**Pakistani stars react to the escalating tension between Pakistan and India
Pakistani artistes – musicians and actors especially - have been making hay while the sun has shone brightly on the peace process between India and Pakistan. But that relationship-building process seems to be in jeopardy now that the bridge has been dislodged. Instep Today talks to the stars who frequent India and get their opinions on what might happen next…**
Fakhir
"Blaming the Muslims straight up without any evidence is childish. It's disappointing to see the section of media blaming Pakistanis and Muslims for crimes against humanity. We condemn this violence in Pakistan as well as anywhere in the world and we feel for Indians. There will be a political showdown, muscle flexing and drama for some time and hopefully nothing serious is going to happen in the end. I'm hoping 2009 would be a better year. Last night, I saw scrolls of news stating Pakistani films, musicians and dramas are banned in India and I thought it was bizarre. Politicians and philosophers in the world don't react like that.
If Indian films and channels are restricted here, like very smartly restricted in India, it would be great for our own dramas and music industry. Indian channels were restricted earlier and that's when Pakistani pop bloomed. And that way, we will learn to defend our own people and expertise. It would be an opportunity for us."
Xulfi
Of course the Mumbai blasts have affected not only the Indo-Pak relationship but the whole exchange of talent too. We were supposed to travel to India this month for the shoot of our two songs which are being incorporated in upcoming movies, 'Aloo Chat' and 'Aasman' but we had to call off our trip. We were even there for their music launch because of the whole situation. We were supposed to shoot one of our songs in India too but now we are going to Malaysia for its shooting.
The producers asked us not to come right now but that was not because of any anti-Pakistan sentiment but purely because of the security reasons. There are few people who blame Pakistan for it and they are probably the political sources. The general people have no hatred for Pakistanis. And, we know very well that the political stance is always different from the general stance. So politically there might be the element of detestation but on a people level, they are very welcoming.
For now, we can only wait and watch how the situation turns out to be in near future because it's not that we are afraid to go to India, we are not even safe in our country. Don't forget what happened at the World Performing Arts Festival and the recent riots in Karachi. It's really difficult to go indulge in any recreational activity at home too, so crossing the border is a different ball game altogether.
Rohail Hyatt
I don't think anyone can say that what happened in India was right. It's a very complex situation and to get a full flavour of what happened one needs to see the whole picture. However the role played by the Indian and western media has been so irresponsible, while our media has played a more responsible role, even if there are some war mongering elements here. I may sound stupid, but I feel like this is a trap and people seem to fall into it. Personally, I was very sad at what happened. But then within the first hour - CNN, BBC and then the Indian media all joined and said it's Islamic terrorists who have done it. On what basis? It's shocking - it's instantly b*****ng us as guilty, both because of the country we belong to as well as our faith. From empathizing with India, I felt this anger at the fingers being pointed at us, that we've been implicated in this. And there are so many conspiracy theories - how do they know the attackers were from Pakistan? One can quite easily distinguish between Indians and Pakistanis and the faces that they've shown on television look like Indians. And no one in Pakistan knows of these people, where they've hailed from, no one has come forward saying they know them. We have been suddenly sidelined and told off as guilty!
Anger has started rising - I was watching television yesterday and these people were calling in saying cinemas should be closed which have Indian films running in them. But the kind of angry sentiment that has come out from the Indians, it is like they haven't accepted the reality of Pakistan. Indians have to do some soul searching. I was watching this program on Indian television, which had an SMS poll where 90 percent of respondents said India should attack Pakistan. There's war mongering going on. India is not a tolerant society - they have hard line elements like the BJP there.
Bal Thackeray has already announced that Pakistani comedians or singers shouldn't come to India. And where is the western media when Christians are being massacred in India or unarmed protestors are being killed in Kashmir? Isn't that terrorism as well? Or when 160 people are killed in Afghanistan because a bomb fell on a wedding; and most of those who die are kids.
What I think needs to happen is that people have to come together and it has to be a people-to-people movement. However there isn't any easy solution to this. I'd be the biggest fool in the world to have Indian artists come here to perform in this situation, for instance. What we need to do is to set a good example, and lead by it if the spotlight is on us. We need to not compromise on our defense but also have a very friendly approach. How that translates into art and media is still something that needs to be seen. We cannot have a tit-for-tat approach. There will be a ray of hope when better sense prevails, and I see the future in the people.
Shallum Xavier
Indian media just needed someone to blame it on and of course Pakistan is the easiest target. It's just a political game because of which the entertainment industry is suffering. In fact their party, Shiv Sena, has announced that they won't let any Pakistani artist come to India for an album launch or a concert. It's not that everyone is against Pakistan over there but there are extremist forces who are very vocal about their sentiments towards Pakistan.
We should understand the whole political game. They will be holding elections within a few months time and BJP probably wants to come back to power as it has the support of Indian extremist parties. By instilling anti-Pakistan sentiments they might increase their vote bank too.
The Mumbai blasts were a major set back for me as well as. I have been to all the places that are damaged under the attack. We used to hang out at the Leopolds Café in Colaba market which is supposed to be one of the most secure places of the city. And something of that magnitude happening in such safe areas is shocking as well as saddening.
The whole incident has already started affecting the relationship between India and Pakistan. We had to tour India this month, then in January again and something was planned for February too but now everything has been called off. I repeat, not postponed but called off! And, it's not just because they didn't want to put our lives in danger but also because they don't want us to come to their country now.
I personally recommend all Pakistani artists not to visit India as it's not safe. Especially, for the singers because concerts are more publicized so there is a greater risk to perform. Just think out of the box and be safe wherever you are!
Mekaal Hasan
Its too premature to say anything. Given the statements made about Pakistan in India, relations will probably be affected for the worse, but one can't say at this stage. One hopes that things work out using the diplomatic channels between the countries.
Ali Noor
Initally Ali Noor refused to comment on the incident because he believes his views are 'different' from the rest and that's why he doesn't want them get in print. But later he agreed to give a statement on record.
"Instead of crying over it, do something!"
Haniya Aslam
Our tour to India has been postponed due to the blasts. The organizer who we were to perform with called us and told us the Pak-India issues need to be sorted out. He said it has been postponed, not cancelled due to the uncertainty about what is going to happen next. I guess there is a feeling that is bad but it will hopefully blow over soon. There is a sense of disappointment as this was our first tour to India. With time, everything will get better as it will blow out of the water. There have always been complications between India and Pakistan and they always tend to get sorted out. "