Pakistani Couple beat Tribal Veto on Wedding

Pakistani couple beat tribal veto on wedding

April 01, 2004

From Zahid Hussain in Islamabad

THE ordeal of two young lovers who risked death for defying a strict tribal code of honour finally ended this week when they were reunited by a Pakistani court order that validated their marriage.
Shaista Almani, 23, a former schoolteacher, and Blakh Sher Mahar, her husband, are now living together in police quarters in Karachi.

The two, who belong to opposing tribes, were married in June last year, but were forced to flee their homes after tribal elders ruled that they should be killed for insulting their honour. The newlyweds were separated when armed tribesmen kidnapped Mr Mahar and Ms Almani fled for her life.

Scores of human rights activists and lawyers cheered the couple as they emerged from the courtroom on Tuesday, holding each other. “We are happy to be together again,” an ecstatic Ms Almani said.

Mr Mahar was presented to the court after police rescued him from a private tribal jail in his hometown of Pannu Aqil in the southern Sindh province, where he had been confined illegally for the past three months.

After recording their statements, the court ruled that the couple were free to live together. “They are free citizens and can decide for themselves,” the court ruled.

**Human rights organisations have described the ruling as a serious blow to the illegal parallel tribal judicial system. “The decision has strengthened the public confidence in the country’s judiciary,” Anis Haroon, a leader of Women Action Forum, said. “It has come as a serious blow to the inhuman and retrogressive tribal custom.” **
The couple were taken to their residence under heavy police protection because of a fear of attack by tribesmen. Mr Mahar said that they had no intention of leaving the country.

The two committed the “ultimate crime” under a hidebound tribal code when they fell in love and decided to marry. Tribal custom prohibits a woman from marrying a man of her choice and outside the tribe. The couple had their parents’ blessing to wed, but the tribal elders took offence.

Tension started to mount as Almani tribesmen threatened to attack the groom’s family, forcing them to flee town. They also took Shaista Almani’s parents and six of her siblings hostage and threatened to kill them if she did not break the marriage and return to the town.

In a tribal system deeply entrenched in many parts of Pakistan, disputes over marriage often trigger a blood feud between the tribes that continues for decades. Hundreds of people become victims of revenge each year as tribes fight for their “honour”.

The couple had moved secretly from place to place but were tracked down by tribesmen who raided their apartment in Karachi and kidnapped Mr Mahar. Under the threat of death, he divorced Ms Almani. He told the court that his action was under duress and did not have any legal validity.

President Musharraf intervened this year after a desperate appeal for help from Ms Almani, vowing to protect her and ordering the government of Sindh province to ensure her safety. Since then she has been living in police quarters in Karachi. The Government has also offered her a job with the police.

Crime against women is a big challenge for General Musharraf, who is trying to project Pakistan’s image as a modern Muslim state. More than 700 women died in the name of honour across Pakistan last year. Most of them were killed either by their family members or on the orders of the tribal council.

=============================================

The courts and police come in for plenty of criticism in Pakistan, so it’s only fair to give them some credit for a job well done. Another proud day for Pakistan :k:

**Human rights organisations have described the ruling as a serious blow to the illegal parallel tribal judicial system. “The decision has strengthened the public confidence in the country’s judiciary,” Anis Haroon, a leader of Women Action Forum, said. “It has come as a serious blow to the inhuman and retrogressive tribal custom.” **

Go to see the lead that President Musharraf has taken on the issue of women’s rights, has now finally energised our courts to challenge the tribal jahils. :k:

What state/province? which tribes?

Mr Mahar was presented to the court after police rescued him from a private tribal jail in his hometown of Pannu Aqil in the southern Sindh province

It's in Sindh but it's not restricted to Sindh. I remember reading about some Pakhtun girl who married a Mohajir and the girl's tribe wouldn't accept it claiming she was to marry someone from their clan. They turned up in court and shot the man who survived. I think the couple then got refuge in a European country, I'm not sure.

ok. missed that bit..ta..
It's sad, jahiliah still exists,, not only in pakistan, but in other muslim countries where tribal systems are strong,, like somalia..etc.

laykun us banday ne to us ko talaq nai de dee thee :confused:

I believe that i readt that the court ruled that the talaq was not valid, because he was forced to do it by the threat of death

It almost seems as if people from tribal areas go through such daring events just to get out. Call me a cynic, but its almost assured that if such a case is made public, human rights orgs will be all over the place, and more importantly, countries will offer you assylum, or at the very least, you will get a ticket out of the tribal areas, into the city.

I saw Shaista Almani's interview on tv back when her case was fresh, and in that half hour interview, in response to almost every question, her response seemed to focus on financial and economic factors more than anything else. SHe was asked as to what she would like for the government to do. THe interviewer meant to ask, what kind of steps she would want the government to take in order to prevent such cases. And her response was that she'd like the govt to provide her accomodation in Karachi, help her brother come over to Karachi as well, and to give her a job. She repeated this in response to several other questions as well, and it almost seemed her motives were predetermined.

Agreed that there is a lot of intimidation in tribal areas, but it should be dealt with in a more streamlined way, by imposing Pakistan state laws in those areas, rather than have the president personally intervene in one or two odd cases in order to make positive headlines. 50 cases get swept under the rug, and one case gets highlighted. The 'victims' get Belgian nationality, and case is closed.

