Are we related? 
Like Jaanwar said, whatever floats your boat. I got married quite young anyway, so my Frenchie was my first love. It’s always been my family’s criteria that i marry a Muslim, and that i did. And yes, he was a Muslim [revert] before i met him.
And this was back in my day when i think it wasn’t as socially acceptable as it is now…but the people around me were pretty relaxed about this sort of stuff…
If i did not get married at the age that i did, was getting on a bit with regards to age, and was not having any luck with the Pakistani diaspora, then for sure i would “broaden my horizons” so to speak. I don’t think you should limit yourself.