Pakistan To Re-Write Anti-India, Hindus Curricula

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Fraudz: *
right so indian hatred for pakistanis is innate versus pakistani hatred for Indians is indoctrination..makes sense. :D

anyways, this was a good topic, but same old pissing contests between the usual suspects screwed this over too.
[/QUOTE]

Mr. Fraudia

Majority of Indians don't care about Pakistan. There is no hatred that is inbuilt.

This is not a pissing contest. I'll dispute any claim that there is indoctrination of anti-Pak values in Indian curriculum.

accha bhai theek hai, majority of indians dont care, acchi baat hai. shabaash

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Fraudz: *
accha bhai theek hai, majority of indians dont care, acchi baat hai. shabaash
[/QUOTE]

That is really true. Partition only affected people in Bengal and Northern India - Punjab, UP, Haryana, Delhi etc.

Rest of India had no civilizational interest in Pakistan, good or bad.

I really feel that as long as Pakistani kids are being taught that all Hindus are evil etc. we will have a tough time maintaining even a semblance of peace.

I find it galling that some people here even justify such hateful teachings.

What do you think about these types of teachings?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Talwar: *

That is really true. Partition only affected people in Bengal and Northern India - Punjab, UP, Haryana, Delhi etc.

Rest of India had no civilizational interest in Pakistan, good or bad.

I really feel that as long as Pakistani kids are being taught that all Hindus are evil etc. we will have a tough time maintaining even a semblance of peace.

I find it galling that some people here even justify such hateful teachings.

What do you think about these types of teachings?
[/QUOTE]

Yeah Sure, sure! the media might buy such crap but i am sure many others dont!

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Enforcer: *

Yeah Sure, sure! the media might buy such crap but i am sure many others dont!
[/QUOTE]

would pakistan accept bihar if it becomes muslim majority state same way it wants kashmir?

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Talwar: *
What do you think about these types of teachings?
[/QUOTE]

let me quote one of my previous posts in this thread that you may have missed

"either way, its a good step that curriculum is being sorted out in both countries, hopefully the future generations will not have to bicker like the current one is doing in this thread."

organized, systematic or otherwise teaching hatred and skewed history is incorrect.

pakistan needs to sort this mess out and portray an accurate account, without diluting thr bad truth as well, during partition massacres did occur..saying that they did not is incorrect, however noting that it happened to people in both sides should be fine, and if there is a mention of estimated casualties referring to various sources that is right information.

You have to understand though, that hatred does not have to be officially indoctrined to make it a danger. Sectarian and ethic violence in pakistan, and religious violence in india is an example of that.

aside from just cleaning up text books, a system should be developed that misinformation is stopped from spreading at all levels and thru all mediums.

sure, Pakistan would not only accept bihar but all the way to bihar:hula:

fitrst accept biharis stranded in bangaldesh who fought for west pakistan

step by step, first bihar than bangal

Salam to all!,

I have been busy with my year end exams so that's why I have been off the radar for a while. I have a couple of days relief so I thought might as well check and see what's cooking.

I think this is also relevant to the thread.
One thing Pakistan should make sure is known to its masses is that how it became independent on August 14, 1947 (and thereby British colonial rule ended with the birth of Pakistan) and how and why "secular" Hind chose 15 August.
In fact this will shed an analytical light on how Indians view Pakistan through the superstition of astrology. My Muslim brothers and sisters (with the exception of perhaps Aejaz, Imdad Ali!- the "secularized" Indians) know how astrology stands amongst Muslims in general.

Here is an article from The Guardian (November 2003) so barely just about 7 months old. Please note how India's so-called EDUCATED people live on astrology and how they view Pakistan's trouble through a superstitious prism. And please read carefully: hind's movies, political campaigns, business decisions, marriage, revolve around this.
So if Pakistan includes these FACTS in its curriculum, then it will save a lot of time and energy when meeting people like the Hindi ones on this foum! : when they mention India's secular nature, cut the story short by asking: why did India wait till August 15, 1947 for independence? (to rid itself of the influences of "planetary mischiefs"!!!), then ask what the top layer of saffron in the hindi flag stands for (what a coincidence the saffron represents piety/patrotism - I'm sure it has NOTHING to do with a particular religion!).............., khalas, then don't waste time!

