One interesting Phenomena..

Not something important, but just thinking about the most of so-called devine religions( about one God, prophets and books). One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

Jews opposed jesus but confirmed all previous prophets, christians did the same. and Muslims also oppose any new claim for prophethood.

Re: One interesting Phenomena..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Code_Red: *
Not something important, but just thinking about the most of so-called devine religions( about one God, prophets and books). One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

Jews opposed jesus but confirmed all previous prophets, christians did the same. and Muslims also oppose any new claim for prophethood.
[/QUOTE]

how about reformers or who intrepret the religen according to
present realities .

Re: One interesting Phenomena..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Code_Red: *
Not something important, but just thinking about the most of so-called devine religions( about one God, prophets and books). One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

Jews opposed jesus but confirmed all previous prophets, christians did the same. and Muslims also oppose any new claim for prophethood.
[/QUOTE]

The statement above is not entirely correct.

Re: One interesting Phenomena..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Code_Red: *
Not something important, but just thinking about the most of so-called devine religions( about one God, prophets and books). One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

Jews opposed jesus but confirmed all previous prophets, christians did the same. and Muslims also oppose any new claim for prophethood.
[/QUOTE]
Jews and Chrisitians opposed the prophet and Muslims oppose any new prophet but it is not the same.

Jews and Christians were already told in their books about the last prophet and they still denied his prophethood, whereas, muslims are told that there is no prophet after Muhammad (SAW) and that is the light of Belief which make them oppose any other (false) prophet.

So, basically Jews and chrisitians went against their own divine teaching while Muslims never go against it.

Re: One interesting Phenomena..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Code_Red: *
Not something important, but just thinking about the most of so-called devine religions( about one God, prophets and books). One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

Jews opposed jesus but confirmed all previous prophets, christians did the same. and Muslims also oppose any new claim for prophethood.
[/QUOTE]

Wrong. Jews are still waiting for the next prophet (the messiah, or Al-Masih in arabic).

They merely believe that neither Hazrat Isa (pbuh) nor Mazrat Mohammed (pbuh) are the messiah.

Jews believed in Moosa (as) and hundreds of other prophets who came after him including dawwod, suleyman, uzair, zakariya, yahya (alayhum assalam) etc etc....

christians have been told to expect a prophet after jesus (as) and many christians did await him until muhammad (saw) came and most of them accepted his prophethood....

muhammad (saw) has already declared that no prophet wud follow him hence muslims can by no means be expected to believe in any claim of prophethood by anyone....

so, all in all, a very pointless argument put up by u....

Munni I dont need to be entirely correct. Nor i can be :slight_smile:

I am not talking about their belief or what they should have done, but a general trend of believing in past and refuting any future devine commandments and messengers

Well anothor interesting point. Followers of all these religions are/were waiting for some massiah/maseeh. And more interesting that followers of these religion, never accepted any claim of any person to be promised maseeh.

They were 100% sure of their prophethood. They are waiting for the one who will be the king of the world. I think jews had so many prophets that they were not inclined to entertain some claim of mere prophethood. They want some mighty ruler.

Christians are waiting for Armagadon and some kind of massiah as well.
Muslims are also waiting for Hazrat Esa :as: and imam mehdi.

Suppose if hazrat imam mehdi apear (in near furture ) will I accept him ?
As i am ( and most of the educated muslims are) skeptical enough. And we are not at high level of emaan as well.

Re: One interesting Phenomena..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Code_Red: *
One thing is common. Followers of all these religions wholeheartedly believe in the teaching of past prophet and furiously oppose and reject teachings of any prophet(s) of future that may come.

[/QUOTE]

simple human nature.nobody likes to lose his/her uniqueness(not sure of this word) and imagine losing that belief which gives u identity.nothing more than ego.

Re: Re: One interesting Phenomena..

You are absolutly right here :k:

Reformers were always present.. but not very popular.

If some part of Taj mehel is destroyed then, people would like it to be repaired in orignal shape using the latest material available.

Reformers mostly try to change the sturcture.

We let Ahmedi believe in what they feel appropriate for their way of life.

We let christians and jew believe in what they have chosen for them for their way of life.

But muslims believe that prophet mohammed was the last prophet of GOD.

Since I know for sure that I am not GOD and all those in which I have faith as pious companions would be like all of us present on the day of judgement waiting to know their NAMAEY AAMAL like every one in the world. I would restrain in saying others are doing wrong or believing in wrongly. Who knows?

GOD almighty has fixed just one day of judgement.

Please be scared saying that he has announced through some one jannat for this or that person(S) all lies concocted stories. Because it is GOD"S decision to keep one day of judgement. So it is in main principle of GOD.Not believing in one day of judgement leads us to be non muslims. So none of us knows in real sense what would be the fate of our moullas, whose we(majority of muslims) are indirectly followers.

We know about our 124,000 prophets only but no one elses fate we know.

We only know what our moullas have given us through ahadeez. We have Quran but we do not even try to receive approval to our ahadeez through quran. If some hadeez does not matches with Quranic verses. We start engaging ourselves in different universities to do reseach on Grammar of arabic language until we succeed in fixing our loved hadeez match with Quran. So what can I say? Walla hou aalum Bis souwab. Bye sokoon