Re: Pakistan announce T20 squad for world cup
‘I think, you think, we think, he thinks, they think’ ... fact is that, everyone thinking can have biases, discrimination, injustices, nepotism, like/dislike, provincialism, bradarism, recommendation-culture and so on. A player seems slogger to one, fluke, cross batter or whatever to others ... while one may think that a player is talented, others might think that same player is worthless ... but in the end, fact is the Average runs a player makes over many innings and their Strike rates, Economy rate (if game is limited overs) is most important. Fielding and catching can be taken into account too.
I do not care how a player make runs, hitting sixes or taking singles, slogging or playing proper cricket shots, as long as a particular batsman is making on average more runs than other batsman per innings, that particular batsman is better than other batsman. Same goes for bowlers.
All players of a country play in domestic cricket and when judging players and comparing them, similar ‘condition, background and situation’ can only be found in domestic cricket. Thus, domestic cricket is best judge for national players, and that should be criteria for team selection.
One should acknowledge that if a player ‘A’ is better than player ‘B’ in domestic cricket, than their performance figures would be better than player ‘B’ in domestic cricket too. There is no reason that a player ‘B’ is better than ‘A’, but have lower Average than ‘A’ (or lower SR than ‘A’) in domestic cricket. Simple as that.
It is true that things like, some team in domestic cricket might regularly face team with good bowlers (so their batsman Ave drops) or face good batsman (so their bowlers Ave go bad) … but in a country where there is so much discrimination, provincialism, nepotism, biases, like/dislike, recommendations, such discrepancy can be ignored. (Though taking this into account, Karachi batsmen would get up-grade, as most good bowlers are coming from north Punjab).
I believe that if a player has good performance in domestic cricket (over last 10 games he performed) than that would show in his averages and strike rate, and than that player should be selected for national team over those who have lower performance figures (Average, SR, etc), regardless of 'I think, he thinks, you think, we think or they think'.
If a player is incapable in international matches than his Ave and SR over last 10 games would drop, and then other players would get chance ... as international runs, wickets, SR, etc .. gets included in domestic figures .. for instance FC figures include test, List A figures include ODIs, and Twenty20 figures include T20Is.