Some years ago, in my grandfathers village, its only half an hour away from Islamabad, two families were rotted as a girl and a boy married out of love and ran away. It was really pathetic, one day we go to the village and everyone was in uproar, we asked what has happened, they said that in the down village, yesterday some men have killed 11 members of the boys family, the loved birds had ran away, leaving the conflict behind, some men from the girl's side came to the house of the boys family and started shooting, they killed everyone, mostly females including childern, only one small boy survived as he hid behind a door. It was a masacar, as they also used knives and other sharp things.

Then one year later, the man, who ran away with the girl and married her, said he wants to have peace with the other family, so they all come to the meeting point, somewhere in the city, there he pretends that he wants to forgive, but he doesnt, he and his friends take revenge and kill all the people who came for the peace resolutions, about 10 people, I think.

To think of how stupid this is, to kill in the name of honour, makes me sick everytime I read such news.

wow i had no idea SaadiaB was sicilian.

It's not a tribal thing, its an all out Pakistani thing, Indian thing, Arab thing and all those that believe in "Honor".

I remember a Pakhtun guy in love with this girl in Islamabad, since he was poor, and the girl Punjabi family rich, of course the family of the girls were opposed to the whole thing. I'm putting away the racail factor here for a reason. Now, what the girl family did, that they had contacts, high contacts, they had the police arrested all the males of the guy family, then taken to jail, and beaten the you know what out. Including their old aged father. Later the father died, though the sons servived, so what they do?

Well :- ) the girl arranged not only her self but also her younger sister for the guy other brother, got married, and ran away.

In cases like these, the only loser at the end is the family, if and when it comes to honor, and if and when the girls decide to run away.

This is nothing new, it's so common. I bet that almost everyone here knows some that went through this.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Mr Xtreme: *
It's in Sindh but it's not restricted to Sindh. I remember reading about some Pakhtun girl who married a Mohajir and the girl's tribe wouldn't accept it claiming she was to marry someone from their clan. They turned up in court and shot the man who survived. I think the couple then got refuge in a European country, I'm not sure.
[/QUOTE]

They were both killed, unles you are talking about some other incident.

lol not really, it was a big news… in the front page of every national newspapers, with pictures and all .. I have to say our village gained a lot of publicity. :fraudia: sicilian style.

funny thing is that both families were from the same family, tribe, only their honor was hurt, that the couple ran away, pind people are very emotional.

This is the story I was talking about:

Despatches
Phil Goodwin
Islamabad

The man at the centre of a controversy in Pakistan because of his marriage to a woman without her father’s consent, has been shot and seriously injured outside a court in the city of Karachi. The man, Kanwar Ahsan, who was being taken to the court under police protection, received at least four bullet wounds. Three policemen were also injured. The authorities have arrested four men in connection with the shooting, including the man who had earlier been engaged to the woman. From Islamabad Phil Goodwin reports.

This is a tragic development in a controversy which has gripped Pakistan for weeks. The issue first surfaced when the ethnic Pashtun community in Karachi held demonstrations and called a nationwide strike, to protest at what they allege was the kidnapping of a local women, Riffat Afridi.

Her father said Kanwar Ahsan had abducted her. Police located them and they were both arrested.

She later appeared in court and testified that she had been engaged to another man but had chosen to run away from home and marry Kanwar Ahsan. They’ve since both been held in protective custody.

Kanwar Ahsan had said he feared for his life. The man that Riffat Afridi was originally engaged to is among those arrested in connection with his shooting.

Marrying for love in Pakistan defies longstanding traditions in which families choose the marriage partners for their children. The tradition is especially strong in the ethnic Pashtun community.

The human rights commission of Pakistan says many women are currently in prison throughout the country, awaiting the hearing of cases brought by their families who are challenging their marriages. Last year in a high profile case a woman, Saima Waheed, was taken to court by her father for marrying the man she loved without consent, she won her case on appeal.

Isnt it ironic that every of your post has pakhtuns being opressed in them :hehe:

Good to seel Ms Almani and her husband finally together but if they will remain in pakistan they will be killed pretty soon, because for tribal people they dont care about country or human laws. if they have to kill some one for honour they simply have to, no matter what.

so they should be trying their best atm to get asylum anywhere outside pakistan. and never come back no matter what happens.

i remmebr a PTV drama long time ago , in which Safee Muhammad was a feudallord and his daughter got married with some guy she liked and then they flew away from pakistan, but in a twist safee called his daughter and said they are happy for her and ok with her decission bla bla bla , asked her to come back, girl went crazy with happines that her father is ok now and came back to pakistan and while on the way to home from airport was shot dead in cab by hitmen hired by her father.

Moral of the story: either dont break tribal rules and laws and if you have done that then there is no turning back what so ever.

we were discussing the shaista almani case today at lunch in the office…a sindhi guy was of the opinion that this girl was not bad looking at all and the guy she chose was such a ‘lallu’ he was laughing in the interview when they were asking him on tv what he thought…atleast if she had to do all this she could have chosen some better guy :smiley: :hehe:

Finally!!!!!!!
Congrats to the couple;

Well said, way to go mushy! :k:

Spock, isn’t it funny how all 9308 of your posts are all alike: single line filled with grunts and noises? :slight_smile:

Sultan Suri speaks the truth, Spock. Maybe you can’t hanlde it Spock, isn’t it funny that you can’t handle it Spock?

Spock, just concentrate on steering the ship will yah…Spock. :hehe: