pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dramas

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

why all this not applies to India? why don't they show our shows? and please don't come up with the answer that our productions don't have potential viewership there. Even our dramas in 80s shown their professional academies

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

I will repeat what I said earlier, "capital" is beyond "India", "Pakistan", "Jewish", "American" distinction. It has no religion, no ethnicity and no country. However, consumers are definitely divided into boundaries to maximize the potential of business market. In case of India, of course its the biggest consumer market and business dynamics r in their favour in this reference.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

I noticed this when I was switching through channels at home. It was weird. At first I was like...is this a Pakistani drama with white people? Then I realized it was all dubbed.

Who watches this crap?

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

Yasir Pirzadah - zara hat key - dramay - Jang Columns

a very incisive commentary on the whole issue. He is spot on when he talks of the hypocrisy of the media houses. At the end it is a battle for profits and cultural issues are being unncessarily dragged into it.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

Well, why is it that only Pakistani TV needs to show foriegn shows to stay afloat. I don't know any American channel that shows foreign shows during prime time that are horrendously dubbed.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

why do ppl make sucha big deal ?? if indian dramas are shown then why not turkish? those who dont wanna watch them- DONT!

wont channels telecast what brings them the most $? i guess it's the turkish dramas then..

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

I don’t think Indian dramas should be shown either. :chai: Meh, whatever floats Pakistani awaams boat. Soon when there may not be any Pakistani shows left which would be a tragedy but hey you get to watch poorly dubbed Turkish shows.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

yes u r right. dubbed versions costs less.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

In August this blogger came up with this story…check this out
Cafe Pyala: How One Channel Could Shake Up Pakistan’s Media Scene

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

This particular Turkish drama has been shown all across the Arab world and eastern Europe.. It’s also been discussed by the BBC for its widespread popularity..

Not sure why it’s become an issue in Pakistan :confused:

I’ve seen it and it’s actually really good.. the storyline is a bit controversial but there’s no nudity or ‘proper’ bedroom scenes.. it’s conservative by western standards but liberal by eastern I guess..

If people don’t want to watch they don’t have to.. Seems a bit petty to me to try and ban foreign tv.. same with India not showing Pak dramas

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

^ Right!! Why get into others peoples business all the time. If you don’t like the show, don’t watch it! But let those who want to watch it do so. None of your business.
PS. I haven’t seen the show, can’t get past the horrible dubbing :bummer:

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

^^Why is it petty to support and cultivate your own talent?

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

You don’t see a problem that’s fine but don’t call me petty or others who feel otherwise.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

I didn't say it was, did I??

I said I think it's** petty to try and ban foreign dramas..** Why the need to stop ppl doing something just because it's not your type of thing? I do think it's petty (and narrow-minded) to make an issue out of tv shows just because they come from outside Pakistan.. If it was not Pakistan and some other country I'm sure a lot of ppl here would be saying 'omg how narrow-minded.. what are they afraid of??' As I mentioned I think the same about India banning Pak dramas as well..

It IS perfectly possible to cultivate + encourage your own talent without resorting to this..

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

Incidently, those dramas from the 80s are the only dramas that are shown in their academies, because those dramas were class. Current crop of Pakistani dramas are rubbish, revolving around themes copied from indian soaps, ala saas bahu.

Samina Ahmed was on one of the talk shows recently, and when she was asked about why Indian shows are ok for you, but you insist on protesting against this new breed of turkish shows, she responded by saying that 'we tolerated indian shows for a while, but with these new dramas, pani sar sey guzar gaya hai'. So according to her, just 1 turkish drama turned out to be the tipping point, all the while they were 'tolerating' the barrage of indian shows on each channel.

This fight is as much between actors and voice-over artists as it is between Pak and turkish dramas. Our production houses are just being cry babies. They are ok with indian stuff, will dance to indian songs in their dramas, morning shows, and will gladly go over to act in a c grade indian movie if asked, but they are not OK with a turkish drama.

As for the cultural aspect they cite so frequently, our own Paksitani dramas have shown what borders on filth at times. Bhabi dewar affairs, out-of-wedlock children, saali behnoi affairs are common place in our dramas. This is certainly not our culture.

These celebrities are not protesting turkish dramas...they are protesting against the hit their own production houses are taking, since they had a monopoly to date. Its a financial issue, not cultural. THat is why most of the people you see protesting are owners of some production house.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

Agree to the point, but Indian content should also not have been promoted freely a decade ago. It affected our own dramas badly which got glamourised over the period. Upto 90s PTV was able to produce classics revolving around real issues in decent manner and people still remember those dramas unlike the fake hyped stuff being telecasted from all the channels.

Re: pakistani media celeberities to protest at karachi press club against turkish dra

People are free to watch whatever they choose, whether it be Indian content or Turkish content. HOWEVER, that content should not be shown at the expense of the Pakistani industry: to be clear, NOT on Pakistani channels. Pakistani channel = Pakistani show. Everything else can be shown on international channels.