Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

in case this is true, we must do a lot to change the situation for equality and fairness for all. any personal experiences or anecdotes and how people in that situation successfully came out.
although i definitely think, this article is written in a contemptous mode.

dushi

Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

The Christians in Pakistan continue to face discrimination from a majority of employers on a level akin to what African Americans experienced in the Southern US before the Civil Rights movement. In vocational terms, for Pakistanis, being a Christian means being a janitor, a brick-maker, or working in sewage. They are constantly denied jobs, not based on their merit, but based on their religion. Instead of racism, Pakistan excels in “religion-ism.”

Recent comments by the Catholic Archbishop of Pakistan, Lawrence J. Saldana, have highlighted the severe discrimination that many Christians face when looking for jobs. The Archbishop delivered these comments while speaking at a ceremony held in connection with Prince Charles’s visit to the Anglican Cathedral Church of the Resurrection in Lahore on November 2.

A number of factors dim job prospects for Pakistani Christians – most of whom are condemned to do menial cleaning jobs due to their appalling socio-economic situation.

The reason Pakistani Christians do not obtain dignified jobs is not their inability to measure up to the criteria laid down for the jobs. Rather, in most cases, it is the hardened and intolerant mindsets of employers that thwart their upward social mobility.

The Lowest of the Low

Most Pakistani Christians work as janitors. They are born in slums deprived of even the most basic civic and health amenities. Even if a Christian obtains decent employment, his life-time efforts to rid himself of the ‘janitor label’ will prove futile. Some employers might be willing to hire talented Christians for certain jobs, but refuse because of the possibility of angering the majority-Muslim workforce. Thus they seal the continued marginalization of the Christian community.

The unfortunate fact that a large majority of Pakistani Christians eke out a living by doing jobs that are looked down upon by the society does not and should not mean that Pakistani Christians are condemned to do basic jobs. ‘Like and dislike’ of the existing Muslim workers may be one factor that goes against Christian candidates looking for jobs, but of more substantial importance is how a Muslim employer perceives Christians.

If only merit determined whether a person could obtain a job, the prospects for Christians assuming dignified jobs would become far better than what they are at present. The problem is that a candidate’s qualifications for the job are not a factor in job-hiring process. Instead, religious affiliation overrides the candidate’s abilities.

Educated Christians Can’t Find the Jobs They Trained to Do

Failing to obtain jobs that match their abilities, a sizable number of young educated Christian men and women resort to teaching at missionary schools. These young Christians fail to provide the best education since they only take up teaching as a profession after giving up their quest for the jobs they think they are made for. Seeing their faith as a hindrance in their drive for upward social mobility they develop a sense of deprivation, disillusionment, and a nagging inferiority complex.

Those from among the educated Christians who somehow or other do manage to gain jobs that interest them are vulnerable to implicit and explicit criticisms by their Muslim colleagues targeting their poor Christian background or their faith.

Christian girls aspiring to become nurses often face difficulties in getting admissions to government-run nursing schools. The same holds true for registered Christian nurses who find it difficult to find jobs in the government sector.

Some Muslim candidates who fail to outshine their Christian contenders because they lack talent ultimately secure their wanted jobs by giving bribe money and making use of the economic leverage they enjoy over Christians and members of other religious minority communities.

The Source of Discrimination: Semi-literate Muslim Clerics

All of this can be traced back to semi-literate Muslim clerics at hard-line religious schools who seem bent upon negatively influencing the minds of the majority of Muslims while they are young and impressionable. The young boarders of the religious schools are given religious education, but during their time at the Madrassahs (religious schools) they also learn lessons of intolerance that get so indelibly etched on their minds that they find it hard to unlearn them even if they want to at a later stage in life. The graduates of the radical religious schools perceive people of faiths other than Islam as their enemies.

Though they may realize the pernicious repercussions their actions may have on the already down-trodden minority communities, fundamentalist Muslim clerics continue to unleash hate propaganda both in the religious schools as well as in the mosques where they preach.

Given the credentials of most of the teachers at the radical Islamic religious schools, it is not hard to imagine to what extent the mind of a child entering a Madrassah would have been prejudiced against other faiths and their followers at the time of his exit from the school.

