.

Army trying to "cleanse" the area with everyone living there will result in huge lose of life and property, for all, army, terrorists and civilians. still with no guarantee that after this lose we will get any better Karachi in long term.

It has to be done slowly, by better policing and better corruption free administration. depoliticized govt departments. that CPLC should be handed over to a non-political entity (currently MQM controls it), command and control center of those large number of CCTVs should be linked to more than one security agencies for the reasons of cross-checking and check-and-balance of one agency on the other, and better coordination.

Army can for sure cordon of the city, and help police and civil law enforcement agencies by stopping arms inflow, and terrorists outflow. but army should not undertake a full scale operation in the city.

Re: Pakistan's commerical hub faces growing extortion menace

Perhaps you were not born during Zia-ul-Haq martial law regime in Karachi. Presiding military officers (ranks of majors and captains) in military courts collected millions in bhatta from businessmen under-trail in military courts. None had balls to challenge these robbers. Believe it or not military is originally bhatta founder in Karachi. MQM and others are their illegitimate by products.

Before breakup of Pakistan in 1971, military looted their own banks including State Bank of Pakistan in Dacca in former East Pakistan. And you want them to take over Karachi, so that history repeats itself eh!