Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Some good news…

Cookies must be enabled. | The Australian

Pakistan share market makes giant strides

by: Robin Pagnamenta
From: The Australian
June 01, 2013 12:00AM

IT IS plagued by a terrorist insurgency, paralysed by blackouts and its financial and business hub, Karachi, is one of the most violent cities on earth. So why, over the past 18 months, has Pakistan’s stockmarket been among the best performers in the world?

Last year the Karachi Stock Exchange’s 100-share index surged by 49 per cent, placing it among the top five globally. This year the index has roared another 21 per cent higher, propelled in part by investments from the likes of Mark Mobius and Goldman Sachs. At the end of March, 4.6 per cent of Mr Mobius’s $US18.5 billion ($19.1bn) Templeton Asian Growth Fund was invested in Pakistani shares, more than its exposure to Hong Kong, Singapore or Taiwan.

On one level, this buzz of excitement around Pakistani equities seems bizarre. Over the past five years, under President Asif Ali Zardari, Pakistan has been beset by violence, corruption and power cuts lasting up to 18 hours a day. These have forced factories to close and led to an exodus of migrants seeking better opportunities overseas.

It is a pernicious mixture that has hardly encouraged foreign investors. Growth in Pakistan’s $US210bn economy has averaged 3 per cent per year - less than half the rate of the previous five years.

But the world’s sixth most populous country, with nearly 200 million people, is nothing if not resilient and for all its troubles, things may not be quite as bleak as they seem.

The election of Nawaz Sharif as prime minister last month was the first time in Pakistan that one democratically elected government had handed over power to another, generating optimism that it may be on a path to greater stability.

Mr Sharif, a pro-business tycoon who spent several years in Saudi Arabia, is in talks with the Saudis about a $US15bn bailout to end the country’s power crisis.

If he can accomplish it, that alone would be a huge step forward for Pakistan, one that might offer enough of a breathing space to create a virtuous cycle of new business investment and jobs.

Indeed, with reliable power, some experts believe that Pakistan’s gross domestic product growth rate could double to 6 per cent or more, a figure that could be given a further boost if Mr Sharif succeeds in another stated goal - boosting trade with Pakistan’s traditional rival, India.

There are other grounds for cautious optimism. Pakistan has huge mineral resources, a youthful population expanding at 1.8 per cent a year and a middle class that is hungry for consumer goods. A diaspora overseas continues to support the economy through remittances.

Though the level of violence is still appalling, it is worth noting that it has also fallen sharply. From a peak in 2009 when 11,704 people were killed, deaths due to terrorism nearly halved to 6211 last year - still a grim statistic but a marked improvement.

If the trend continues and foreign investors can be lured back, the nation’s weak currency and low wages make Pakistan highly competitive.

Of course, it takes a brave investor to place a bet on a country with problems as big as Pakistan’s, but it’s not just speculators such as Mobius and Goldman that are taking a second look.

Unilever, the British consumer goods giant, recently launched a $US47bn share buyback to boost its exposure to its Pakistani-listed arm, a step it has also taken in other key emerging markets such as India and Nigeria.

The fact that such blue-chip names are putting their money where their mouth is says a lot about the potential they see in a country that is often dismissed as a basket case.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Mr Sharif spent several years in Saudi Arabia?

Talk about convenient truths and oversimplifying things!

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

It is odd that with so many well read folks on this forum, people still buy into our stock market farce. And interesting to see an australian paper talking about a $15 billion saudi loan, talk of which has only come out on social media, or 2nd tier newspapers.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Well, a sustained good performance of the stock market is an indicator of financial health of a country, if the stock market is big enough to not be susceptible to manipulation. KSE is small and can easily be manipulated.

Having said that, I think the market is just catching up, given the potential, inflation and little downside risk. Also, the 'regulation' last year allowing black money to be invested into stock market to make it white has had an effect.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

There's a lot of potential in Pakistan. Just provide the right environment and things will come into place.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Bhai, the government is not even put in place, and you are giving credit of market performance to it?!

Everyone knew that the next government, whoever it is, will perform better than miserable performance of PPP. So the spike we see now is just positive thinking from investors about economy becoming better than where it is today.

Like you said, the performance need to be consistent to say that economy is improving. So let us see how it goes in future.


Nostalgia:

http://apmlus.org/economic-growth-under-pervez-musharraf/

  • Karachi Stock Exchange emerged as one of the best stock exchange, in emerging economies. The Karachi Stock Exchange Index surged more than 11 times – rising from **1189 **in October, 1999 to 13998 in November 2007. This represented the growing confidence of the private sector (both domestic and foreign) on economic management.

http://faculty.nps.edu/relooney/Rel-TOSJ-08.pdf

The Karachi Stock Exchange has been one of the best performing among emerging markets. Market capitalization (as a percentage of GDP) has increased from **9.0% **in 2000 to **35.3% **in 2006.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

You missed 'sustained', 'good performance' and 'country'. We need to see if the current surge is 'sustained' in future. A market with frequent bubbles and bursts are not exhibiting 'good performance'. Nowhere did I give credit to NS government for whatever it is. It might turn out to be another bubble.

Market price fluctuations are ALWAYS indication investors' expectations of the FUTURE though.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Ok. I was reading between the lines.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

As you said, KSE is small, and is almost always manipulated. This is what I discovered in my 4 years in the KSE.
1. More than 60 of the 200 members were inactive.
2. Out of the remaining 140 members, approximately 70 were 'owned' by Aqeel Dhedi, either in whole, or part.
3. Another 20-30 were owned by Arif Habib, either in whole, or part.

With almost 65% of the members owned by 2 parties (rather individuals), this stock exchange is far from being mature. Every year, the finance ministry asks various organizations for input on the annual budget, and the only feedback ever provided by the stock exchange is a recommendation on the percentage that they should pay in order to whiten their money.

KSE is not worth more than 10k to be honest.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

I'm not a financial guru & when I said "some good news" I meant in relative terms. In other words, its better to read that stock market is going up than to read that terrorists blew up 200 people.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Do you have any other barometer for gauging the financial health of country?

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

I am not a financial expert either. But I know that stock market is not an economic indicator at all for any country.
Things like GDP, unemployment, inflation, FDI, are some of the better indicators.

This performance of the market is nothing but celebration for getting rid of the worst government.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Employment rate, inflation, interest rates....tons of other realistic factors based on ground realities, not based on which side of the bed Aqeel Dhedhi woke up this morning.

Re: Pakistan share market makes giant strides

Stock market indices are good measures but for economies with developed capital markets.

For me, the most comprehensive long term measure is Global Competitiveness measure.
Pakistan rank 2008-2009 ==> 101
Pakistan rank 2012-2013 ==> 124

Very few countries have slid so much in this period. Thanks PPP and Taliban!!!

We might have slid further if there were more countries to ‘overtake’!