Constitutional Discrimination

Pakistan’s constitution denies non-Muslims the privilege of assuming the high-profile offices of the Speaker of the National Assembly (Lower House of Parliament), Chief of Army Staff, Prime Minister and President. While it is obvious that a constitutional amendment is required before non-Muslim citizens of Pakistan could aspire to these positions, the establishment of a culture of tolerance and respect for people of all faiths in the country could at least help the weaker segments of society attain jobs which are theoretically open to them.

Media and a Way Forward?

Some time back a Pakistani TV station was criticized by Christians for having a Muslim acting as a Christian given the role of a cleaner in one of the TV station’s programs.

The Pakistani Christian community expressed its anger, alleging that assigning the sweeper role to the actor acting as a Christian conveyed the message to the audience that Christians are only fit for janitorial jobs.

The TV station would have done better if it had aired a documentary featuring some great Pakistani Christians who served the country in respectable positions. It would not only give a sense of recognition to those featured in the documentary, but it would also help allay the sense of deprivation and disillusionment that affects most Pakistani Christians.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

This is something that truly breaks my heart. Although I am gora raised in the west as a christian, I would love to live over there. I am not a practicing christian and am learning the Koran and Islaam and liking it. But I could not live over there because of the discrimnation and fear for my children who have blue eyes and a gora mother.

If there were more of a "live and LET live" attitude over there, the economy could turn around so very quickly your head would spin. If it were seen as a "safe" place to visit, the tourism income has limitless potential. The sad and staggering figures of "brain drain" where highly educated professionals leave the country would abate.

Although it all seems like common sense to me, these hatred-preaching Mullahs never seem to lack for followers.
This is what needs to be realized and addressed.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

'nuff said
they need to be controlled
and challenged
when was the last time any of us opposed an imam at a masjid even if we did not like what he was saying…
if people stay ambivalent and apathetic towards it, nothing will change for the better.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

But dont you think the prejudice is everywhere - my father at first couldnt find a job in U.K. (Bath) even though he has done his mba from Oxford University and then Bath University and got the highest % of all, because of his nationality i.e. Pakistani, color i.e. brown - so i guess its everywhere - rather then critisizing pakistan look at the countries as well. and at first even when he got accepted by universities like oxford, bath, harvard (usa) etc but he didnt get accepted by kings uni and thats because of his nationality.
my teacher (who moved from india to Pakistan) told me that some muslims like the actors in india are well of but many arent given their rights. they arent even let to practise their religion properly.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

Don't worry Mo3, Pakistanis have nothing against blue eyed people with gori mothers, we only discriminate agains the charred skin desi christians who call each other "Jaaraj"(George).

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

To a certain degree, you are right, tee. Discrimination is everywhere on the planet. But in places like USA, its typically frowned upon and prosecuted so that you do not fear for your life or that of your family for a religious belief or a way of life. This is a somewhat naive statement I realize....but Pakistan is a country of Muslims. When there is someone different, they are persecuted in a manner that seems to go far beyond what would be tolerated in more "mixed" countries I think. And the intolerance is fueled by the ignorant Mullahs.

In western countries, yes there IS discrimination. But there is also a major effort to overcome or at least tolerate differences.

Yes I'm going to get beat up about these statements, yes there are exceptions and yes there have been horrible instances of discrimination in the west...I'm just speaking "generally" and also to the subject of this particular thread - that of discrimination "over there" ok?

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

ppl have faced issues for being different everywhere, institutionalized or not. Aside from the govt offices, there is no real official policy that prohibits hiring minorities, however it happens, back in the 80s i recall reading ads that emphasized that the applicant must be punjabi or sindhi .. or holder of a domicile of such and such place..basically limiting applicant pool even tough that had nothing to dow ith the job requirements.

Canda has seen a lot of issues for new immigrants, to a point that ppl I know left Canada after they had their citizenship sayng that now they ahve a safety net and kids can also come for education there and work and all, but for now they are headed back to pak.

there are glass celings for minorities, race, religion, nationality and gender..even in US.

