Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

Society Religion & Philosophy
1

Can Asr prayer be offered as qaza if missed to be prayed on proper time? I heard some people say that Asr prayer cannot be performed as qaza. Is it true?

2

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

yes, it can be offered after maGhrib... qazaa is due for any farz namaaz that you miss.

3

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

Is it okay to offer Asr prayer as qaza after offering Isha prayer?

4

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza


i believe yes you can but qaza should be done as quickly as possible...asr is NOT qaza until 5-10 minutes before sunset...so if you miss that then the earliest time is AFTER maGhrib because maGhrib prayer has precedence over qaza asr. is it clear now? :)

5

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

Yes! :slight_smile: :jazak:

6

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

If you missed asar prayer you should offered it before maghrib namaz, means when you offer maghrib namaz before it you offer 4 rakat farz (qaza) of asar namaz then offer maghrib rakats.

7

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza


maGhrib has precedence over qaza asr because it's time for maGrib...jis namaaz kaa waqt hotaa hai uskaa Haq qaza namaaz se ziyaada hotaa hai is liye maGhrib kii namaaz ke ba'd hii asr qazaa paRh sakte haiN.

8

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

main bhi aisa samjhti thi pehlay par mainy ek book main parha hy is liya kah rahi hon.

9

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza


achchhaa...kis fiqh kii kitaba hai...kuchh bataa saktii haiN?

10

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

ji ahl -e - sunnat ki book hy main book ka name bata dongi.

11

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza


ok, sure! thank you! :)

12

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

mujhy us din yaad nahi arha tha ky mainy kis book main parha hy,
Bhashti zewar, written by Hazrat Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi (R.A)

13

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza


hmmm...interesting!...to kia aap bataa saktii haiN k mausoof ne apnii kitaab 'Bihishtii zevar' meN kia likhaa hai? aksar samajhne kaa bhii ulaT pher ho jaataa hai...'ibaarat kaa siyaaq o sibaaq kaa bhii Khayaal rakhnaa paRtaa hai...mere nazdeek to maGhrib kii namaaz 'asr kii qaza namaaz se awwaliyat rakhtii hai...it makes sense too kiuN k maGhrib kaa waqt kam hotaa hai aur usko delay karnaa munaasib nahiiN...maGhrib kii namaaz sooraj ke Ghuroob hote hii due ho jaatii hai. Khair...muKhtalif fiqh meN iKhtilaaf ho saktaa hai jiskaa mujeh ilm nahiiN. thankoo

14

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

From my understanding, one can pray Qaza whenever one wants to (except time when one should avoid Salah). That means, one can pray Qaza of Asr during Maghrib time, before or after Maghrib Salah.

Anyhow, if situation is that praying Qaza would make one miss Maghrib or miss Maghrib Jamaat, than praying Maghrib would have precedence over Qaza.

Else, there is no precedence in order of performing Salah (be they Sunnah, Nafil or Qiza), other than that one should do his best to perform farz salah on time.

As for not praying Qaza of Asr, I believe you may have read in book that if one have to pray Qaza of Asr then they should not pray Qaza after end of Asr time (makruh time). Probably writer of the book may have mentioned that in such way that it caused confusion.

Thus, right thing to say is that, one should not pray Asr Qaza at time just after end of Asr time and just before start of Maghrib time (as time between these two times is Makruh time for Salah ... and one should avoid Salah during Makruh time), but it does not mean Qaza of Asr cannot or should not be prayed at any other time.

Actually, even though not preferred still current Asr prayer can be prayed during this Makruh time too, if Asr of that day got delayed for some valid reason.

15

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

^ If some one is *sahib e tarteeb *i-e do not have any other namaz qaza then one should offer asr first and then maghrib. This is what scholars say.

However if time for current salat is short then one should offer current salat first.

Please confirm from some scholar as well.

16

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

^^^ Weather one is Sahib-e-Tarteeb or not ... according to what I know:

A person should not pray Qaza-e-Asr during Maghrib time if Maghrib time left is short and praying Qaza would make Maghrib Salah Qaza too.

Similarly, even if one can pray Qaza-e-Asr and could still pray his Maghrib within time, then also one should not pray Qaza-e-Asr before Maghrib if that would make him miss Maghrib in Jamaat.

17

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

asal main bhishti zewar jo hy wo for women hy us main sirf aurton ky masail mention hain, mardon ko namza jamat ky sath parhni hoti hy to wo to pehly maghrib ki namaz hi parhaingy kyunk waqt kam hota hy,par aurtain ghr main namaz parhti hain to un ky liya yeh masla nahi ky pehly asar ki kaza parhain phr maghrib.
Hazrat Ashraf Ali Thanwi (R.A) wo 19th century ky mujaddid hain, mujhy mujaddid ky bary main itni information nahi par sayad mujaddid ek century ka ek hi hota hy.

unki yeh book yahan hamari country main bohat parhi jati hy well known book hy ap bhi sayad janty hon,,, unhon ny jo bhi likha hy bohat detail main or bohat sahi likha hy kaza namazon ky bary main bht detail main hy or bht easy language main hy koi bhi parh or samjh sakta hy.
or haan sirf maghrib hi nahi hr namaz is hi trhan parhni chahya agr zuhar ki qaza hogai to wo asar ki namaz sy phly parhni chahya phr asar ki farz parhain haan agr waqt itna nahi ky apki asar ki ya koi bhi namaz qaza hojany ka imkan hy tab pehly us waqt ki namaz parhain phr qaza.

18

Re: Offering Asr prayer as Qaza

Peace All,

we should made our mind like that when we hear 'Haiyalal Salah' & 'Haiyalal Falah' then we stop what we are doing and offer the namaaz without any further delay. I heard when a Sahabi missed the 'Takhbir' to us pr aik 'ghash' tari ho jata tha. Its very common among us to miss a prayer, b'coz we are relax and know that we can offer that missed namaaz by qaza.