Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Pakistanis knew where bin Ladin was. www.nbcnews.com/news/world/pakistanis-knew-where-bin-laden-was-say-us-sources-n357306
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Pakistan is just a puppet of Saudi..Saudi is the driving force for the chaos in the entire region..hur ganda kaam hota hai in both nations but both have nerve to call themselves Islamic..sorry to say but absolutely nothing islamic about these 2 governments
In either version of the story that pakistani doctor who was doing humanitarian work got screwed
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
The official accounts are very shady. This version makes a LITTLE more sense than the official accounts given by US and Pakistani governments, but still many holes in this story as well.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I wouldnt be surprised if Musharraf the guy who created and used MMA to scare the Americans (to prolong his rule) brought Osama to Abbotabad for the same purpose.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I wouldnt be surprised if Musharraf the guy who created and used MMA to scare the Americans (to prolong his rule) brought Osama to Abbotabad for the same purpose.
These things are not very difficult to investigate, if the government is willing.
The unwillingness on Pakistan's part to investigate gives a pretty good idea that a lot of murky stuff is going on.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I am sorry but you are a total ..... This was Sindh which voted for Muslim League Mine & Your Punjab didn't vote for Muslim League As per our tradition to follow the powerful Our elders voted for Unionist Party.....
In your hate, you like to twist a lot of facts.
If you are talking about 1936 elections, then Unionist Party was very much similar to Muslim League. ML had its own fair share of landed gentry and Sirs. The only difference being that Unionist party was more secular. However, In the same elections, Muslim League did not win a single seat in Sindh.
If you are talking about 1946 elections, then ML did win substantial number of seats in Punjab, even though it wasn't a Muslim majority area and Unionist party did not win much.
I get your hate for military, but Punjabis have never voted for ethnicity. ZAB and Benazir received a lot of support from Punjab. If Punjabis were generally racist, that wouldn't have happened. I cannot say the same for a Punjabi getting support from Sindh.
If you like to be racist, it is your choice but please do not always present BS as facts.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Remember it was a reply to an anti Pakistan post
and making government of Unionist party is a truth and Punjab assembly never voted for Pakistan perhaps
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Altaf Hussain says Pakistan should never have been created, PPP walas say how Pakistan should have never created. What's the difference? Why is it only people from Sindh that are so against creation of Pakistan? That just shows how much they actually care about the country that desperate bouts of ethnic hatred is enough to discard the creation of the whole country they pretend to care about. Sickening.
exactly. actually feudal lords are making people so. they create ethnic hatred among their people so their corruption can be neglected. ajrak baqi rehna chaheay roti kaprra aur makaan ya insaan ho na ho. lolzz.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I am sorry but you are a total ..... This was Sindh which voted for Muslim League Mine & Your Punjab didn't vote for Muslim League As per our tradition to follow the powerful Our elders voted for Unionist Party It was Sindh assembly which passed first resolution for Pakistan Karachi was the first Capital of Pakistan Bahawalpur bearded the all primarily expenses of new state including paying salaries What we did with Sindh and Bahawalpur What we did with East Pakistan , Sarhad , Baluchistan and with Sarailki belt Just looting , cheating and killing Still blaming others !
absolutely corrupt people talk about rights of others is non-sense. you are just making people fools so people of sindh cannot see the corruption of your leaders. Your so-call struggle for people of baluchistan is complete hypocrisy because you have been exploiting your own people of Sindh. munafiqat ki intehaa hai.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I am not talking about Sindh only , I represent Pakistan . Difference is only this that I differ to my heritage , The mind set
This type of mindset
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
LET’S COME BACK TO TOPIC
White House rebuts claim Pakistan role in Laden raid
http://i1.tribune.com.pk/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/884616-osamabinladenreuters-1431364048-865-160x120.jpgAFP
Seymour Hersh claims Pakistan’s security agencies not only knew about raid but had been holdin*g bin Laden since 2006
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
.....and making government of Unionist party is a truth and Punjab assembly never voted for Pakistan perhaps
Remember, Punjab at that time and Punjab after partition were very different provinces. More than half of it was Hindu majority areas. They could not get a vote in favor of Pakistan passed even if they tried.
Also, remember that Sindh voted for Sind United Party which was same in ideals as Unionist party. Also, remember that Muslim League did not win a single seat in Sindh in those elections.
Please, do not twist historical facts for your convenience.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I REQUESTED TO COME BACK ON IMPORTANT TOPIC , BUT YOU ARE ASLI PUT PUNJAB DA
See this and stop fakes now
[TABLE=“class: wikitable”]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Province[/TH]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Congress[/TH]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Muslim League[/TH]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Other parties[/TH]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Independents[/TH]
[TH=“bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center”]Total[/TH]
Assam
58
31
Europeans 9
Others 3
7
108
Bengal
86
113
Europeans 25
Others 12
14
250
Bihar
98
34
8
12
152
Bombay
125
30
2
18
175
Central Provinces
92
13
7
112
Madras
165
79
Communist Party 2[SUP][9]](1946 Indian provincial elections - Wikipedia)[/SUP]
19
215
North West Frontier Province
30
17
2
1
50
Orissa
47
4
9
60
Punjab
51
73
Akalis 22
Unionist Party 20
9
175
Sind
18
27
10
4
60
United Provinces
153
54
7
14
228
Total
923
425
123
114
1585
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I REQUESTED TO COME BACK ON IMPORTANT TOPIC , BUT YOU ARE ASLI PUT PUNJAB DA See this and stop fakes now[TABLE="class: wikitable"]
[TH="bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"][/TH] [TH="bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"][/TH] [TH="bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"][/TH] [TH="bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"][/TH] [TH="bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"][/TH]
So, where is Unionist Party government in Punjab you are crying about?
And can't you see substantial seats for Muslim League even though Half of Punjab was Hindu majority?
And can't you see that Congress:Muslim League ratio of seats is same for Punjab and Sindh?
I REQUESTED YOU TO STOP LYING, BUT YOU CANNOT.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
So, where is Unionist Party government in Punjab you are crying about? And can't you see substantial seats for Muslim League even though Half of Punjab was Hindu majority? I REQUESTED YOU TO STOP LYING, BUT YOU CANNOT.
Now I can only laugh at mindset
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Now I can only laugh at mindset
Because you cannot back up your claims with facts.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
Because you cannot back up your claims with facts.
Tusi asli ho sir , Asi tay Jhelum par day aan , maaf kar dio
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
... I represent Pakistan....
Tusi asli ho sir , Asi tay Jhelum par day aan , maaf kar dio
It is good to sometimes think beyond ethnicity.
I can't even laugh at this mindset.
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
I am proud of being Pakistani and proudly represent Pakistan
not care any ethnicity even my own
Not care any danger or threat , A peaceful democratic Pakistan with equal rights to all is my dream
I hate anything else
Re: OBL was a prisoner of Pakistan Army : Seymour Hersh
“Knowledge of this operation was confined to a very small circle of senior US officials,” insisted Price.
“The President decided early on not to inform any other government, including the Pakistani government, which was not notified until after the raid had occurred.”
They are right , they didn’t tell the government (Zardari) but …