Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

This is good news for Pakistan. President Musharraf is now seeking to emulate India’s success in the high-tech and IT sectors, telling the annual OPEN Silicon Valley conference Saturday that "a network of infrastructure is in place to serve as trade and energy corridor for the landlocked Central Asia, India, the Gulf region and China

http://www.wpherald.com/storyview.php?StoryID=20060605-105018-7702r

Walker’s World: Pakistan poised to become Asian tiger
By Martin Walker
UPI Editor Emeritus
Published June 5, 2006

WASHINGTON – War is not often seen as a source of economic growth, but Pakistan seems likely to emerge as one of the main beneficiaries of the Bush administration’s War on Terror. As a front-line state and major base for the U.S.-led campaign in Afghanistan, Pakistan has enjoyed U.S. financial support that has paved the way for new private investment and is turning the country’s period of military rule into an economic success story.

The publication Monday of the Pakistan government's budget demonstrates this dramatic change in the country's financial fortunes, with surging growth and new investment plans that suggest the world's second most populous Islamic nation is poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies. 

 
The Persian Gulf sheikhdom of Dubai is to invest an initial $10 billion in Pakistan's boom, mainly in property, port and transport development, a sum that may triple to $30 billion if current negotiations succeed. 
 
The World Bank, now run by former U.S. Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz who urged heavy U.S. financial support of Pakistan when the country was being wooed after the Sept. 11 attacks as a key partner in the war on terror, is now doubling its own investment loans to $6.5 billion. The government is also to increase its own development budget by 50 percent. 
 
Salman Shah, economic adviser to Pakistan's prime minister, announced in a press conference Sunday that the country's gross domestic product has grown at an annual rate of 6.6 percent in the latest fiscal year. 
 
"This year also the economy has shown a solid growth in spite of major setbacks during the year," Shah said, citing the massive earthquake that killed some 70,000 people last October and the dizzying climb in oil and commodity prices. 
 
Pakistan's growth rate has averaged an annual 7 percent over the past four years, helping lift almost 20 million of Pakistan's 150 million people out of poverty. The proportion of Pakistanis officially calculated as living below the population has fallen from over a third to less than a quarter in the past five years, Shah said. 
 
Pakistan's take-off began with the War on Terror, starting with the war to topple the Taliban regime in Afghanistan in 2001. That triggered a big U.S. aid program, starting with $91 million in the first year and rising steadily to $706 million in 2005. 
 
"The U.S. forgave all bilateral debts to Pakistan, helped reschedule debts involving multinational lenders, provided billions in economic and military assistance, and encouraged international banks to provide even larger amounts of aid. As a result, Pakistan's foreign debt declined from $47.8 billion to $30.3 billion (today's estimate). Foreign exchange reserves, boosted largely by the transfer of large sums of money from expatriate Pakistanis, rose to $12 billion," notes Dr Ahmad Faruqui, research director at the American Institute of International Studies 
 
U.S. and international funds were joined by private investment from the Arab world and the Gulf states as the military government of President Gen. Pervez Musharraf launched a program of economic reform and privatization. Pakistan Telecom was privatized last year, with the bulk of the shares being bought by companies based in the United Arab Emirates. 
 
Already closely linked to the oil-rich Gulf economies through some 3 million Pakistani guest workers, Pakistan is now benefiting from new infrastructure investment. Dubai Ports World is bidding for the management contract to run the new Chinese-built port of Gwadar, near Pakistan's frontier with Iran on the Indian Ocean, and other Gulf companies are investing in the new road and rail links from Gwadar to China and Central Asia. 
 
President Musharraf is now seeking to emulate India's success in the high-tech and IT sectors, telling the annual OPEN Silicon Valley conference Saturday that "a network of infrastructure is in place to serve as trade and energy corridor for the landlocked Central Asia, South Asia, the Gulf region and China." 
 
"We have put in place an elaborate IT infrastructure; connected cities and towns to the Internet; and three submarine cables are to further enrich the IT scenario," Musharraf said. "On top of it, we have talented English-speaking graduates, which are an asset for the country and international investors." 
 
"Pakistan today is in an altogether different league economically," Musharraf told the conference by video. "It has been put firmly on path of high economic growth with its GDP having more than doubled to $135 billion and all macro-economic indicators including exports, revenue collection, foreign investment, foreign exchange reserves staying positive." 
 
Pakistan's future prospects are far from guaranteed. Political instability, violent spillovers from the Taliban insurgency in Afghanistan, a new surge in the oil price or new tensions with India could all jeopardize the country's future growth. 
 
But once again, a pattern emerges of a major U.S. strategic initiative bringing financial aid and investment and transforming regional economies. It happened in the Cold War, when America's Marshall Plan revived the war-battered economies of Western Europe. It happened in Japan, when that country became the industrial base for the Korean War in the 1950s and then the U.S. strategic base in Asia. It happened again in the Vietnam War, when U.S. aid and investment helped Thailand, Malaysia and Singapore into their economic takeoff, and led to the formation of ASEAN, the Association of South-East Asian Nations that has become a regional powerhouse. 
 
And now the same seems to be happening in Pakistan. The one exception to this rule of U.S. strategic involvement leading to a surge in growth is Iraq, where the instability of the insurgency has been a disincentive for outside investors. But the part played by the Iraq war in suppressing Iraq's oil production has led to higher prices, and the massive inflows to the oil-rich Persian Gulf countries that are now pumping some of this money into Pakistan.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia’s new “tiger” economies

this is garbage. THis article gives too much credit to “us strategic initiative”.

Most of the Investment done in Pakland is coming from Dubai and not from US. Dubai is investing in pakland cause of its own interest and not cause the US is telling it to.

THe Foreign reserves in pakland are rising because over seas paks are sending home alot of money, and not cause the US is telling them to.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia’s new “tiger” economies

Brave Heart, as they say… ** Success has many fathers failure is an orphan… ** Turn around in Pak economy is due to govt. policies plain and simple. We are an agro based economy and will be a for a long time. the funy thing is that Indians talk about economy when they are in ethe same boat. About 2 years ago their growth rate took a nose dive, guess what happened.
China is in a different league…

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

I honestly dont know what to make of the pak economy... Most are saying that its heading the wrong way, and then out of no where we get articles like this... Either the Pakistani analysts are misinterpreting or underestimating the countries potential, or the foreign analysts just dont know very much about the country... They cant both be right! I guess it just wait and watch for now.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

Do Pak analysts know anything other than pessimism. Sheesh. I remember that reputed film maker of some film called Javed Shampoo whose film was much talked about at KaraFilm and later screened on telly. He was GRILLED by the goras for painting such a morbid picture of his home country at the Pehli Dharkan fest in Ireland....I guess Pak folks are enough to destroy themselves, you really don't need a foreign power :)

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

That is because they live in Pakistan and can see the ground realities for themselves(unlike many living around the world,on the net)

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

Pertinent article

EDITORIAL: Conflicting ways of looking at the economy
The Economic Survey 2005-06 made public on Sunday inspires hope, but as usual the general comment on it challenges the figures and predicts doom in the coming months. This is nothing new. We have seen it from the times Pakistan’s economy couldn’t balance its income and expenditures, but this time around there is a lot of noise about the economy. And not even foreign observers, away from the politically motivated quarrels over statistics in Pakistan, agree that the poverty alleviation claimed by the government could be realistic. Negatively speaking, the trade gap has ballooned, even though it is significantly related to the import of capital goods and raw material and oil. The opposition’s challenging of the growth rate of 6.6 percent can be taken with a pinch of salt but shockingly, it is being challenged by a section of the industrial sector as well!

Those who make their voices heard include non-economists who believe in a world that is still to come into being or should be brought back from the debris of the totalitarian economies of the now-defunct Soviet bloc countries. The votaries of such a welfare state belong on both extremes of the political spectrum. Those who believe in the ideology of Pakistan and in Islamist politics say that the Quaid had promised an Islami falahi state in which the poor would be looked after. Together with the left-wing and “social” ideologues, they are against privatisation and against opening up the market under WTO rules. They reject the fact that global oil prices have caused difficulties and want the government to take off the duties it imposes on imported crude oil, and they ignore the fact that India’s petrol in the retail market is not cheaper than Pakistan’s. And no one listens when the government says it is paying Rs 82 billion as subsidy to WAPDA to keep electricity cheap (theft by the poor and line losses are a form of subsidy).

There is much noise about poverty, which is natural because every time a Third World state increases its rate of growth inequalities become pronounced. Everybody acknowledges that the greatest incidence of poverty is in the countryside and not in the cities. Yet when the TV channels want to investigate poverty they go to the streets of the big urban centres and make us hear citizens complaining of big electricity bills and rising cost of food items. Everyone refers to India’s low prices and no one pays attention to the fact that flour is cheaper in Pakistan than in the neighbouring states. It could be that poverty-scanning is wrapped up in culture: in India acceptance of inequality is embedded in the social order, therefore, the poor express grief at being poor; in Pakistan, non-acceptance of inequality is embedded in the social order and therefore the poor express grief at not being rich.

The government is boasting about the unprecedented amount of money it is going to set aside for development. As President Pervez Musharraf said, it used to be around Rs 90 billion in the 1990s; it is now going to be over Rs 300 billion. This means that every fund-starved sector like education and health will get larger amounts to spend. An outsider would be deceived into thinking that good times are about to dawn in Pakistan; but he will have to be disabused about our ability to spend development funds. The Rs 90 billion never got spent in the old days. Given the system today, a chunk of Rs 300 billion too will remain unspent. It is said that more than half of the allocated funds routinely remain unspent; and in the sectors mentioned above almost 80 percent of them are returned to the exchequer. One chief minister in Sindh left his job with 80 percent of the development budget unspent! Aware of this, the president has charged former State Bank governor Dr Ishrat Hussain with the task of seeing that projects are created and completed to absorb the development funds. In territories where the writ of the state doesn’t run — and that comes to around 60 percent of the country’s territory — development funds will not be spent in any case. In Balochistan and in the Tribal Areas, minimal development is expected, given the state of security there.

The budget is going to go through the usual motions. The government may have done well by objective standards, but it must take some rap for the scandals in the fiscal year 2005-06. It says mysteriously that the current price hike for sugar, pulses, beef, mutton and milk was caused by “extra-market forces”, meaning that there was large-scale hoarding in the country. The opposition has latched on to the fact that many producers of sugar are in the federal cabinet and is pointing fingers dangerously close to the powers-that-be. Although linked to international prices, the sugar and cement crises have not been handled competently by the government. The stock market, fearing new levies and despairing of much-needed concessions, has been see-sawing wildly, which is not a good sign on the eve of the budget.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

Good points!

Here is a set of two equations that describe national mood.

Economic Leftists = Pessimists
Economic right-wingers = Optimists

Every country in the world experiences the struggle between these two groups. Even in America Carter (leftie) meant pessimism, and bad economy. Regan (Rigtie) meant optimism, and better economy.

West usually goes back and forth between lefties and righties. Righties build, and lefties consume. Unfortunately Pakistan so far has not had any rightie group take over. So lefties rule the roost and hence pessimism prevails everywhere in the country.

Leftie Intellectual Class:
Most of our intellectual class is extreme leftie (journalists + professors). They will continue be live in the bottom level of sewers until Pakistan is turned in to a communist jannat (heaven).

Countering the lefties using Right wing economists:
Usually these lefties are only countered by strong business class. However in Pakistan, business class supports fanatic Maulana Ashabs. Now Maulana Ashabs were good to counter communism, but they now are just another form of leftist terrorists.

It is only natural. Lefties are giving Pakistan a look as if everyone is dead. With that kind of attitude, who would want to visit our country? Add religious terrorism and cartoon-ish issues and you got a recipe for utter disaster for Pak economy. Thanks to the army, we have been able to keep a pro-West stance. That helps us survive. However army has no help from the leftie intellectuals. Until we produce a strong economic-right-wing intellectual class, you will continue to see the mood resembling dead and dying-lefties.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

TRD, Link for post #8 pls.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia's new "tiger" economies

Agendas my friend.

Re: Pakistan poised to join China and India as one of Asia’s new “tiger” economies

Didn’t know India was an Asian Tiger :halo: