Pakistan Islamic or Secular?

Re: Pakistan Islamic or Secular?

In the West, there are differences of opinion on how democracy should be implemented, yet no one uses this as an argument against democracy itself; difference of opinion enriches a concept; it doesn’t detract from it. In the UK alone, we have Conservatives, Social Democrats, English Nationalists, Royalits, Christian Parties (etc) which all have a different idea of how to run democracy, but they all agree that democracy should be the foundation of the British state.

So I say, as Muslims, can we all at least decide upon the fact that we want to live our lives according to Islam and govern ourselves according to Islam, and everything else can follow after this first elementary pre-requisite has been met?

Believe it or not, with regards to foreign policy, economic policy, taxation, penal code, accountability, justice system (or in other words, the public sphere)… most of the schools of thoughts are in agreement. You need to realise Islam has very few doctrinal splits (Shia vs Sunni being the major one). It also only the smaller personal fiqh issues such as salaah, family law, marriage and various theological concepts that the difference of opinion arises. **Remember, the state would **not interfere in these issues. These issues would be decided at a very local level.

I refer you to this:

The Amman Message

In brief, 200 leading Islamic scholars from around the world unanimously issued a ruling on three fundamental issues:

  1. Who is a Muslim?
  2. Is it permissible to declare someone an apostate (takfir)?
  3. Who has the right to undertake issuing fatwas (legal rulings)?

You see? It shows that Muslim scholarship *can *address the major issues facing the Ummah, if given the chance, even if the solution is as something as simple as ‘let’s agree to disagree.’ An Islamic state will never demand one interpretation of Islam - instead it will promote a pluralistic system which accepts difference of opinion as valid, just as Western democracy does.