Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

Please go through this article. This neo-orientalist women has though that she has proven what no one else has been able to prove through her book, Hagarsim-The making of Islam. Anyone who has read the book can put us wise what she says and how she concludes what she says.

Anyone knowing about a copy of Quran being dug in Sinaa with overwriting and different text than the current one. i never heard the story which is cited here in the article. comment please but rational and scholarly not emotional as we need to fight this fitnah on rational grounds not emotional grounds.

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

^
There was already a thread on this a while back...do a search on the author's name.

As I mentioned before, the author seems to have back tracked from the rather absurd position they maintained in the book...

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

Yes, i know that though not announced but the author had backtracked. my question was about the Quran being dug up in sinaa which has been claimed to be the oldest copy of quran and different than the present version. does any one know about it?

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

Never heard of it.

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

Screw her, Islam is taking over as it is already.

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

I think one should read the article by Javed Ghamidi regarding "Different Recitations of Qur'an" and he proves that there is only one and only one recitation which prophet Muhammad taught to Sahaba. He also gives opinions from top traditional judicial authorities in Islamic history. The article can be accessed from renaissance.com.pk/JanQur2y7.htm and see under "Variant Readings". Cheers!

Re: Orientalists new attack against Quran-They think they have a proof that it is changed

Waste of time reading something by Javed Ghamzi
Its like asking goldsmith for medicine.