Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

For the whole series, we would discuss one batsman and bowler as stars of the day. Though it is too late for first test but I will still go ahead and post my nominies for the fourth day.

Test 1 Day 4:

Stars

Salman Butt for his extremaly mature and patient innings against a very potent attach. Way to go Salman :k: The way he has batted in this test tells that he is willing to let go some of his flamboyance and translate his starts into a worthwhile contribution.

Flintoff for his 4 wickets, yet again. Once again proving how dangerous has he become with the ball. One of my favourite players nowadays. I hoped and hoped he wouldnt perform against Pakistan but alas I was wrong.

Flops:

Giles for his thouroughly ineffective against Pakistani bowlers thus far.

Hasan Raza sir was making a come back but looked at sea unfortunately

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars of the day

IMO:

Day 1: Salman Butt
Day 2: Trescothic
Day 3: Shabbir Ahmed
Day 4: Salman Butt

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars of the day

Day 1: Salman Butt
Day 2: Billy Bowden (oops I mean Trescothic)
Day 3: Shabbir Ahmed
Day 4: Asad Rauf (oops I mean Salman Butt)

:)

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars of the day

Screw day 1 thru 4. I am about to write star of day 5................................ Danny Boy!

Duds of day 1: Yoyo and Hasan
Duds of day 2: Inzi's Captaincy
Duds of day 3: Navedul Hasan
Duds of day 4: Yoyo and Hasan
Duds of day 5 will be English batting line-up!

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars of the day

^ Actually thats a nice idea, we shold mention duds too. But Not the terms :D, actual players.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

I am mostly dissappointed with Mohammed Yousuf's irresponsible style of batting.
Just when Pakistan needed him the most to hang around with Salman Butt to build a huge lead, he started playing strokes early in the innings which is very uncharateristic of him. His job was to support Salman Butt build a bigger lead of about 250-300 which looked a strong possibility when Inzi and Butt were playing.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Without question Yoyo. Raza can be excused on the grounds of inexperience. But what Yousuf has done is unforgivable.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

^ Agreed Yoyo has to be the dud of the match.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Also include Sami in the list of failures
He was wayward and without any plan
He should be replaced by Umar Gul or M. Asif

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Stars: Trescothic/Butt/Inzi/Flintoff

Flops: Sami/Giles/Yoyo/Hassan

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Please make sure you mention stars and flops mentioning each day for tomorrow and forthcoming days of test cricket

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Good Idea.
It will be interesting to count the stars a player gets at the end of the series and see if it matches with the man of the series.
Good thing about this idea is that we will have the first ever GS flop of the series. Is it going to be sami or bowden? Lets see:D

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Stars of the Day: Kaneria, Akhtar, Sami
Duds of the Day: Flintoff, Pieterson, Strauss

Dare I say it, are Flintoff (batting) and Pieterson OVERRATED?

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

pieterson, maybe, after all, he was dropped twice before making that hundred. flintoff, i dont think so. hes a bowling all roundet, he knows it and i think hes ok with that role

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

How come you guys are not picking Akhtar for star? He was awesome on day 5....well througout this test he was awesome considering what people had to say about him before the test started.

I would say Butt was lucky to get MOM same way like he was lucky to get away with the runout and other drop catches. I would say it was Akthar and Kaneria who were the stars for PAK.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

day 5

Stars: Kaneria, Shoaib
Duds: Pieterson

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

stars of the day: Shoaib, kaneria, sami, and inzi

Flops: Whole english team and Botham

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

Day: 5

Stars: Kaneria/Shoaib/Sami

Duds: England batting/all those Paki spporters (Myself included) who thought Pakistan could'nt do it.

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

stars of the match: pak fans who kept their hopes till the last moment....
duds of the match: those pak fans who did not even bother to follow today's proceedings and already declared pak as loser yesterday (and more those who went on to watch the Ind/SA match instead of bothering to watch the pak-eng match)....

Re: Pakistan v England-- Stars and Flops of the day

:hehe: