Re: PAK in ENG (2006) - Media Coverage Center - Post articles here
Pakistan facing dilemma
Telegraph.co.uk
Pakistan must decide whether to stick or twist when they come out to face England at Headingley today.
The safe option would be to drop Shahid Afridi, the rakish all-rounder who has managed only 49 runs and three wickets in the series to date.
The brave one would be to give him more responsibility by promoting him from No 8 to opener, where Afridi has scored two of his five Test hundreds.
Afridi hardly fits the conventional description of an opening batsman. He is more likely to flay the new ball than see it off, but on a Headingley pitch that looks full of runs such a combative stance might just disrupt the England bowlers.
And if he fails, well, Pakistan would be no worse off than they were in the first two Tests, where their opening stands numbered 28, 0, 4 and 21.
At least they would not have sacrificed a bowling option - a dangerous thing to do when your opponents keep piling up 400-plus in every innings.
The problem with promoting Afridi is that - even more than most batsmen - he dislikes genuinely fast bowling. But then few Asian batsmen enjoy going in against the new ball in England.
The Sri Lankans lost their first wicket for 10 runs or under in every one of their six Test innings.
Pakistan might have expected to fare better, but their lot has been complicated by injuries - first to Shoaib Malik, who flew home with elbow trouble, and now Imran Farhat, who fractured his right index finger when catching Kevin Pietersen at Old Trafford.
“We had a pretty settled opening partnership against England in Pakistan,” said a wistful Bob Woolmer, the Pakistan coach. "Salman Butt and Shoaib Malik averaged 60 for the first wicket, which was enough to see off the new ball. We had it working then, but we’ve had to shuffle them around a bit since then.
“We’ve got Taufeeq Umar here as well as Butt and I think we’ll play it by the book - six batsmen, a wicketkeeper and four bowlers.”
Reading between the lines, that suggests a certain dissatisfaction with the performance of Pakistan’s all-rounders, Afridi and Abdul Razzaq, neither of whom distinguished himself at Old Trafford. It may be that the medium-pacer, Shahid Nazir, comes in for this game as a support seamer.
The key to the Pakistan performance, as always, will lie in their middle order. With Younis Khan, Mohammad Yousuf and Inzamam-ul-Haq all ranked among the world’s top 10, this is an engine-room with enough combined horsepower to shunt England backwards.
“If we’re to have any chance of winning the series, the first day of this Test is a very big day for us,” Woolmer said.
“We can bounce back, we have a reputation for doing that, and the team are very determined. The boys were stung badly by the last performance.”
Even a draw would not be the worst result for Pakistan, who are hopeful of having their fast-bowling pair of Shoaib Akhtar and Mohammad Asif back in harness for the final Test.
Asif got through an eight-over fitness test on Wednesday without pain; if he emerges unscathed from yesterday’s workout, he will fly in to play against West Indies A next weekend.
SOURCE: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.jhtml?xml=/sport/2006/08/04/scpaks04.xml
I actually won’t mind playing afridi as an opener in place of Butt. I am not suggesting him as an opener in test matches for future but only in this current crises.