Pakistan Tribe Orders Teen Raped

(AP) A Pakistani tribal council ordered an 18-year-old girl to be gang-raped in order to punish her family after her brother was seen walking with a girl from a higher-class tribe, police said Tuesday.

The private Human Rights Commission of Pakistan demanded that all those involved in the rape, which took place June 22 in the village of Meerwala in southern Punjab province, be punished.

Police said the victim’s father had filed criminal charges against the four men involved in the case. Police said they picked up eight relatives of the suspects to pressure the perpetrators into surrendering.

“We will spare no efforts to do justice” for the victim, police official Malik Saeed said.

According to the victim, the Mastoi tribe demanded punishment after her 11-year-old brother was seen walking unchaperoned with a Mastoi girl in a deserted part of the village. The boy and his sister are from the lower class Gujar tribe.

The Mastoi tribe called a meeting of the tribal council, which ordered the girl to be raped to avenge their tribal honor. The teen-ager said she was taken to a hut and assaulted as hundreds of Mastois stood outside laughing and cheering.

Pakistan has a tradition of tribal justice in which crimes or affronts to dignity are punished outside the framework of Pakistani law. The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan has demanded an end to punishments by tribal councils.

Kamla Hayyat, of the commission, said the group will send a fact-finding mission to the victim’s village to determine what happened and provide help to her.

“The increasing incidents of terrible atrocities against women are a terrible reflection on the state of society and the status of women within it,” commission chairman Afrasiab Khattak said in a statement.

Last month, an Islamic court overturned the conviction of a woman who was to be stoned to death for adultery. Zufran Bibi, 28, said she was raped and appealed her early May conviction in the conservative North West Frontier Province.

Her case prompted demonstrations and protests by hundreds of civil and women’s-rights groups nationwide.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2002/07/02/world/main514039.shtml

I read it in the newspaper that she was made to walk home naked in front of 1000 people…

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/frown.gif

When will these illiterates learn!


You can only paint with the colors you're given...
...so get what you like and like what you have.

what has this got to do with religion????

move it to culture or world affairs plz....

[quote]
Originally posted by armughal:
**what has this got to do with religion????

move it to culture or world affairs plz....**
[/quote]

This has a lot to do with Religion!

Who are these people? What is their religion? There are "Gujjars" who are Muslim too... aren't they?

"According to the victim, the Mastoi tribe demanded punishment after her 11-year-old brother was seen walking unchaperoned with a Mastoi girl in a deserted part of the village. The boy and his sister are from the lower-class Gujar tribe.

The Mastoi tribe called a council meeting, and the order was issued for the sister to be raped to avenge their tribal honor. The teenager said she was taken to a hut and assaulted as hundreds of Mastois stood outside laughing and cheering.

Pakistan has a tradition of tribal justice in which crimes or affronts to dignity are punished outside the country's legal framework."

Tradition of tribal justice.... what are Muslims supposed to do? Ignore and wait for miracles to happen? That some day these illiterate people will learn, all by themselves? Where is the Islamic Justice?

What will happen to those men? will they be flogged in public? let alone being stoned to death!

Ofcourse not, since it is a cultural issue and it has nothing to do with religion. Correct me if I am wrong brother armughal?

Islam is a religion and it teaches us how we should live our life, and this issue has a lot to do with religion. The Mastois have gang raped our sister to avenge their tribal honor, what about the honor of Mulims?

Well, not surprisngly, the silence from our generally vocal Mullahs is deafening…They freak out over things like “Islamic Banking,” but when it comes to human rights, a girl is raped and paraded naked in front of 100’s of onlookers, Islam falls silent… This is the WORST kind of inhumanity, the perpetrators should be given the death penelty. These people make pre Islamic Arabs look civilized…

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/mad.gif

Frankly sad as it is there is nothing that says that islamic law was implimented.

Thereis this same topic in Culture by Addu .I dont understand ,either it should be political forum as law & order issue or anthropological aberration of tribal studies.Islam cant be draged for eveything in Pakistan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

There are 50+ other islamic countries & many large musklim populations in mixed populations in India LebenonEurope America .....Islam is global & e,g, if not global but local is WRONG !!!!


Clean your Own Mess

Reena, when it comes to govt and banking systems, perfume and working women, then Islam is brought in. But when this hideous incident happens by people who call themselves muslims, the other cheek is turned.

The article certainly does not mention that this ridiculous punishment was termed Islamic by the tribe, and hence the basis of the punishment. But we guppies are certainly questioning what Islamic action ought to be taken against the people responsible for this so called punishment.

Also , what punishments if any, are there for a woman and a man to talk in a village? I've often posted that men and women should have healthy integration in terms of spoken words -- the article doesn't state what the guy and the girl were doing. So what action should the tribe members have taken, if they were following the Islamic law? -- that question is posed by me on this topic.

As many say here, and as it is fact, Islam encompasses all facets of life. So why exclude this incident? We could talk about this in cultural, political terms, but we can also talk about this in religious terms too.

"District police chief Malik Saeed Awan said that the authorities were informed of the publicly ordered gang-rape several days after the incident. He said that four men took turns to sexually assault the girl inside a room. She was then ordered to return home naked before 1,000 onlookers.

The rape was to avenge the "insult" caused to a family of the Mastoi tribe by the girl's brother's alleged "illicit affair" with a woman of a higher social standing. The girl and her brother were from the lower Gujjar tribe.

The Panchayat had threatened that all women in the accused's family would be raped unless the 18-year-old submitted herself to the public gang-rape."

Where is the SHARIA? Why is it so difficult for us to implement Allah's Laws when these people implement man-made laws no matter how difficult it is for them.

003.110
YUSUFALI: Ye are the best of peoples, evolved for mankind, enjoining what is right, forbidding what is wrong, and believing in Allah. If only the People of the Book had faith, it were best for them: among them are some who have faith, but most of them are perverted transgressors.

We have clear instructions, yet we find it difficult to follow those instructions.

The Mastoi's have displayed how powerful they are, that they can get away with anything. Arrogant people should be taught a lesson, and unless all those involved in the gang-rape and all the members of the Panchayat are stoned to death in front of their own people, we shall continue having such incidents.

Mastoi's are not the only ones who have honor, they should be taught a lesson.

[quote]
Originally posted by Different:
** This has a lot to do with Religion!

Who are these people? What is their religion? There are "Gujjars" who are Muslim too... aren't they?
**
[/quote]

I agree with Armughal, this is a cultural issue, should be moved to Cultural forum.

Just because a group of people who happen to be muslim choose cultural practices to guide their lives, it does not make that practice muslim.
Tribal customs are tribal customs, no religion condones such barbarism, lets not mistaken that insanity for Islaam.

Looks like some people are still stuck in the caste-obsessed dark ages. I wonder when us desis are going to get a sense of priorities about what needs to be dealt with and what is insignificant, i.e., Pakistani tennis players with jewish doubles partners. Incidentally, there is already another thread running regarding this issue.

[quote]
Originally posted by Yasmine:
** I agree with Armughal, this is a cultural issue, should be moved to Cultural forum.

Just because a group of people who happen to be muslim choose cultural practices to guide their lives, it does not make that practice muslim.
Tribal customs are tribal customs, no religion condones such barbarism, lets not mistaken that insanity for Islaam. **
[/quote]

How can one claim to be a Muslim and a strict follower of un-Islamic "tribal customs/traditions" at the same time?

What is Shirk?

By Laxmi Murthy
NEW DELHI, Nov 6 (IPS) - Protected by powerful lobbies, landlords and men in uniform continue to use rape as a means of suppressing dissent, say social activists.
They say that newspaper headlines screaming ‘landlords gang- rape dalit (low-caste) women,’ ‘activists raped by members of rival group’, and ‘army jawans (soldiers) gang-rape tribal women in the north-east’ seem to disturb no one.