You Pakistani people are so lucky!: remember that day of August 14?
It was 27 Ramadan, after Fajr prayers that something dramatic happened in Karachi and a new nation was born. The "secular" Indians, convinced the supporters of India (including perhaps people like Maulana Azad - ie Muslims of India) that 14 August is not "an auspicious" occassion and so wait till midnight (August 15) so that none of the "mischiefs of planetary influences" are able to derail our nation!.

So when a nation is BORN and BASED on such perspectives (India), you don't need so much active indoctrination through state education do you?!
I thought the split of Pakistan in 1971 (with Hindi help) was a consequence of West Pakistan's unIslamic (and "cultural") behaviour with the Bengali Muslims and not due to the influence of planetary positions 24 years earlier in 1947!.

No one should write false stuff in school text-books but school text-books are a means to an end. Pakistan should also be careful of other indoctrination processes working magnificinetly in Hind!
I will be back after my exams - in the mean time enjoy!!
Please read how urban educated Indians are more influenced by astrology than rural Indians!. And please..........The Guardian is not funded by the ISI Mr. Talwar!!

Matches, hatches and dispatches are all made in heaven for India's millions
New Delhi
Saturday November 29, 2003
The Guardian

A monsoon of weddings has hit India with superstitious romantics pinning their hopes on the stars. As many as 12,000 couples were married on Thursday in Delhi as the power of astrology gripped those set on nuptials.
The trigger came from astrologers who designated the day as protected from Jupiter's "planetary mischief". The frenzy will be repeated in the coming weeks with more auspicious days coming up.

"Every 12 years Jupiter transits in Leo, and that definitely brings ill luck to marital unions," said one astrologer, Arvind Kumar. "The bad period will end only after January 15."

That warning spells bad news for India's multibillion rupee wedding industry. Indians spends an estimated 50bn rupees (£700m) on weddings, excluding the cost of jewellery and clothes. Too many problem days can be bad for business.

The rush to get married on special dates is a nightmare for parents, who arrange everything from selecting the bride or groom, after astrologers match individual horoscopes, to paying for lavish feasts.

Priests, brass bands, wedding photographers, even the grooms' ceremonial horses are in short supply. But astrologers have a solution for this, too. The ill-effects of a wedding on an unsuitable day can be warded off by first "marrying" the bride and groom to, say, a holy tree.

"Astrologers basically assist by providing direction," Mr Kumar said. "The rest is up to man."

Influence
The success of astrologers like Mr Kumar who specialises in "medical" predictions is evidence that astrology influences almost every sphere of life in India - politics, business, family, healthcare, sports, entertainment, even crime.

Many candidates for next week's state assembly elections filed their nominations at a time fixed by astrologers. Most Bollywood films are released after determining auspicious dates.

Many family events are dictated by the stars: an entrepreneur from Mumbai recently hired a yacht to ensure that his pregnant wife delivered his son by caesarean section at the time and location deemed lucky by an astrologer. And multibillion rupee industrial projects are guided by planetary conjunctions.

"Nobody in India does business any more without looking at auspicious dates or determining the best vaastu [India's version of feng shui]," said an editor of a business newspaper. The more India develops, the more people resort to superstitions touted as "ancient sciences".

"Astrology hardly has any influence among the illiterate and poor in rural India," said a sociologist, Asish Nandy. "It's the urban educated, grappling with an increasingly complex and uncertain reality, who are in its thrall."

The idea of India may be secular, but astrology played a role in the country's birth. The transfer of power from Britain took place in New Delhi in the early hours of August 15 1947, after an inauspicious period had passed.

