Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
^ Giving false promises of marriage to a girl, before having sex is considered illegal in India.
lol what the hell. where is this law?
Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
She can take him to court if she wants. The police will register a case. The media will have field day in both India and pakistan, however the court may or may not find him guilty as there is no definite law for such situations. The conviction will depend on the judge’s interpretation of rape laws in india.
Here are two different interpretations in two different high courts
Delhi HC
Sex on false promise of marriage is rape: Delhi HC
Bombay HC
Sex on false promise of marriage not rape: HC
A very good article in the hindu explains
The Hindu : States / Tamil Nadu :
*=left]Lower courts cannot refuse to frame charges under Section 376 (rape) of the IPC just because the complainant had admitted that she consented for sexual intercourse because the accused promised to marry her, the Madras High Court Bench here has held.
*=left]Section 375, which defines rape, stated that the offence would be made out if it was committed against the will of the victim or without her consent or by obtaining her consent under the fear of hurt or by impersonation or by reason of unsound mind of the victim.
*=left]If one read Section 375 along with Section 90, which stated: “A consent is not such a consent as is intended by any section of this code if the consent is given by a person under fear of injury, or under a misconception of fact.” Giving consent on the false promise of marriage amounted to misconception.
*=left]Whether the accused had made a false promise to marry the petitioner only with the intention of having sexual intercourse or whether his promise was genuine, which he could not keep up owing to other considerations, was a matter to be decided only during the course of trial.
*=left]Finally, The alleged offence may attract only Section 417 (cheating) and not Section 376. Section 417 carries a maximum sentence of one year of imprisonment with or without fine.
Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
But if she did consent (key word) to sex (regardless of Rauf's real motives / whether he lied to her etc.) then it does not constitute rape under international law
Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
but y that girl allowed him to have sex before marriage. I think she also desired to check empire stamina
Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
The law and its interpretation may not make much sense in a western/international context, but it is a law just for Indian society like the dowry laws. The assumption is that a woman risks social consequences unique to the Indian/desi society and a possible traumatic trail , and so is unlikely to make self damaging accusations without a good reason.
Re: Pakistani Umpire Asad Rauf accused of Sexual exploitation by Indian Model
Cant believe the Ump is still exploimating!