Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

Something to ponder for those who pass negative judgments on the relief effort so far.

It’s worse than tsunami: WHO: Race against time: UN official

The earthquake which struck northern Pakistan and Azad Kashmir early this week was a bigger catastrophe than last year’s tsunami in terms of the number of people made homeless and the extent of destruction to infrastructure, a World Health Organisation official said here on Thursday. Hussein A. Gezairy, the organization’s regional director, said the quake rendered 2.5 million people homeless as against 1.5 million displaced by the tsunami. Besides, another million people are in extreme grief, needing immediate help. He said $10 billion had been mobilized by the United Nations and the world community for tsunami relief. Talking to reporters at the Emergency Health Relief Operations Centre at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Mr Gezairy said that although the quake had caused much more severe devastation than the tsunami and even hurricanes Katrina and Rita, he had doubts that the same amount of money would be raised for rehabilitation of earthquake victims. No roads were destroyed by the tsunami and the destruction was confined to areas within a few hundred meters along the coasts and it took only a few days to assess the damage. Besides, there was the facility of transportation through the sea. But here the devastation is widespread, in mountainous and difficult-to-reach regions and only helicopters could reach the disaster areas. However, Mr Gezairy said, he still hoped that the world community would come forward to support Pakistan in rebuilding its entire infrastructure and to provide humanitarian assistance like shelter, water and basic healthcare. The WHO, working in collaboration with the Ministry of Health has fielded international experts and mobilized personnel already operating in the country to build an early warning systems network for disease surveillance and epidemic control in the affected areas.

AFP adds: Pakistan is in a ‘desperate situation’ with survivors cut off beyond major towns five days after the disaster, UN relief chief Jan Egeland told AFP in Muzaffarabad after seeing the devastation. “This is a desperate situation. As you can see we are making progress in the more populated areas but it is so hard to reach the others,” Mr Egeland said after a helicopter tour of the disaster zone in Azad Kashmir. “We’re still racing against the clock and we need to get more helicopters, more water, more tents and more money.” He rejected complaints from destitute and injured survivors that the response by UN and Pakistani agencies was too slow, saying relief workers were doing their best under extremely difficult circumstances. “It is not slow. The first three or four days there weren’t even (open) roads here,” Mr Egeland said. “In the pipeline we have 10,000 tents and 100,000 blankets but it takes time to go to these areas.” The Norwegian became the face of relief efforts after December’s tsunami disaster when he derided wealthy nations as “stingy” in their response. Asked if the South Asian earthquake was a unique disaster, he said: “It has never been worse. The devastation is beyond belief.” “There is this combination of an earthquake in one of the most rugged areas of the world - not only have thousands of homes and schools been entirely destroyed but also poor communication, and transport is gone when it is needed the most. “It is so incredibly difficult to restore it because the trails and narrow mountain roads have been destroyed in hundreds of places, which means people are stuck without food, without roofs and with badly wounded people among them.” Mr Egeland, the UN’s Under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs, arrived on Thursday having cancelled a trip to tsunami-hit Indonesia as the scale of this earthquake calamity became clear.

http://www.dawn.com/2005/10/14/top1.htm

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

:(

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

:-(

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

No single nation has suffered such a scale of disaster in recent decades.

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

Bam happened in one small city in iran, this is Bam across a whole region. Its difficult to comprehend its scale just yet.

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

A correction..the largest natural disaster ever faced by Pakistan was the cyclone of 1970 which killed around a million people..

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

What are you correcting? Note what I said to begin with - no single nation has suffered such a scale of disaster in recent decades. But as the cyclone of 1970 devestated the then East Pakistan, we can say that this is the the largest natural disaster ever to hit the territory of modern Pakistan, at least as far as we can remember.

Re: Pakistan Earthquake bigger disaster than Tsunami

I agree with that…

Worse than the tsunami!

This is really sad indeed :(. Wish I could do more than pray and send financial help. May Allah help all our suffering brothers and sisters.

Quake ‘is UN’s worst nightmare’

The UN says the shortfall in aid for victims of the South Asian quake has made the relief situation worse than after last December’s tsunami.

UN emergency relief chief, Jan Egeland, said the organisation had never seen such a “logistical nightmare”.

Nato began flying in 900 tonnes of aid on Thursday, but Mr Egeland said a massive airlift was also needed to bring people out of remote areas. Pakistan says nearly 50,000 people died in areas under its control.

Local officials put casualties far higher, and the number is expected to rise. At least 1,400 others died in Indian-administered Kashmir, officials say.

Aid airlift

Mr Egeland said an airlift was needed of the proportions of the Berlin blockade of the 1940s, when Allies flew in supplies to the divided city in communist eastern Europe.

He said aid had to be sent in, and tens of thousands of homeless and injured people flown out, of remote regions before winter set in.

Mr Egeland said of the aid sent so far: “This is not enough. We have never had this kind of logistical nightmare ever. We thought the tsunami was the worst we could get. This is worse.”

The tsunami, which struck on 26 December, killed more than 200,000 people around the Indian Ocean.

Mr Egeland, speaking in Geneva, said the quake situation was becoming worse by the day.

“Tens of thousands of people’s lives are at stake and they could die if we don’t get to them in time.”

Nato on Thursday began an airlift of 900 tonnes of aid from warehouses in Turkey.

Ten thousand tents will be flown to Pakistan over the next few weeks, although the UN has warned there may not be enough winterised tents in the world to meet the needs of the earthquake victims.

‘Second wave of death’

Mr Egeland said only $86m had been pledged of the £312m the UN had asked for to fund the relief operation - and far less actually received in hard cash.

Earlier, UN Secretary General Kofi Annan called for the global relief effort to be increased to help three million people made homeless by the 8 October quake and facing the fierce Himalayan winter without shelter.

“That means a second, massive wave of death will happen if we do not step up our efforts now,” he said.

Mr Annan said that in the most affected areas hospitals, schools, water systems and roads had all been destroyed.

He called upon top international representatives to attend a UN-sponsored donors conference in Geneva, Switzerland, next week.

Mr Annan’s chief aid co-ordinator in Islamabad, Andrew McLeod, told the BBC: “If the second wave of deaths hit, it’s the major donors that are going to have to look at themselves in the mirror and ask why.”

Health fears

On Thursday the Global Green Peace group warned of another danger for quake survivors - the possible shifting of thousands of landmines along the Line of Control in Kashmir.

However, both Indian and Pakistani military officials said if there was any shifting, civilian areas would not be affected. Similar fears in Sri Lanka after the tsunami proved to be unfounded.

Doctors have also warned that tetanus could become a big problem in quake areas if vaccinations are not carried out properly.

WHO doctor, Irfan Noor, said 18 cases had now been reported from the Balakot area of Pakistan’s North-West Frontier Province and that many of those affected were children.

He said there had been three deaths so far from tetanus, two of them children.

The BBC’s Imogen Foulkes in Geneva says the earthquake has come at a time when aid agencies are already very stretched carrying out relief work in storm-hit central America, as well as Niger and Sudan.

She quotes a senior official as saying agencies would find it very difficult to respond to another disaster. While 92 countries had helped nations hit by last year’s tsunami, only some 15 to 20 countries had responded to the quake, the Reuters news agency quoted Mr Egeland as saying.

Source