None of this is right, and we should be speaking up against injustice everywhere but especially in places where we have an impact, e.g. for me it would be US, UK and Pakistan. for others it may be canada and australia etc. WHat mean is that you cant do a whole lot for some completely unrelated country, you have more impact in countries where you live, work or have associations with.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

obviously if someone is outcasted to such an extend they will take their frustration out on everyother religion even if the christians in Pakistan are brown skinned - what do the whites in U.K. or U.S.A have to worry about (other then their own leaders) to be preudice against others?
they have been prejudice against everyone be it blacks, browns, asians...
pakistanis toh have been pushed so much so i guess they are bound to get provoked - compared to U.S of A whats pakistan's size? nothing even then U.S.A shows that they have threat from these 3rd world countries - while the indians are still treated well because they take the water from Kashmir (as shown in local U.K channel documentary once) and send it to U.K - here the Pakistanis are almost out of breath shouting for America to help them with the kashimir issue...but obviously if they (america) does that then they (britian) wont get the water and britian and america are friends (you know that dont you).
A pakistani cant even think of going to U.S and kill the people reason for their misery so i guess they use the pakistani christains as alternatives.
i am not saying that its ok - NO! it is wrong to harm anyone but if you dont see whats going on in these so called "peace loving" countries then i guess you shouldnt blame these people as well.
p.s. i guess if christians are leading miserable lives in Pakistan then well dont you think muslims are also going through issues in their own country - but since christianity is a different religion it comes in the front.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

i have association with CANADA, UNITED KINGDOM AND UNITED STATES along with PAKISTAN so i am speaking of what i have seen in these countries. not anywhere else (just for the record).

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

teelo, fine so issues exist, the questiin then is what d we do about it? atleast in US you have EEO and other laws to try and protect ppl. Indeed employers can try and get around those if they choose.

Now lets forget about the global political scene, and focus on what is right. if minorities are not getting opportunities in pakistan, then all Pakistanis need to speak up. I agree wit you that it is not just christians..it is other groups too. Mush of teh frustration in karachi was that urdu speaking folks were not getting hired by sindhis and punjabis back in the day, and i guess it still happens today. I think religous minorities may get it worse, just like muslims in India. But we can not discount it.

emplyment law in Pakistan needs to be revamped anyways, lasttime I read parts of it , it was dated and seemed like something from pre partition days repackaged..actually with chunks taken out.

I have written before that we have no protection and no enforced rules regarding domestic workers etc either. and while Pakistanis sit proudly and claim that they have 10 servants, its a shame that those workers dont have many rights and facilities that they should.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

Also Canada which has so many people from different nationalites other then pure Canadian them selves used to have a national anthem in which they had words like WHITE CANADA - i dont remember the exact words - but it clearly shows the prejudice and treating others as inferiors -
if you know about the Komagata Maru, in which about 2050 people from India (Muslims, Hindus and Punjabis) came to Canada in about 1900 and they were stopped on the bay and not let to come out of the ship - is a very big sign of prejudice here. later on these people were sent back after a halt for about 2 months only 24 out of 150 passengers was forced to go back to India and there the people of the ship were shot to death the day they stepped on the indian soil by british soldiers.
and you know about the american invasions over afghanistan and iraq, isreal invasion over palastine and the british invation over india -
who have we learned to kill from? i guess early british and americans, since they used to show prejudice against other in earlier times.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

Comming to Pakistan well obviously when you see no option, no way out one will act in a certian way - what is Pakistan? is it a great prosprous country? NO! as a matter of fact its a third world country - it not only has these issues but other issues as well -
how to give back their over dues, how to protect themselves from being called as a terrorist state, and so forth.
day by day the country is going into dumps.
stupid uneducated taporis and gundas are appointed as nazims over educated, university graduated guys because of this regardless of religion or mother tounge these people have to leave their country and go abroad, rather then finding out solutions the government is showing the upper layer of the countrys improvement by planting few trees on the side walks and all - do you expect such a country to have the time about thinking about christians for now? the dominating countries have everything in ever feild; power money technology everything yet there is prejudice so can you blame Pakistan? i say no!

