People wanting Malik in the team just need to look at his pathetic performances during the last 12 months. Barring that 100 against the Indians in the CT, he has done nothing with the bat or ball in either formats. He does not deserve to be in the team.
Nor does Iqbal or Farhat for that matter...Imran Khan said once that the best openers Pakistan currently has were Butt and Yasir Hameed and I tend to agree...but unfortunately Hameed isent in the team so Farhat is still better than the likes of Malik and Manzoor.
Iqbal is not a number 3 but at least he isent chickening out at playing at number 3 like the others...Misbah and Yousef both dont want to play at 3...first they sent Umar at 3 then Faisal...lambs to the slaughter.
Khair, Iqbal hasnt done that bad...I would go with him since Younis and Yasir are not in the team...you dont really have much of a choice with the reserves...the likes of Manzoor and Malik are even worse.
In terms of the bowling, I think Kaneria would be back ahead of Ajmal..and Sami in place of Rauf. Gul was dropped for a reason..ie his performances have been poor, to add to that the rumors of indiscipline on his part - ie the incident with Aamir, and I think its good to have him carry the water for a few games. Sami wont do worse than Rauf at least plus he has some pace...might as well give him a go..
I dont think playing Ajmal and Kaneria together is a good idea...we`ve never won a test when we played 2 specialist spinners...it just upsets the balance of the team. If needed, to support Kaneria Yousef can have Umar Akmal bowl his right arm off spin and Farhat can put in some overs of his leg spin..that should be sufficient if the regular bowlers do their jobs