choti jaan - yelling is in no way productive, insults and put downs lead to to low sef-esteem. Constructive criticism is beneficial
carpool - gora kids will do the same things as brown kids. I dont understand this where this generalisation of saying western/gora kids are worse the pakistani kids has cropped up from, its a form of racism just like saying all black people are criminals.
Whether u like it or not sex, drugs n alochol are prevalent and easily accesible everywhere. If teenagers growin up wish to experiment you cant really stop them. Can u watch someone 24 hours a day? i think not. At least in the west they try to educate children about the dangers, where as in Pakistan everythink is brushed under the carpet, which if anything makes kids and teenagers more curious and more likely to try it.
wondurgirl - im not talkin about the rich spoilt kids in pakistan who live in big kothees wid 10 nokaar.. im talkin bout overseas parents, who feel that they have to keep control and bringing an element of old school 'fear' with their parenting style. Basically copying their parents. I've heard many desi parents saying "kids aint scared of their parents like we were"
Look, shortdog every family is different in the way they handle things. Some parents do evoke fear in their children's hearts and they grow up just fine and later on joke about it. Some parents even give their children a whopping and kids grow up to love their parents for it and later joke about it--- in fact there was this whole one thread where everyone related about the worst whopping they ever got, and most of those people loved there parents. Some parents yell to get points across, and many times it works.
Other parents never yell or scream and there children have no fear of their paretns, and many of these kids grow up fine. However, others don't- they grow up end up doing controversial things.
Screaming, yelling, whopping, instilling fear in the hearts of children are not new Parental techiniques limited to desi parents. Have you not heard goray people say: "spare the rod, spoil the child," or say now " if I did that in front of my dad....." "these days parents are just not hard on their kids anymore- if I did that while i was growing up....." and on and on? Well I have- many a times. Its's nothing limited to desi parents or to any culture and to say so is a gross generalization.
Also, the point that you make where "at least in the West they try to educated their kids" about drugs. Well if you grew in the West in the mid-late 90s there was program called DARE that did just that-- and guess what- this program became so controversial- and showed NO CHANGES in drug usage in kids later on- in fact I believe, studied showed MORE usage they said it was because kids became more aware of what was out there and wanted to try those things.
Regardless of why people use drugs it is surely not limited to their "desi" upbringing (and many many factors are involved-povery, parents working all the time and not watching their kids, parents using drugs themselves, peer pressure, etc all play a role. ) and** neither do we see more desi kids in the West using drugs then their more "western/goray" counterparts**- so to say that pakistani kids use drugs because their parents don't talk about it is a gross statment with little evidence to back it up. In many desi households it's a given not to do things like that- and that's the end of story.