Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

Today, Pakistan is passing through a critical phase where it is facing so many challenges both inside and outside. Our politicians claim that only they can take Pakistan out of these current crises, whereas our Army claims he has solution of all issues of Pakistan. On the other hand, Judiciary is active in taking notices and trying to make us believe that it will not allow any un-constitutional business. Everyone presents himself as a “true” savior but no one cooperates with others to become a savior.

Who is our savior? Army, Politicians and Judiciary; can we trust any of those?

Our politicians remind me of Ghulam Muhammad and Iskandar Mirza who did not let our political system stabilize. In their 7 years tenure, 6 Prime ministers and 2 assemblies were dismissed. They remind me of Bhutto and Mujeeb who couldn’t come to an agreement and ultimately split the country. They remind me of Benazir and Nawaz Sharif who are known for their corruption and never let each other work for the country. Those were our politicians who first appointed Ayub Khan (COAS) as defense minister and told army that it can be part of govt. Politicians (not army) imposed first martial law in this country and also celebrated Army take over in 1958, 1977 and 1999. Those were also politician who invited army to take control in 1977, 1993, 1997 and 1999. They were also politicians who enjoyed military rule and took their fair share. When I look back in our history, I can not find any single example which gives me confidence to trust these politicians.

How about Army? Army ruled this country for 32 (out of 60) years. General Ayub, General Yahya, General Zia and General Musharaf all are dictators of army regimes. Although, every time army took over it was because of our politicians but Major General Akbar Khan (Chief of General Staff at that time) prepared first conspiracy to take-over Liaqat Ali Khan govt 1951. Once in power, all army dictators tried their best to remain in power as long as they could. None of these army generals let political system stabilize. Army is also equally responsible for losing East-Pakistan. It happened under army regime when people were brain-washed for jihad and were fueled into afghan war. It was an army dictator who introduced Kalashnikov culture to this country and we are still suffering with it. It’s happening under army govt. when our army forces are fighting against its own people. (It’s another debate as to why this is happening).

Can our judiciary be our savior? Judiciary who provided legitimacy to actions of Ghulam Muhammad, Zia-u-Haq, Ishaq Khan, Farooq Laghari for dismissing assemblies? Judiciary who introduced “doctrine of necessity” when Iskandar Mirza and Zia imposed Martial Law; when Ayub Khan and Musharaf took control of this country? Judiciary whose judges turned against their own Chief Justice? Judiciary who allowed every single dictator to amend constitution? Judiciary who is exploiting this nation in name of Justice and playing in hands of opposition (although many wouldn’t agree with this)? If this Judiciary would have given historic decision in 1954 when Ghulam Muhammad’s action of dismissing assemblies was challenged in court or would have not allowed Ayub Khan by introducing “doctrine or necessity” we might have had a different Pakistan.

I see none of these as a “savior” of today’s Pakistan. I think only a “Nation” can save this country. Nation, not “Awaam” and currently we are not a Nation. We are “awaam”, common people, divided into many groups. We are divided into sects, casts, parties, languages, classes etc. Speaking different languages and supporting different parties doesn’t make us “awaam”. It also doesn’t make us “awaam” if different people come from different backgrounds. It makes us “awaam” when these groups do not unite for National Issues, when we prefer supporting our individual groups and put our country behind. When we think all groups are illegal, criminal, unethical and dishonest except us. Today, we are considered more loyal to our party if we are more cruel, violent and critical to other party. The more we criticize other group more we get popular in our own group. Today, our leaders want us divided so that they can rule. Every politician in our country has only one line agenda; to become part of government and suck this country.

Jinnah was a great leader who united this “awaam” into a Nation and was able to get this country for us. Today, we need to get united again as Nation and this time we will have to do by ourselves. We need to get united for Pakistan and not for Musharaf, Benazir, Nawaz Shareef or any other. We need to change our behavior from violent to tolerant so that we can listen to opinions different to what we believe. We need to learn how to sit together when it comes to our country. Reacting violently to everything and bringing people to streets will make things only worst.

We have a beautiful country but need a Nation for it. And I am personally sure that in comming ellections we chose again these politicans or one party the same old history repeat again and new war between army/polticians/judicery will continue. and Oh please dont mention the names of Zardari and party and IK so called inqlabi tsunami whatever it is, one is tested and another not but as we say POOT ke PAOON PALNE mai hi nazar ajate hain.

Honestely dont know what i discuss here coz we already discussed a lot on every single i mentioned above. Bas esi hi likhne ko dil kar raha tha. but I still beleive on miracels someday we awam Inshallah turn into a nation and chose a real leader.

My good wishes and prayers for my beloved country Pakistan and peace on all you.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

Good, thread Eyes! :k:

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

As far as I see the things in Pakistan, historically the army has been calling the shots overtly and covertly during the past 65 years. This has not only weakened the institutions but also served to push the country into chaos.

The civilian politicians haven't fared well too as they seem to be more interested in plundering the country instead of providing good governance. We have a sham democracy in which the establishment brings the rulers as per their wishes, therefore the politicians look towards those forces which can bring them into power instead of the people (who should be the owners in the first place). This is the main reason why the least focus is on governance, because they know that the establishment hasn't got any options.

If the governance is good, I can assure you that the army and judiciary will go into the back stage. When the government does not perform its duty properly a vacuum is created, which other forces try to fill in. During the present regime some mega scandals have come to light, if the government had taken care of them through its institutions like FIA and NAB, it would have stopped the court from interfering in their affairs.

Anyways genuine democracy is the way to go, the people will make 1-2 mistakes, and then they will start choosing the right people to represent them.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

Yeah I'm in favor of a democractly elected govt. Let it be what we chose this is how we learn specially now the media is free and things come out soon make politicians think atleast first not like old days. Things are changing little by little it's we how we take these changes for our future for our destiny towards a goal to make our country strong in all aspects.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

kahan se chhapa hay ye thread?

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

The army, politicians, and judiciary have all played their role in destroying Pakistan. They are all as bad as one another.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

Pakistan needs a revolution. That is the only saviour.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

So it's us awam need to turn into a nation. IK was my hope too when he jump into politics but latter he changed his inqlabi quo status start depend on almost corrupt used politicians and somehow agencies. He leave behind awam helpless the peoples with him now mostly from radical extremists belong to various group.

Re: Pakistan’s Savior Army, Politicians, Judiciary or Nation?

We are in a trap .
Our own mistakes ,Our own faults .
No one can correct it but if there is a will
It is a matter of days
If all powers of the country should sit together and decide to do no wrong in future .
We need a new social , political and regional contract .