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

Yes its very wrong to feel proud about having 10 servants and all but obviously those 10 servants to need to earn somthing to take care of their families, thats why they work - if they had the option then they wouldnt have no matter how much one paid them. so its their only way or earning, employing someone to earn for themseleves and then bragging about it is not all wrong.
its better to bring about changes rather then debating over here - you want change you bring it - otherwise its very easy to sit on your bed/ desk and type on your laptop and demand for changes.
you yourself are living in U.S. right? there are so many Indians in Canada and even in America or be it any part of the world who actually work hard to bring improvements to their country why dont you or any pakistanis who ask for a miracalous sudden change.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

thanks or no thanks for ur bits.

ur guilt trips and attempts at sarcastic recommendations seem more like u are dieing to squirm and compare India people with Pakistani people.

first of all, i need to stop the comparison.
it makes u look no more better than u would aspire to feel like.
before knowing me or other Pakistanis at this forum, u have no right to make pre judgments how we are and what we think about ANY ISSUE or this issue.
ur loyalty to ur country and ur people is commendable, do not forget though, that when u get a chance to say something as a suggestion t a problem, or a conflict of interest, u should have a tone and a well reasoned argument. the reason i posted this here, is because i do not want this associated to any country and its people. had i been insensitive, i would have given it a bloody damn tinker to share it here, when i read it.

u can conveniently take ur third world label back to ur country & only apply it there, since u are very good at flattering the international corporate interests due to which the politics and cultural cruelties in India that have always reflected a truly sorry state of affairs there in, yet, i never would take that as a downgrading opportunity to belittle and make ignorant statements for those issues.

i'v Indian hindu & sikh colleagues and they are so upset at their country when it comes to a lot more gruesome caste system discrimination.

u need to wake up & if u got a chance to respond to a thread at a forum - sound credible, not despicable, instead of sounding like some patient and sensible world citizen, clear of personal prejudices.

best,

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

I blame Pakistanis, wherethere is a will there is a way. Laws are not needed for people to do what is right, people should do what is right, laws would attemt to make sure that people who dont want to do right atre kinda bound to do what is right.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

*Yes its very wrong to feel proud about having 10 servants and all but obviously those 10 servants to need to earn somthing to take care of their families, thats why they work - if they had the option then they wouldnt have no matter how much one paid them. so its their only way or earning, employing someone to earn for themseleves and then bragging about it is not all wrong. *

yep but sweatshops, bonded labor, and abusive domestic labor is not right. people not earning enough leeds to all kinds of social issues

*its better to bring about changes rather then debating over here - you want change you bring it - otherwise its very easy to sit on your bed/ desk and type on your laptop and demand for changes. *

I dont like bragging :) but I do what I can working with an assortment of groups ranging from those based in pakistan to those set up by expats and headquarted in US. And have had direct discussions with people ranging from high court judges, civil rights attorneys and even the PM of Pakistan

posting on a forum to discuss/share/learn and working directly to bring about change is not mutually exclusive you know :)

you yourself are living in U.S. right? there are so many Indians in Canada and even in America or be it any part of the world who actually work hard to bring improvements to their country why dont you or any pakistanis who ask for a miracalous sudden change.

No one is asking for a miraculous sudden change, it will not come whether the change is made into some law overnight or whether locals or expats are doign all that they can.

I mean have the slums in Indian cities gone away? is HIV eradicated? No...yet I know ppl who are working to that effect.

Your statement assuming that Pakistanis in pakistan or abroad are not doing anything to bring about change is based simply in ignorance.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

I'm not trying to belittle the christian population's plight but just so you guys know prejudice and racism is way too rampant in the desi psyche.

Someone look up an ethnicity of people called Makraanis. They are a population of black people (more politically correct would be African-Pakistani)living in Sindh. They too face extreme racism and prejudice, given their luck - they are black and extremely poor.

Bias and prejudice is rampant everywhere. It sucks that the christian minority is one of those targetted by bias but theres others caught in the same boat too.

Re: Pakistan’s Chronic Pattern of Employment Discrimination against Christians

we simply need to NOT DO anything wrong that other people, races are doing to their own fellow citizens.
injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
to my mind, it will take each one of us, to extend trust and offer respect to all those we work with & live among - in any society or citizenry.
education will take care of alot of it. as well as a respect-giving culture.
our religion teaches us kindness and fairness, so yes, we must follow that in letter and in spirit.
dushi