Pakistan took no such precaution and became independent a day earlier. Indian astrologers say it is paying the price. It split into two in 1971, with the creation of Bangladesh, and is destined for further division.

Astrologers really came into prominence in the Indian capital in the late 60s when the prime minister Indira Gandhi began to turn to soothsayers and holy men.

"When I predicted that her son Rajiv Gandhi, then only an airline pilot, would one day become India's prime minister, she immediately summoned me for a consultation," said Lachhman Das Madan, 82, probably India's most famous astrologer. He also claims to have also predicted Mr Gandhi's assassination in 1991.

There is no reliable estimate of the number of astrologers practising in India today. A directory published by a New Delhi astrology company lists 10,000 practitioners. But the publisher acknowledges that "this probably accounts for no more than 1% of India's astrologers".

India's IT revolution has also popularised astrology and related practices. Computers allow for quick casting of horoscopes, and a variety of astrological software is available.

After the rise of the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata party, astrology has received the official stamp of approval. There are government-funded courses in astrology at universities. It has acquired so much significance in India that it had to be excluded from a draft anti-superstition bill in the Maharashtra state assembly.

The bill, meant to protect people from charlatans and cheats was tabled eight years ago, but is awaiting New Delhi's approval. No one seriously expects it to be passed in the near future. The stars would not be in its favour.

El Turki,

Hope you did your exams well.

Astrology is believed in to a large extent in India, particularly when in times of distress. That is true. But that has nothing to do with secularism. But that is besides the point.

Astrologically, nights, particularly midnight is a bad time. Astrologically, the day does not begin at midnight, which is a western concept, but with sunrise. Thus, if one is born at say, 01.00 am on say 29th May, hospital and government records in India would show the DOB as the 29th, but one's astrological charts will show the DOB as 28th May.

The interpetations in the article are extremely naive though.

If it will make you any happy even though you don't believe in astrology, according to many Indian astrologers, the country is suffering because of the wrong time chosen for independence. And, even more, because the Indian parliament house is extremely contradictory to the indian version of feng shui

Nehru, all said and done, was practically an atheist. He had no patience for mumo jumbo. Still, one can be extremely secular withoug even being irreligious.

Best wishes for your exams.

^^

Brother El Turki,

This place was getting to be a bit boring after the cricket series.:sleep2:

Then along came you!!!:rotfl:

Then you Disappeared!!!:sleep2:

Now you are back, and that too just to prove, that you are the perfect example of the “EDUCATED ILLITERATE”:frusty:

Welcome back, its our pleasure to witness you open your mouth and put your foot into it!!!:whistling

El Turki,

Why do you have to make a clown of yourself by posting irrelevant nonsense?

Do you want me to post stuff from Pakistani papers about how many Pakistanis believe in Jinns and myths from Astrologers?

Why don't you stick to the topic.

Mods, how is Turki's post relevant to this thread?

yah mods, there is too much junk on the same usual suspects who are turning every thread into a mud slinging match. Can you control all these types?

Thanks

Turki, you should come to Sindh and visit the sufi shrines. If you talk such nonsense there, the Sindhis will beat you and throw you out. Sindhis would rather die then give up their sufi saints.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Imdad Ali: *
Turki, you should come to Sindh and visit the sufi shrines. If you talk such nonsense there, the Sindhis will beat you and throw you out. Sindhis would rather die then give up their sufi saints.
[/QUOTE]

lol so now your claiming sufi's are sindhi? ther are turkish dummy!

Enforcer, I am giving you an oppertunity to edit your post. I hope you take it.

Well i stand by what i said IMAD now please go and visit this website for further enlightenment:
http://www.australiansuficentre.org/teachings_tasawwuf.htm

http://www.sufisattari.com/soofism.html

Sindh is known as ‘the land of 124,000 saints and dervishes, both Muslim and Hindu.

http://home4.pacific.net.sg/~makhdoom/sufi2.html

[thumb=H]0_9447308.JPG[/thumb]