Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

Reproducing a letter to the editor (Dawn)
http://www.dawn.com/2007/09/18/letted.htm#8

+++++++++++++++++
Observations about Muslims

I HAVE felt, reading letters in these columns there is always a concern how the Muslims in India go through. I am sure they have genuine concerns of what their aspirations are and what fears do they live in.

My profession as a paediatrician, catering, for over 10 years, to an area that has a sizable Muslim population, I have the honour to closely interact with them.

These are my observations:

a. They are simple folks, God-fearing, amenable to suggestions if it falls within the tenets of the Holy Book.

b. They have generalised opinions of what is going on in this world, based more on what is told to them than processing the information themselves. This would cover anything from Palestine to Iraq.

c. They would rarely enter into a discussion over Kashmir. If they do, they want it to be with India. Remove the fear of having an independent opinion from this, because they are my good friends.

d. It seems to be a society that moves in small interactive whirlpools. It seems to be churned like the synchronised wheels of a clock. The local mullah churns some part of the society and, on the other hand, the daily rigours of life churn the other wheels.

e. Getting an education is a priority, be it in government schools.

f. Economically, they seem to be getting better off, than say five years back.

g. They have a soft corner for Pakistan. It is not the way some Hindu organisations percieve. It is like a phantom pain. I know of an old gentleman who died of a heart attack, when India lost an ODI.

h. The number of children in a family is slowly getting to three, at least in the families I know.

i. Muslim women are getting more enlightened and free. They understand that the future of their children lies in good education.

j. The economic threads between Hindus and Muslims are strongly interwoven. Over a period of time I have seen that the jobs that are education-based are being taken by young Muslim boys. Many medical representatives, smartly dressed, confident are young Muslim boys.

DR VIMAL RAINA
New Delhi.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

key to growth and betterment of entire community…education, education and education.
**

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

I have many muslim friends from india.
I think what this letter says, is not very far from truth.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

I always wanted to know how it was for Muslims in India as a minority religious group and how life is for them. Thanks for posting this.
you're right in that once that word "education" is given the importance it should get then the diversity in religion and subcultures in India would be such a treat to be around. Now with all the extremist Hindu-extremist Muslim riots i'm sure everybody there is jumpy and apprehensive some times.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

muslims will never excel in indai..until they wil demand a seperate land for them..its the only solution left for them...

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

And you are such fool to advise them such a foolish thing.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

Muslims are so much dispersed all over India that nowhere they are in majority. How can they do it?

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^ :hehe:

Khocha phir se shoro karey ga

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^^ sir....its the only solution left...also wil happen in Ghazva hind..why not today...:D

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^ yeh ju pehley eik mulk bana ke rakha howa hai india ke musalmano ne… pehley isko tu thikaney laga do poori tarha :rolleyes:

your demand sounds absurd specially looking at the dismal state of affairs of this country.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^Bus kar codey, bachay ki jaan lay ga kiya.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^^ :omg: good one

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

devine-light: the south Indian muslims are very much integrated in India, and there has always been peaceful co existance..

Parts effected by the violence during Partition did divide people, but time is the best healer, and with the new generation of educated muslims. The future is looking good for secularism in India.

D-L : Apne zamin to sambhal naihe sakte, chale hain dosron ki zamin ko torne - pehley sambhalo Balochistan, Waziristan or Pakhtoonistan.

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

^^ haha..what a joke....

what is happening here ..in india dharti matta..a super power...:D

  • kashmiries
  • naga land
  • tamil nadu
  • Mani pur
  • West Bengal
  • Tri pura
  • Chatees Garh
  • Assam

Re: Observation about Muslims in India - Letter to Dawn

Correct brother,Why the hell can't India be as Stable and progressive as Pakistan.
Everyday there is talk of the Supreme court of India's decision whether its President can run for elections in Uniform.
The only thing good with India is that it has Pakistan as its neighbour,so that India knows what exactly a country should not be doing.