Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

This project will bring peace and control to some extent in Pakistan. Afghan government is in favor of this project but locals, mafia, drug dealers and arm smuggler are not happy.


KANDAHAR, Afghanistan (AP) — In the dusty badlands along its disputed border with Afghanistan, Pakistan is carving out a massive trench to keep out separatists, smugglers and militants in an attempt to bring order to a lawless, tribal region.

But like the Berlin Wall or Israel’s West Bank barrier, the planned 485-kilometer (300-mile) trench is giving physical form to a border that locals have long seen as artificial, dividing families and crippling trade. And it is adding to simmering tensions between Afghanistan and Pakistan, U.S. allies which have long accused each other of turning a blind eye to insurgents.
The trench runs along part of the 2,640-kilometer (2,640-mile) Durand Line, named for British diplomat Mortimer Durand, who drew the now internationally recognized border in an agreement with Afghan ruler Abdur Raham Khan in 1893. But the modern Afghan government has never accepted the border, and neither have the mainly tribal communities that straddle it. They are accustomed to moving back and forth freely and in some cases own land on both sides.
The trench is being built in Pakistan’s Baluchistan province, where Baluch rebels have been battling Islamabad for decades, demanding greater autonomy and a larger share of the region’s oil, gas, copper and gold. It’s an eye-sore of construction — a massive furrow 10 feet (three meters) wide and 8 feet (2.4 meters) deep that already snakes 180 kilometers (110 miles) across the desert landscape.
Pakistan’s Frontier Corps said in a recent statement that the trench would “not only help in effectively controlling the movement of drug and arms and ammunition smugglers, but also will help in stopping the intrusion of terrorists and illegal immigrants.” Pakistan fears that arms could make their way to any number of insurgent groups, including the Taliban.
But Kabul sees the trench as the latest move in a new incarnation of the colonial-era Great Game, in which Pakistan hopes to destabilize its neighbor to extend its regional influence. It already considers Pakistan as the source of the Taliban insurgency it has been battling with U.S. and NATO support for the past 13 years.
“The people here have never accepted the Pakistan-Afghanistan border in the first place,” said Gen. Abdul Raziq, the police chief of Afghanistan’s Kandahar province, which borders Baluchistan.
“Pakistan is not doing anything to stop terrorism. If they want to stop it, they should stop producing it,” said Raziq, who has long had a reputation for ruthlessness in battling the Taliban. “This trench is simply to draw a border with Afghanistan and claim our land as their own,” he said.
[View gallery

http://l3.yimg.com/bt/api/res/1.2/PBxO78nFOXnbC2UUx4Uy9w--/YXBwaWQ9eW5ld3M7Zmk9ZmlsbDtoPTE3NDtxPTc1O3c9MzAw/http://media.zenfs.com/en_us/News/ap_webfeeds/c780b9d899d13e2f670f6a706700c3ef.jpg](http://news.yahoo.com/photos/may-16-2014-photo-pakistani-border-guard-stands-photo-060227197.html) In this May, 16, 2014 photo, a Pakistani border guard stands alert as an excavator digs a trench alo …

Pakistan insists it is committed to fighting extremist groups and points to a massive offensive it launched in the tribal region of North Waziristan along the Afghan border over the summer. But analysts have long said Islamabad differentiates between the Pakistani Taliban, with which it is at war, and the Afghan Taliban, which it quietly tolerates and views as a means of preserving its influence in Kabul.
In that context, the trench is not seen by Afghans as a counterterrorism measure, but as an affront.
“This can never be acceptable for the Afghans,” said former Afghan Tribal and Border Affairs Minister Akram Akhbelwak, who was removed from his post this week while President Ashraf Ghani finalizes his new Cabinet.
“The trench and the tribal border are completely illegal. Such actions on the border are creating problems among the tribes and will never be a solution to the problems between the two countries,” he said.
Afghanistan’s Ghani signed security agreements with Washington and NATO immediately after taking office in September, permitting an enduring international military presence after the combat mission formally ends on Dec. 31. The insurgents have meanwhile stepped up their war against his government with a series of high-profile attacks in Kabul.
Along the border, construction is proceeding, to the anger of local residents.
“My land is my only asset from my forefathers — now some of it is on the other side and I’m powerless to do anything about it,” said tribal elder Muhammad Ghaffar, who like many people living along the trench took the freedom of movement across the Durand Line for granted.
Raziq said that when work began, some local people made their anger clear and there was some exchange of fire across the line. “But then we got orders from Kabul not to engage with Pakistani forces, so we backed off,” he said.
For polio worker Abdullah Jaanan, the implications of the barrier are potentially devastating, as Pakistan is experiencing a resurgence of the disease and his area of responsibility traverses the trench. Jaanan said that eradication of the disease, which remains endemic only in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Nigeria, is taken seriously by Afghans.
“But how can I go and visit those homes on the other side of trench?” he said.

Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

Re: Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

Interestingly, many Americans are not happy with their own government and making case if Pakistan can take initiative in protecting border from Afghanistan, why does not American protect its boarder from Mexico.
For those who don't know about American Mexican border.. Smugglers, drug dealers and human trafficking are the issues US facing constantly from Mexican borders.

There are many positive comments on this news from American readers, I am sharing few.

[QUOTE]
By refusing to let Pakistan build a trench to put an end to cross border terrorism and let both countries manage terrorists on their own side, it is now crystal clear which country is doing it and fooling the Americans since long. Their claim of border being disputed is just a facade as the line was drawn by the British more than a century back and was also signed by the Afghan king at that time. It has stayed as such since then.It is like Spain now claiming California to their part.
The claim of divided tribes is also a ploy for drug smugglers and other criminals to work on both sides. When the city of Berlin was divided, even some of the houses across the line had to be divided.
[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE]
Pakistan is condemned for not doing anything to stop terrorism and Pakistan is condemned for taking steps to stop terrorism.
After US and Nato are running away from Afghanistan with tails between their legs and Afghanistan not being able to do anything to stop terrorists on their land. Its Pakistan's right to take its own measures to see what is fit to protect its land from these terrorists and criminals.

Afghanistan should man up and stop the terrorists on their land or shut up and let Pakistan do its own thing.

[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE]
Wow!!.. A sovereign country that wants to protect it's border with a Failed Narco -State. ? what a Fracking concept a REAL barrier .. I wonder where this same solution could be applied? Some where? Oh I don't know maybe BETWEEN the USA & Mexico? For any body who has Not seen it The DMZ between the 2 Koreas. Manned guard towers, armed response teams . walking patrol with a steady over watch . expensive? wait until 3 young guys with a Backpack dirty bomb blow up Austin or Dallas or Denver or La or NYC then the cost will seem like chump change.. Can't be more than 13 million illegals in this country.

[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE]
Thank God. Pakistan has spent decades actively funding the insurgency, and if this trench does any good at all it is a step in the right direction. The fact that this place exists in a contested state of anarchy is precisely why insurgents use it as their base. Bickering over who owns what patch of dirt is part of the problem, and as long as nationalists and tribes keep fighting over small-scale #$%$ like this, they aren't solving the bigger problems.
[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE]
AMERICA LOOKS WEAK AGAIN - Pakistan protects its boarder while the United States leaves it open craws a sharp contrast to the fake arguments that the USA can not define and protect its boarder because it is impossible or costs to much when a small country like Pakistan can? This make the American boarder policy look absurd and in place to meet some secret undisclosed policy which might inflame the average American Joe.
[/QUOTE]

Re: Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

a 10x8 trench will not stop a terrorist from either direction, especially since a lot of that is occurring with tacit support of institutional agents! but this is a good way to stop the 'retail' terrorists and narco smugglers

Re: Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

@SID_NY @muqawwee123

Re: Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

There will be corruption still, people will just feed any guards any money to get across the trench.

But it will control and monitor the movement, at least you can start identifying the actual people moving across the border, and if people need to be caught, at least you can identify who crossed the border with possible arms, etc.

I think it's appropriate.

And Afghanis are NOTHING like Mexicans. Nothing. They are simply not a match. These afghanis especially the militants are atrocious. I don't even think we should call them muslim, the amount of gand they have spread across Pakistan.

Re: Pakistan trench along Afghan border enrages Kabul

This has been long awaited need. This had to be done. And I hope it gets completed without any issue especially if the govt is changed in Pak. What happens actually is that not only the border is lousy b/w Pak and Afghan but also all the border security officials are corrupt to the core. I once heard on NPR that sometimes they let go the smugglers even for a couple of cigarettes.

So what is required now is
1) Let this project get complete asap
2) Tighten the border security on both sides to make sure there is no corrupt or incompetent staff on duty. Its a supersensitive domain and no country can afford a lackluster.