‘‘Not only is there an escalation in the number of rapes, but in the perversity of crimes against women,’’ said Indu Agnihotri, senior fellow at the Centre for Women’s Studies here.

Agnihotri says the situation is worst in the north Indian states of Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan, where caste and gender divides are sharp. ‘‘Gender issues including rape are often subsumed by caste loyalties,’’ she said.

This was clear in a gang rape case that occurred in September this year. When a 25-year-old woman complained of having been gang- raped by seven men in a college hostel in Jaipur, Rajasthan, politicians from the poweful Jat-caste to which the men belonged rallied to protect their kind.

Cutting across party lines, the Jat politicians termed the rape story, which found prominent display in leading newspapers, a ‘‘conspiracy to defame a particular caste’’.

As a result, the National Commission for Women (NCW) that investigates rape cases often finds itself helpless in cases where political pressure is brought to bear on behalf of the accused rapists.

‘‘Lower-rung police officials are not responsive and either do not register complaints or falsify or delay them,’’ said Kokila Vyas of the NCW.

In fact, rarely do rape victims get justice. Bhanwari Devi, a worker with the Women’s Development Programme, was gang-raped in 1992 by four high-caste men for daring to oppose child marriage. She is still shuttling in and out of the courts seeking justice.

In 1994, a lower court judge who acquitted the four men said the rape could not have taken place since the men were upper-caste and included a Brahmin – while the victim was low-caste. Bhanwari has brought her appeal to the High Court.

However, the NCW has been able to intervene and get police cases registered against members of the Shanti Sena, a group backed by the ruling party in Maharashtra state, who allegedly gang-raped activists of the rival Adivasi Mukti Sangathan (AMS) in August.

Madhuri Krishnaswamy, an activist with AMS, says women at the forefront of struggles on behalf of the poor and marginalised face serious risks of getting raped.

In 1993, Budhi Behn, an activist of the Narmada Bachao Andolan in Gujarat, was gang-raped by policemen after she resisted eviction from her land threatend by a dam project.

Usha Dhiman, a low-caste woman, was stripped, paraded naked and raped by goons of a powerful liquor lobby, whose interests she threatened by leading an anti-liquor movement that was gaining momentum in western Uttar Pradesh state.

In a similar case, Dhapu Bai, a tribal women from the Tonk district in Rajasthan, was gang-raped by liquor contractors because her husband was leading an anti-liquor agitation.

Perhaps the worst abuses are found in Bihar, where landowners and upper castes maintain armed private armies like the Ranvir Sena, which regularly attack low-caste villages and kill or mutilate the men and rape the women.

Women’s groups such as the All-India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) have been vocal against police or army collusion with landlords, employers and business or political interests who use rape as a weapon in conflict or suppression.

The All-India women’s association alleges that as part of the ‘‘pacification’’ programme in the north-eastern state of Tripura, scores of women were raped by soldiers in Ujanmaidan.

Similar occurrences have been reported in areas like the northeastern region where there is unrest among the Naga people, and in divided Kashmir. According to members of the Naga People’s Movement for Human Rights, ‘‘security forces in the North-east and in Kashmir rape women to induce a state of humiliation and terror in the entire local population.’’

Often, such abuse of power by men in uniform is facilitated and justified by special laws that give them wide-ranging powers of search and detention over civilians.

Women’s organisations are now coming together in broad coalitions to resist abuses by law officers or those who represent the forces of caste hegemony. Some of them have in fact been formed specifically to fight rape.

‘‘If they think they can silence us with rape, they are mistaken. We will never take it lying down. We are now stronger than ever before,’’ asserted activist Sumli Bai, leader of the Advivasi Mukti Sangathan.
http://www.oneworld.org/ips2/nov/india_rape.html